Speech by the Hon. Dolores Cristina, Minister for the Family and Social Solidarity, at the Business Breakfast on the Pension Reform organised by MediaToday – St Julian’s – 24th May 2006
Good morning Ladies and Gentlemen.
Two years ago, almost to the day, I was also a guest speaker at a Business Breakfast organised by the Malta Financial and Business Times. The subject then, just as it is today, was Pension Reform. At the time we were very much at the beginning of the Great Debate. Today we are looking at decisions which will form the framework for legislation intended to be approved by Cabinet and moved to Parliament before the end of the summer recess, as announced by the Prime Minister last March.
The current Government, in spite of other pressing matters, assumed its political responsibility and decided to tackle this particularly thorny issue. It found the political maturity to acknowledge the fact that it is one that needs to be addressed in the short term, the sooner the better.
Two years ago the question on the table was ‘Do we need a Pension Reform?’
Government’s unequivocal reply to this question was yes, a resounding yes. This conclusion has nothing to do with politics. It is a rational conclusion based on facts that are staring developed countries in the face throughout the world. It is simply a reading of the writing on the wall.
Shrinking birth-rates, an increased longevity of life, demographic changes that will impact not only on the adequacy and sustainability of pensions but also on the sustainability of our health services all come into the picture. For the pension reform cannot be viewed in isolation, not of the local economic situation nor of other impending reforms, most notably health services. As people live longer, the cost of public health will increase dramatically, when one considers that currently the mean cost of institutional health services of a person over 75 years of age is more than Lm 600 annually compared to approximately Lm 350 for a person who is 65 - 69 years old.
It could well be that in the future the health issue may indeed prove more difficult to deal with than that related to pensions.
It has, admittedly, been a long haul.
It is almost ten years down the line since first indicators pointed towards the need for a Pension Reform to ensure that future generations are guaranteed an adequate pension that will provide them with the income to enjoy a decent standard of living and to maintain the lifestyle to which they will have become accustomed during their working life.And, obviously, to ensure that the country will be able to sustain the expenditure incurred.
A quick walk down memory lane: allow me, in essence and very briefly, to revisit a scenario that has been depicted many times over.
The first major review of the current system was held in December 1997 by the then MCED. This report was followed by that of Watson Wyatt Ltd., an international firm of actuaries and consultants, who presented a report on pensions in Malta with recommendations for a future reform. The National Commission on Welfare Reform, set up in 1999, drew up an analysis of the Maltese pension situation based on the World Bank Model. The results of this analysis confirmed the concerns with regards to pensions funding as had been expressed in earlier reports. In November 2003 Government provided guidelines for the reform of the Pensions System, setting up a Pensions Working Group shortly afterwards.
The terms of reference given to this Working Group were to review all work previously carried out as from 1997, to review international trends on issues and solutions provided for pensions reform, and to identify challenges faced by Malta with a view to securing an adequate and sustainable pension system. Finally, the Working Group was to submit proposals and recommendations for Government’s consideration.
A White Paper was tabled in Parliament in November 2004, and throughout 2005 the Group continued to develop and substantiate the analysis made in the White Paper and the national discussions on the matter.
This was done through the carrying out of various studies, including an economic impact assessment, a social impact assessment, a public opinion survey and an actuarial study about the Second Pillar.
The Group carried out an extensive national consultation process, including 39 sessions with various stakeholders and 17 media participations.
The Group’s final report was presented to Government in June 2005, which report included 7 supplementary specific studies. Last October all these documents were made public with the aim of providing the widest possible range of information available and with a view to enhancing and strengthening the necessary dialogue on the matter. In March of this year the Prime Minister announced decisions which will form a framework for legislation for the proposed Pension Reform.
Irrespective of the political identity of the Government of the time, the conclusions reached by every technical study carried out since 1997 are all the same, whether carried out locally or by an international firm of repute such as Watson Wyatt or by a supranational organisation such as the World Bank: that is, unless reform is induced and sustainability of the social contract that a pension constitutes will be heavily jeopardised.
Studies carried out by the World Economic Forum have also shown that over the last quarter of a century the average retirement age in a number of developed countries has fallen, with women tending to retire at a younger age than men. And these are two factors that need to be considered in evaluating options for the future: the retirement age is increasing in two dimensions - people living longer and retiring earlier.
