Left arrow Mur Lura

CONTRACTUAL OBLIGATIONS ACROSS THE EU – INVITATION FOR THE SUBMISSION OF COMMENTS

PR0280
Date Icon 26/02/2007

The Council of the European Union is currently discussing a draft Regulation entitled Regulation of the European Parliament and of the Council on the Law Applicable to Contractual Obligations (COM (2005) 650). The purpose of this proposal is not to harmonise the contract law of Member States, but it is intended to harmonise the choice of law rules on contracts. 

One might wonder what this choice of law rules on contract (or private international law) might be. To begin with, contractual obligations are those rights and obligations arising out of a written deed, a verbal agreement or a tacit agreement which has the legal effect of a written deed. The subject matter of a contract can vary greatly. Examples include sale of movables or immovables, employment, the giving of a service, carriage, franchising agreement etc.  

The matter may be complicated further when it involves nationals from different countries who might be involved in the contract. For example, a Maltese company enters into a contract with an English company to buy books for sale partly in Malta and partly in Italy. Which law would apply to problems that might arise in relation to this agreement? Would it be the law of the place where the agreement was concluded, the law of the place where the service is provided, or the law of the habitual residence of the service provider? If a court case ensues on this agreement, once it is established that the Maltese courts have jurisdiction on the case, the court must decide which law to apply. In the contract, the parties might have chosen the law that would apply to the contract if problems arise. However in the absence of such a specific choice, it is the court which has to decide on the applicable law and this in turn would affect the outcome of the case. The law which establishes which law to apply is called private international law. Each country has its own private international law or choice of law rules, so that for the same case with the same facts, the outcome might be different depending on the country where proceedings are instituted.  

This draft Regulation proposes to harmonise the conflict of law rules of the EU Member States with regard to contractual obligations. One can easily understand the importance of such harmonisation so that, whichever court is deciding a case, it will opt to apply the same set of conflict of law rules in order to establish which is the applicable law. 

The proposal deals with many different forms of contracts. Areas expressly mentioned in the text include contracts relating to sale of goods, provision of services, carriage of goods by whatever means, transport by whatever means, immovable property, intellectual property, financial markets and financial services providers, auctions, consumers, insurance, employment, contracts concluded by an agent, franchise agreements and distribution agreements. 

It is however important to note that the proposed Regulation is not limited to these areas, but it applies to all situations of conflict of law rules regarding contractual obligations, except for those areas expressly excluded from its scope. The proposal as it stands at the moment, excludes from the scope of the Regulation questions relating to status of natural persons, family relationships, matrimonial property regimes, succession, negotiable instruments, arbitration agreements, law of companies, trusts, evidence and procedure and precontractual liability.  

Having said all this, it is pertinent to point out that the proposed draft still recognises the right of the parties to choose the applicable law relevant to the particular contract between them. 

Persons wishing to have a look at the proposal can do so by accessing http://ec.europa.eu/prelex. The Ministry for Justice and Home Affairs would welcome comments on this proposal and persons wishing to make such comments should do so by sending an e-mail to euaffairs.mjha@gov.mt by not later than Wednesday 28th February 2007.

Ixxerja din l-istqarrija Icon socials Icon socials Icon socials Icon socials

Stqarrijiet Oħra:

PRESS RELEASE BY THE OFFICE OF THE SPEAKER  The Speaker of the House of Representatives Meets Ambassadors of Guatemala, Lebanon and Vietnam

PR261959en

PRESS RELEASE BY THE OFFICE OF THE SPEAKER The Speaker of the House of Rep...

STQARRIJA MILL-UFFIĊĊJU TAL-ISPEAKER  L-Ispeaker tal-Kamra tad-Deputati jiltaqa’ mal-Ambaxxaturi tal-Guatemala, il-Libanu u l-Vjetnam

PR261959

STQARRIJA MILL-UFFIĊĊJU TAL-ISPEAKER L-Ispeaker tal-Kamra tad-Deputati jil...

Aktar Stqarrijiet Right arrow