SPEECH BY THE HON. TONIO FENECH, PARLIAMENTARY SECRETARY IN THE MINISTRY OF FINANCE, DURING THE FISCALIS SEMINAR “TAX TREATIES AND EC LAW” – FLORIANA – 5TH OCTOBER 2006
Distinguished guests
Ladies and Gentlemen
It is a pleasure for me to welcome you all to this Fiscalis Seminar entitled “Tax Treaties and EC Law” which is being held here in Malta over these next two days. It is a satisfaction for me to confirm the Maltese Government’s commitment to providing support to such EU-wide initiatives dealing with fiscal policy issues and the implications of EU legislation thereon. In this respect I am honoured to be welcoming all of you experts and senior tax administrators seeking to foster further discussion and debate on this subject.
Today’s seminar deals with a matter of great interest to Malta. Indeed, over the past years Malta has made effective use of double taxation treaties so as a means to ensure that residents carrying business activities outside Malta are not subject to undue tax burden as well as ensuring that foreign investors in Malta obtain effective double taxation relief.
Due to the need for a recognised model, Malta has made use of the OECD Model Convention as its main basis for such negotiations, but its status as a developing country for many years, also meant that it needed to borrow concepts from other suitable models, particularly the United Nations Model, in the drafting of such treaties.
Furthermore, given the various investment incentives that Malta used to grant investors so as to stimulate investment in one of the smallest nations in the world, with an insignificant domestic market, lacking any form of natural resources and situated at the periphery of Europe, Malta’s treaty policy included also the desirability of negotiating tax sparing provisions which would ensure that the incentives provided under Maltese law would not result simply in increasing the tax take of the other treaty partner on the investor repatriating his profits to his home country, thus materially eroding the effect of such incentives.
Despite the country’s limited resources the negotiation of such treaties was always given importance by successive Maltese Governments, particularly in respect of Malta’s main trading partners. The impetus for the negotiation of such treaties increased materially over the last twenty years when Government policy on this subject was extended to incorporate a more proactive approach, that is, one which seeks to negotiate tax treaties not just with important trading partners but also with emerging economies, with neighbouring countries and with other jurisdictions which could be expected to become trading or diplomatic partners in future.
As Malta started to intensify its efforts to join the European Union, it also increased its efforts to negotiate tax treaties with EU member states and prospective member states with which it did not yet have a treaty, in an endeavour to ensure that on accession or shortly thereafter, Malta would have a complete array of treaties with other member states aimed to achieve effective double taxation relief in trade relations involving Malta and any other Member State.
This is what has resulted in the negotiation of 55 comprehensive double taxation treaties, of which 44 are already in force. Presently the Ministry of Finance is carrying out detailed technical meetings with the US Treasury that will lead to a new Double Taxation Agreement with the United States in the near future. Moreover the Maltese Government intends to continue with its endeavour to negotiate tax treaties with other jurisdictions in future.
EU law is also a subject which is of material interest for Malta. Since May 2004, EU Accession has meant that Malta recognises the supremacy of Community law. However interest in the subject has been present in Malta for decades before, due to the importance which trade relations with EU Member States has had for a very long time before accession, and this interest increased as Malta closed in on EU membership. Material investment has therefore been made by the Government, the University of Malta, private industry and individual students in the teaching and learning of EU law; something which has been key to ensuring that Malta is well prepared for the legal implications of membership.
The subject being dealt with at this seminar is therefore of material interest for Malta because it deals with the inter-relationship between tax treaties and EU law. Of particular interest is the issue of the extent to which EU law limits a member state’s freedom of negotiation of double tax treaties. What is the effect of EU law even on the interpretation and application of treaties which have already been negotiated? These and similar issues are of great interest to a new member state such as Malta because they deal with some of the new challenges which have been posed by EU accession.
However such issues are not of interest merely for Malta but they should be of interest for all member states whether they are new member states or countries which have formed part of the EU for various years. Indeed double tax treaties are used on a universal basis as a tool for the relief of double taxation and for the curtailment of international tax avoidance and evasion. This has resulted in the negotiation of thousands of double taxation treaties worldwide and this pattern is expected to continue for the foreseeable future.