Feedback received from constituted bodies, from articles and letters in the press, in their majority, expressed the view that reform is necessary. Random surveys, however, show that respondents were not like-minded. Individual concerns, the fear of change, an insufficiency of simple and clear information, as well as negative perceptions in all probability account for this result. My Ministry was inundated with queries in March from current pensioners who were apprehensive that their status would be negatively affected, no matter how often it was repeated that current pensioners will not be affected adversely.
The involvement of youth organisations throughout the process was essential as this reform will directly affect youths. It was of great satisfaction to have various youth organisations participating very actively, not only with submissions but also in discussion processes. These included the University Students’ Council, the National Youth Council and the General Workers’ Union Youth Section. They are, after all, representatives of the cohort that will be most affected by the reform. As Professor Scicluna himself stated in the 2004 Breakfast meeting “…call in the young people, the Youth Federations ... and explain to them and listen to their views”.
‘Reform yes but with caution’ was an admonition that featured in a substantial amount of feedback. And, understandably so.
The Pensions’ Reform addresses three fundamental elements. Given the declining birth rates, the increasing elderly cohorts and the increasing life expectancy, the reform of the statutory retirement age is integral to the reform process.
Another element is the first pension. All along it has been stated that this is the critical element, based on the concept of solidarity. The guarantee of a National Minimum Pension underpins the need for reform. Critical here also is the increase in the Maximum Pension, which was set in 1981.
The third element will be the introduction of a supplementary pension system.
Adequacy will always remain the major challenge, adequacy in terms of wages earned by people working and ensuring that income from pensions does not fall behind wages earned.
It is primarily for this reason that Government is proposing a structured five - year review of the system which will act as a control lever and direct towards parametric reforms to maintain the level of adequacy of pensioners’ income.
Government has accepted the feedback received from the majority of stakeholders and interested parties and through its decisions has sought to broaden the contribution base and enlarge the pool of labour supply.
Very briefly, a run-through of the decisions:
Those persons, women or men, who have not attained the age of 55 by January 1st 2007 will witness the introduction of a gradual increase in retirement age whilst those persons aged 45 and under on the same date will retire upon reaching the age of 65. The first change will start in 2014. Persons who will be 55 by the beginning of January 2007 will not be affected by this gradual change and will therefore be able to retire at the age established at present.
Currently, women enjoy the option to retire at 60 or 61, with an estimated 80% of women in the public sector choosing to stay on until the age of 61. However, in the private sector the final decision belongs to the employer. In future the choice will be theirs throughout the labour market. After the age of 65, a person will be entitled to carry on working without a decrease in pension.
Government is conscious of, and sensitive to, the impact an increase in retirement age may have on workers in manual and other demanding jobs. In this sense, there is the mitigating measure which will minimise any negative impacts from increasing the retirement age from 61 to 65. Although early retirement is not to be encouraged, retirement between the age of 62 and 65 is possible. However, this will entail an adjustment to that person’s pensionable income.
Although raising the retirement age will increase the contribution base, it is possible that there will be a simultaneous adverse effect on the point of entry of employees into the labour market. In this respect, Government is committed to continuously generating new jobs with a view to ensuring that whilst soon-to-be pensioners are kept in employment, the younger generation continue to find employment.
Recent announcements of new job generation at Smart City, HSBC Call Centre and De La Rue among others will undoubtedly help to remove the possibility of adverse effects by the increase in retirement age with regards to job availability.
Whilst a survey carried out by the Working Group revealed that the overwhelming majority of respondents expected the raising of the statutory retirement age, this brought about mixed reactions, with the Malta Employers’ Association, the Chamber of Commerce expressing agreement while others disagreed.
The Youth Organisations were pretty laid back about it while the Pensioners’ Associations were also in agreement.
The main bone of contention remains those in demanding jobs. The question begs itself: How does one define a demanding job? Is a job that demands physical stamina any more demanding than the white collar job that could lead to burnout due to stress?
One comment that was received was that Health and Safety Regulations will demand an investment as far as health measures are concerned. By an extension of this concept, this could well be an investment for older workers.
The truth is that a mentality change is essential.
Should the need arise for early retirement for health reasons this remains possible in our Welfare system. Earlier this year my Ministry revamped legal provisions on Invalidity Pensions and there is now in place a Benefit Fraud and Investigations Directorate. This exercise was carried out to ensure that only deserving cases benefit from the country’s Social Security system at a time when circumstances dictate that they do so. This reform has already shown very positive results.
