Left arrow Mur Lura

Speech by the Hon. Tonio Fenech, Parliamentary Secretary in the Ministry of Finance, during the Malta Institute of Management conference on Double Taxation – St. Julian’s  - 19 January 2007

PR0050
Date Icon 19/01/2007

Distinguished guests, ladies and gentlemen,         

It indeed a pleasure for me to welcome you all to this International Conference organised by the Malta Institute of Management. I am also honoured to be welcoming the distinguished experts who are taking part in today’s discussions on the recent developments in the field of Double Tax Treaties and the role of Treaty Models.

The evolving rationale of Double Tax Treaties           

Double tax treaties are viewed as beneficial economic instruments by most states conscious that cross border trade, commerce and investment can only foster and grow if businesses are allowed to transact with a degree of certainty, to the advantage of the individuals, partnerships or corporate entities, as well as of the partner states involved.  

Double Taxation treaties have played an integral role in the development of Malta’s economy since it became independent in 1964. In the first instance, these international agreements have allowed tax issues with partner countries to be clarified, international double taxation to be avoided, and fiscal evasion to be curtailed. On another level, and here our local context, they have helped Malta develop trade relations with other countries, assisted the flow of inward direct investment and served as an important platform for Maltese residents doing business in partner countries.  

As most other countries, Malta’s treaties have historically been based on the OECD Model Tax Convention, being the one that best encapsulates Malta’s strategic choices. Obviously when negotiating treaties adaptations have to be made to take account of local legislation. Depending on the nature of the circumstances, we have also made use of other models, particularly the UN Model. 

Malta today has 44 Double Taxation Treaties in force, 24 of these are with European Union Member States, while the rest are with OECD Member States and countries with emerging economies.  Another 10 treaties are currently in various stages of negotiation, including one with the United States which we hope to conclude in the near future.   

Successive Maltese Governments have all been very active in building up this treaty network to where it stands today, although the underlying economic rationale has shifted over the years to reflect the thrust of the country’s economic policies.  

In the post-independence years Malta’s drive was focused on the conclusion of treaties with its main trading partners, the principal reasons being the stimulation of foreign investment into a small island economy that was lacking in natural resources and relatively cut off from any market of considerable size. 

Given the various incentives that Malta granted investors so as to stimulate investment in its nascent economy, Malta’s treaty policy from the very outset also relied strongly on the negotiation of tax sparing provisions within its DTAs. These provisions ensured that the incentives provided under Maltese law would, as far as possible, have maximum effect and not result simply in shifting the tax take to the treaty partner upon the repatriation of profits to the investor’s home country. 

In pursuing this policy Malta was perhaps fortunate enough to make the most of the international economic climate prevailing at the time, where the expansionist strategies of advanced economies on the one hand fitted in well with the development strategies of “non-industrialised” countries on the other, thus encouraging its treaty partners to make certain concessions in the interest of home-grown businesses that were investing abroad. 

As more and more countries began to liberalise their economies and compete for foreign investment, the international economic context started changing. Countries that had traditionally been perceived as net capital exporters joined the investment fray and started adopting measures to attract capital in the reverse direction, mainly by reducing effective tax rates. As a consequence, double tax treaties became more commonplace. The total number of Double Tax Treaties world-wide, as recorded by UNCTAD, rose from just under 500 in 1990 to around 2,500 in 2004.  

As globalisation took root, the levels of foreign direct investment over the longer term continued to increase exponentially. Vast recipient economies such as China and India appeared on the scene, as the desire to offset the effects of foreign competition motivated industrialised countries to step up their outward investment drive. Although in recent years UNCTAD reports have also recorded a marked proliferation in the number of Double Tax Treaties signed between developing countries towards the late ‘90s.  It is also clear that Double Tax Treaties have come to be seen as an added tool in the inward investment promotion armoury of countries with an already developed and diversified economy. 

The increased impetus for the negotiation of treaties on Malta’s part over the last twenty years also reflects their growing appeal across the world. During these years Government policy has taken a wider perspective as tax treaties started being negotiated not just with important trading partners but also with emerging economies, with neighbouring countries and with other jurisdictions expected to become trading or diplomatic partners over time. In doing so Malta was also laying the ground for its own liberalization drive - further opening up its economy to international competition while ensuring it had a treaty infrastructure that would help it make headway in a globalised world. 

On a different front, as membership negotiations with the European Union intensified, Malta also increased its efforts to finalise tax treaties with the remaining members as well as prospective member states, in an endeavour to ensure that on accession it would have a complete range of treaties aimed at achieving effective double taxation relief in trade relations across the EU. Double tax treaties had thus also become a vital tool in Malta’s drive to increase the level of cross-border business not just in the export of goods, a market that was already open to Malta before accession, but also in services and capital movement, both of which were seen as the future growth areas both of the Maltese and of the pan-European economies. 

The perfect example would be the role double tax treaties have to play in Malta’s expanding financial services sector, at a time where various legislative initiatives are being implemented by the EU to increase the level of integration within the single market in financial services. 

Global trends and regional issues

This brings us to a number of topical issues that are of relevance to our discussion both from an international business perspective as well as from a national economic standpoint. 