Every country’s tax treaty history, economic objectives and requirements from such treaties tend to be different from those of any other, which in itself demonstrates the versatility of such treaties which are nonetheless used by all these countries notwithstanding the somewhat different targets which each country endeavours to reach through their use.
Most treaties use the OECD Model as their basis, with influence also coming from the UN Model and with a number of other models (e.g. the US and the Dutch models) playing an important part in the negotiation of such treaties. Within the EU, except for a few exceptions, tax treaties exist between nearly all member states. The issue of how the negotiation of such treaties interrelates with EU law is therefore of great importance for all member states.
In principle, in the absence of harmonisation measures, member states remain at liberty to negotiate their double taxation treaties in line with their particular economic objectives and the legal framework which they agree upon with their respective treaty partners. However the ECJ has also made it clear that such freedom must be exercised in line with member states’ obligations under EU law.
This has resulted in cases being brought in front of the ECJ dealing among others with issues of discrimination of Community citizens arising from the manner in which particular tax treaties have been drafted or interpreted. These cases demonstrate that despite the liberty which is apparently available to member states in respect of treaty negotiations, Community law has an important role to play even in such a sector, which traditionally was looked upon as being one which was as inherent to a country’s sovereignty as to enable member states to maintain unfettered rights therein.
The consequences of a successful challenge in front of the ECJ is naturally not merely restricted to making appropriate changes to the future – something which in itself is not necessarily straightforward in a treaty context, due to the bilateral nature thereof, particularly when the treaty partner is not an EU member state. Typically it also has implications on a retrospective basis not merely in respect of the taxpayers involved in the particular case but also for other taxpayers who may rely on the principle set down by the ECJ in their relations with the tax authorities of their member state, even if such tax authorities were not involved in the particular case adjudged upon by the ECJ.
Indeed however, even in the absence of such legal challenges which could have important revenue implications for them, I am sure that all Member States want to ensure that they respect the commitments they subscribed to on their accession and that all their acts, whether in the domestic sphere or the international one, would be undertaken in full respect of their EU legal obligations.
Hence the importance of tax administrators and civil servants understanding better the relationship between domestic law, double tax treaties and EC law. Fostering such an understanding is important to assist attendees and their members of staff in formulating key principles which they need to bear in mind in the negotiation of double taxation treaties, principles which should also assist them in applying double taxation treaties in the light of EU law, as well as in ensuring that EU law is always given paramount consideration in drafting domestic legislation which is relevant to this sector.
The knowledge gained from such seminars also helps attendees to follow future developments in EU law and ECJ case-law with a broader mind-set and therefore to continue building on their knowledge and expertise on the subject. Given the extensive nature of the subject, we are sure that this seminar will be followed up by other Fiscalis seminars dealing with related subjects, but we hope that the Malta seminar will act as a pace setter in this respect and as a catalyst for the identification of other key issues which deserve further research, discussion and debate.
However, notwithstanding the extremely relevant subject which is being debated, the holding of this seminar is not just a matter of technical discussion. Indeed, an equally important aim of this seminar is to foster further contacts between members of fiscal administrations of different member states as well as the EU Commission. Such contacts are important not just in the context of the technical subject-matter which is being discussed here but even more importantly so as to promote personal relations that may be used for mutual benefit in terms of co-operation between different tax authorities in various sectors.
At this stage, I wish to extend a special word of welcome to the foreign participants in this seminar. Some of you may have already visited the Island in the past, whilst for others this may be their first visit. In any case, we are honoured to have you among us and our wish is that you will go home not just enriched by the technical content of this seminar and by the interrelationship with the other participants present here, but also impressed with the hospitality of the Maltese people, a millennial tradition of our country and people, as well as after having shared with us some of the key landmarks of our country and the historical monuments and buildings with which our country is blessed.
Therefore, at this stage, without further ado, I am pleased to declare this seminar open and on behalf of the Maltese Government I wish all participants a highly productive and fruitful seminar and for our foreign visitors, also a pleasant stay with us.
Other Press Releases:
PR261958EN
PRESS RELEASE BY THE MINISTRY FOR THE ECONOMY, TECHNOLOGY AND STRATEGIC PRO...
PR261958