OPENING SPEECH BY THE HON. TONIO FENECH, PARLIAMENTARY SECRETARY IN THE MINISTRY OF FINANCE AT THE ROUNDTABLE: ‘HOW CAN MALTESE NGOs MANAGE STRUCTURAL FUNDS PROJECTS’ – VALLETTA – THURSDAY, 3RD AUGUST 2006
Ladies and Gentlemen
Thank you for inviting me to discuss with you such an important issue, and more importantly for creating this opportunity to discuss the participation of Civil Society, particularly NGOs in the Structural Funds Programme for 2007 - 2013.
I note with interest the efforts being made by the Civil Society to access EU Funding, not just Structural Funds but also other Programmes and Initiatives where the potential for increased participation by Maltese organisations, Civil Society and others, is still largely untapped. In this regard I would like to take this opportunity to urge you to also dedicate your efforts in this direction in order to maximise all opportunities.
Focusing on the Structural Funds Programme for 2007-2013, as you are undoubtedly aware, Malta is at present in the process of submitting the formal programming documents to the European Commission and the discussions are expected to start immediately after the summer break. The focus right now is on getting these documents approved given that no project can be funded prior to the approval of such Programmes.
Therefore, this morning’s round table is in good timing to discuss the issues dealing with preparation of the pipe-line and participation opportunities. It is important that preparations, both from the public sector and the NGO sector to start in earnest so that once programmes are approved, projects can start implementation.
Allow me to make some comments and to reply to some of the issues and misconceptions that have been raised also in the press in the last couple of weeks. First of all, I would like to stress that Structural Funds were always open to the Civil Society. This was clearly stated in the calls for proposal launched in 2004 and in 2006. In fact Cabinet had approved a number of projects with the participation of Civil Society and I am informed that these projects are now underway. Moreover, a number of NGOs and other members of the Civil Society have applied and some have been successful under a number of other Programmes such as Interreg, Equal and the EEA/Norwegian Financial Mechanisms.
Another point that was made in the press is that NGOs were only given access to the Funds when there was a perceived risk of losing the funds. Here I am proud to say that not only has there not been a risk of losing ESF funds, but Malta was one of the first countries to reach its first N+2 commitments for 2006. Malta reached its end 2006 target of spends in November 2005 – i.e. 13 months ahead of schedule.
An issue is also being raised as to whether NGOs are en par with Government entities with competing for such projects: At this point I would like to point out that pre-financing is available from the national budget for all entities - civil society groups and public organisations – this is a risk which is being taken on by Government to facilitate such participation. The availability of pre-financing should not be taken for granted. It is available in very few Member States and is a very important tool because it means that the final beneficiary does not need to fork out the money (EU and national co-financing) in advance only to get reimbursed three months later when the EU pays. In most countries final beneficiaries need to take out a loan to pre-finance the project with the risk of not being funded if promised project outcomes are not achieved or financial procedures applied are found to be faulty.
A related issue which also seems to be a misconception relates to public procurement. It seems that people are under the impression that Government is asking NGOs to follow the public procurement regulations used for large infrastructural projects. Allow me to recall that the national public procurement regulations do not regulate only large public tenders but also the procurement of smaller items, services or other. One should always keep in mind that structural funds are public funds. NGO projects generally do not run into millions and therefore what Government is asking from such organisations is to follow the spirit of the public procurement regulations by say obtaining three quotations when procuring equipment or to publish a call at least in one or two local papers when contracting a service. Transparency is a principle of good governance irrespective of whether government regulations are applicable or not. These are, to our mind, the minimum steps one should take when using public funds.
These were points I thought I should clarify for the benefit of all present today. Now I will pass on to speak of the challenges that we, as Government, have encountered in the limited experience we have had so far.
Allow me to stress, ladies and gentlemen, that Government fully agrees with the principle of facilitating access to EU Funds – not just for Civil Society but for all organisations. In this regard l would like to point out that the experience has not been an easy one for anyone, however the results are now coming in and they are good results – both in terms of impact and also in terms of absorption.
This money is neither a blank chequenor charity. It comes at a cost and it has to serve a purpose, namely the attainment of the objectives of the Programme. I think we all agree on the purpose. The implementing provisions are key elements of successful absorption of Structural Funds. There are rules and regulations, both at EU and national level, that have to be followed by all project implementers and, unfortunately there are no short cuts. The Regulations do not exempt or allow for easier access or less bureaucracy for projects carried out by particular organisations nor do they recognise the proportionality principle on a project basis. Issues such as public procurement, transparency, competition, and sound financial management are cardinal principles for the implementation of Structural Funds and these must be followed by all final beneficiaries managing projects co-financed by public funds and the Structural Funds are public funds. Even in cases where the funds are co-financing less than 50% of the project, there is a need to maintain respect for the basic rules of sound financial management, competition and transparency – let alone when the public co-financing is 85% or higher.
A number of countries have been mentioned that operate simpler, lighter systems for small NGO projects (allow me to mention that small in this case will mean small – our information is that the thresholds recommended by the audit bodies is something in the range of LM 7,000 per grant and 1% of the overall programme). In principle we agree 100% with a less bureaucratic and speedier approach not just for NGOs but for all small projects and also for the private sector. We (and a number of other Member States) have been very vocal on this issue in the Council and we have proposed to the Commission to apply the proportionality principle for the small programmes. We managed to obtain a number of critical flexibility measures under the Council Conclusions of December 2005 (including a higher EU co-financing rate, an extension of the N+2 by one year for the first four years, retention of present system with regard to VAT – to mention the ones that are of primary interest to this audience). Unfortunately we did not manage to agree on the issue of proportionality. The Commission did not agree and insisted that risk is calculated not just on the basis of the total absolute amount of the programme (or project) but also on the rate of co-financing – i.e. the higher the co-financing, the higher the risk simply because there is less ”own money” in the equation. Moreover, on the issue of global grants and the lighter approach - our information is that these systems (two or three out of the twenty five Member States) are now under evaluation and it is not sure whether they will be continued because of pressures coming from audit bodies, national and EU, to apply the full mainstream controls and procedures.
Let me make myself clear, the intention of the Government is to ensure that the Funds are not just spent, but spent well so that they are not paid back. As most of you know or have heard, the levels of either de-commitments and/ or recoveries in the case of Structural Funds is not low in a number of Member States. During 2005 and 2006, the Malta system and some of the projects have been through a number of audits and controls. The system was found to be sound with many examples of good practice. Nevertheless, it had to be tightened in areas where we did try to adopt a lighter approach – e.g. in the case of aid schemes. This tightening is generally not the result of people wanting to be difficult but is recommended by controllers to ensure that funds are not paid back to Brussels.
Meanwhile, I would like to inform you that the Government is looking at a number of possibilities which would facilitate the access of Civil Society to the Funds, within, of course, the limitations of the relevant Regulations. I would like to take this opportunity to share these ideas with you later on today and to listen to your proposals through the discussions we will be having this morning; that I am sure will be very fruitful. I am confident that the measures being proposed by Government will go a long way in reaching our common objectives.
Thank you.
Stqarrijiet Oħra:
PR261958EN
PRESS RELEASE BY THE MINISTRY FOR THE ECONOMY, TECHNOLOGY AND STRATEGIC PRO...
PR261958