The second fundamental element of the Pensions Reform is the first pillar pension. This remains a crucial element of our pensions system and one which will ensure solidarity for all citizens. Government has addressed its measures at strengthening this pension and, for this reason, it has been decided that the Maximum Pensionable Income ceiling will be increased from the Lm 6750 established in 1981 to Lm 9000 over a period of time. Furthermore, this ceiling will continue to increase thereafter according to the rate of inflation or according to the decisions taken following the five year review of the pension system which will become an integral part of the new pensions system. If left untouched, our Two-Thirds Pension system, which is presently providing pensioners with a 52% replacement rate of their wages, will only provide 40% in 20 years time and less than 20% in 50 years time.
Government is committed to ensuring that the National Minimum Pension is guaranteed. Currently it is worked out at 4/5ths of the National Minimum Wage for a couple and at 2/3rds for any other person. It has been decided that this pension will be a reflection of the 60% of the National Median Income, with the result that it will be higher than that awarded to today’s pensioners.
The contribution period will also be revised and will gradually increase from the 30 years as established by current legislation to 40 years. The averaging period for the calculation of pensions will be based on the average income of the best 10 years of the last 20 years of one’s working life.
This brings employees in line with self-employed and as a measure will help towards eliminating any possible abusive practices whereby earnings are inflated during the last three years prior to retirement, through artificial promotions and inflated incomes.
The Government believes that Malta will benefit from the introduction of a supplementary pension system. This is the third very important element of reform and one which will ensure a better standard of living for our citizens. The intention has always been for the first pension to be directed towards adequacy while the second pension is directed towards an improved standard of living.
The questions were voluntary or mandatory, and at what quantum?
The Working Group’s original recommendation was in favour of an initially voluntary scheme with mandatory implementation looked into by not later than 2009 and an introduction of the mandatory system in 2010. The concern of the group centred around the fact that the introduction of a mandatory Second Pension system today would place additional pressure at a time when micro economic reform is essential in the country. The group then proposed a neutral introduction, neutral in the sense that a percentage or a part percentage of the NI paid by Class 1 contributors and by the self-employed would be hived off into a Second Pension Fund.
Since the Prime Minister’s Press Conference in March, the necessary studies to look into the possibility of introducing a mandatory Second Pension system have been ongoing. Such studies are necessary to ensure that additional burdens on both employers and employees are not introduced.
The introduction of a mandatory Second Pension scheme looks at a “when” and not at an “if”. Government’s official statement on this issue reads “…Government acknowledges that at present it would not be wise to increase financial burdens on employees and employers. Therefore, the possibility that part of the NI contribution be reserved for this supplementary pension scheme is being considered. If this is found to be financially feasible then this will be implemented for all. If not, the scheme will be introduced later on”.
It is obvious that there is an expectation for legislative developments in the area of private pension provision in the banking and insurance sectors, which are already offering long term savings and retirement plans.
Having said the above, Government is definitely not opposed to the introduction of a Third Pension on a voluntary basis as a complementary source of income after retirement.
A recent draft report presented to Government, in fact provides impact assessments of various types and makes recommendations.
The reform also looks at career breaks taken by parents to look after their children and at periods of study intended to further enhance education and training. Cost-benefit studies are being carried out to establish the period of ‘credits’ allowed to ensure that pension rights are not decreased by these ‘inactive years’ away from the labour market.
Women in particular, because of family commitments, fare badly in the pensions stakes. Women’s working lives pass through more phases than those of men for a variety of reasons, not least because they are contributing to society outside the recognised workforce. The ‘housewife brigade’ needs to be looked after in terms of pension schemes.
This holistic reform will definitely impact positively on the sustainability and adequacy of our future pensions. As I have already said adequacy in terms of wages earned by people working and ensuring that the pensions income does not fall behind the wages earned will always remain a challenge. It is precisely for this purpose that the structured review to be undertaken every five years has been announced. This review will allow the possibility of ensuring that the appropriate level of adequacy of our pension system is maintained.
Government has gone for what it considers to be ‘a workable suitable package’.
The consultation phase is still on. I look upon today as a further possibility to listen to your views and interventions on this subject.
Other Press Releases:
PR261958EN
PRESS RELEASE BY THE MINISTRY FOR THE ECONOMY, TECHNOLOGY AND STRATEGIC PRO...
PR261958