I.  One trend that has been developing underlines the importance of having a responsible tax treaty strategy. Double tax treaties are of tremendous importance to businesses that have an international dimension.  Without them trade would be stifled and economies would likewise be affected.  The introduction of anti-treaty shopping articles in double tax treaties (pioneered by the United States) and the exchange of information between treaty partners are forcing substance into structures where perhaps a decade ago this would not have been an issue.  Because of the importance of treaties it is not only necessary to understand how they operate but also how they are interpreted. 

Much is likely to change in the field of double tax treaties, both in terms of interpretation and anti-avoidance. However, it is the exchange of information which is seen as the key to preventing the growth in money laundering (and by extension tax evasion). This is likely to become more heavily relied upon than in recent years. 

Since this seems to be the way things are going in the future, double tax strategies that encourage substance and transparency are likely to be the more successful in the long term.  

II.  A second important reality countries have to live with is the influence of regional economic conditions over bilateral double tax treaty arrangements.  For an EU Member State this practically boils down to the status of EU law vis-à-vis agreements reached with tax treaty partners on a bilateral basis. Since May 2004, EU Accession has meant that Malta recognises the supremacy of Community law. As I had the opportunity of highlighting at another conference last October, the issue of the extent to which EU law limits a member state’s freedom of negotiation of double tax treaties confronts Member States with a particularly interesting issue - the effect of EU law on the interpretation and application of treaties which have already been negotiated.  This issue presents us with a new challenge at such an important stage of our economic development.            

In principle, in the absence of harmonisation measures, member states remain at liberty to negotiate their double taxation treaties in line with their particular economic objectives and the legal framework which they agree upon with their respective treaty partners. However the ECJ has also made it clear that such freedom must be exercised in line with member states’ obligations under EU law.         

This has resulted in cases being brought in front of the ECJ dealing among others with issues of discrimination of Community citizens arising from the manner in which particular tax treaties have been drafted or interpreted. These cases demonstrate that despite the liberty which is apparently available to member states in respect of treaty negotiations, Community law has an important role to play even in such a sector, which traditionally was looked upon as being one which was as inherent to a country’s sovereignty as to enable member states to maintain unfettered rights therein.   

The consequences of a successful challenge in front of the ECJ is naturally not merely restricted to making appropriate changes to the future – something which in itself is not necessarily straightforward in a treaty context due to the bilateral nature thereof, and particularly when the treaty partner is not an EU member state. Typically it also has implications on a retrospective basis not merely in respect of the taxpayers involved in the particular case but also for other taxpayers who may rely on the principle set down by the ECJ in their relations with the tax authorities of their member state, even if such tax authorities were not involved in the particular case adjudged upon by the ECJ.

Indeed however, even in the absence of such legal challenges which could have important revenue implications for them, I am sure that all Member States want to ensure that they respect the commitments they subscribed to on their accession and that all their acts, whether in the domestic sphere or the international one, would be undertaken in full respect of their EU legal obligations. 

III. Another issue arises from an international environment that has become very sensitive towards the grant of direct tax incentives that are meant to attract business from other countries without allowing that incoming business to tap into the domestic market, or by doing so to a very limited extent.  Perhaps more than anything else, this is reflected in the discussions Malta has recently concluded with the EU Code of Conduct Group on Business Taxation.  

In the end the Bill that has just been introduced in Parliament will bring about changes that will allay the fears of our trading partners with regard to our international trading companies and companies with foreign income, without any adverse impact on the basic tenets of our tax system and fiscal policies. Despite the changes therefore, our tax system will continue to retain its efficiency both from a local and international perspective, and to encourage productive investment and entrepreneurship particularly in our SMEs.  

Malta in the EU, therefore, will continue to stand for the elimination of economic double taxation ensuring that business profits are never taxed twice – that is, first in the hands of the company and then in the hands of the shareholder. Just as importantly, preserving our imputation system also means that our double tax treaties remain unaffected, that any misconceptions regarding the harmfulness of our system have been dispelled, and that the system’s acceptability from an international standpoint remains unassailable. 

Conclusion

Ladies and Gentlemen, in the face of these international developments, the Maltese Government will continue in its endeavour to negotiate tax treaties with other jurisdictions making this a central plank of our increasingly sophisticated and diversified economy.   

It is therefore my pleasure to see more initiatives of this type providing a platform for discussion and debate on issues of vital interest to the development of our economy and to our general understanding of the challenges we are facing in the shrinking world of today’s global economy.

DOI – 19.01.2007   

Ixxerja din l-istqarrija Icon socials Icon socials Icon socials Icon socials

Stqarrijiet Oħra:

PRESS RELEASE BY THE MINISTRY FOR THE ECONOMY, TECHNOLOGY AND STRATEGIC PROJECTS  More than 20 digital gaming and esports companies showcase Malta’s Industry Growth at PLAYCON 2026

PR261958EN

PRESS RELEASE BY THE MINISTRY FOR THE ECONOMY, TECHNOLOGY AND STRATEGIC PRO...

STQARRIJA MILL-MINISTERU GĦALL-EKONOMIJA, IT-TEKNOLOĠIJA U PROĠETTI STRATEĠIĊI  L-istrateġija tal-2019 qed tħalli l-frott: aktar minn 20 kumpanija tal-logħob diġitali u l-esports irrappreżentati waqt il-ftuħ ta’ PLAYCON 2026

PR261958

STQARRIJA MILL-MINISTERU GĦALL-EKONOMIJA, IT-TEKNOLOĠIJA U PROĠETTI STRATEĠ...

Aktar Stqarrijiet Right arrow