Summary of comments by the Ombudsman on the follow-up report on Malta (2003-2005) by the Commissioner for Human Rights of the Council of Europe
The Office of the Ombudsman was provided with the follow-up report on Malta (2003-2005) that made an assessment of progress achieved in the implementation of recommendations that were put forward by the Commissioner for Human Rights of the Council of Europe. The Office has submitted its comments on this report to the Maltese government authorities and is releasing a summary of these comments for general information.
_____________________________________________________________________
| In the past the Office | was instrumental on various occasions in focusing attention on the plight of irregular immigrants in Malta . The Ombudsman believes that the progress that was noticed in this field by a delegation from the Commissioner’s Office late in 2005 is also partly due to the implementation by the Maltese authorities of the recommendations that resulted from the Ombudsman’s work. |
| General | comments by the Ombudsman |
| While acknowledging | that the main thrust of the Commissioner’s report is on the observance of human rights of irregular immigrants and asylum seekers in Malta , the Ombudsman laments that little or no reference is made in this report to the country’s particular circumstances. These include the paucity of the human, financial and physical resources that Malta can allocate to ease this problem; its small size and its inability to withstand a large influx of immigrants; the social tensions that complete freedom of these people in a small country may give rise to; and the extent of the response by foreign governments to Malta’s request for assistance. |
| Since the huge influx | of irregular migrants and asylum seekers has reached saturation point and it appears unlikely that the problem will be solved at the point of departure, the Ombudsman expresses the hope of a growing international awareness in favour of solutions that will be found at the receiving end. |
| In particular the | Ombudsman refers to joint initiatives by EU Member States that acknowledge that Malta and other countries that are exposed to the immigration phenomenon should not alone bear the brunt of this humanitarian problem and that EU Member States should share this burden in proportion to the size of their territory and their economic strength. |
| Malta | ’s progress in implementing the Commissioner’s recommendations |
The need for a plan of action based on solidarity
| The Ombudsman points out that in the light of | requests so that the EU would assist in the solution of the crisis, one would have expected the Commissioner for Human Rights in his report to underline the need for a strategic plan that puts into practice the principle of solidarity. This plan would be based on concrete and effective measures that observe fundamental human rights within EU boundaries and also contribute towards a permanent solution by providing resettlement opportunities. |
| The Ombudsman also points out that it would have | been opportune for the Commissioner to stress Malta ’s limitations to handle on its own this humanitarian problem. The Ombudsman insists that the EU should recognize that frontier Member States, especially if small and indefensible, should not be left to face this problem alone and that the Union is duty bound to contribute towards the observance of human rights and to shoulder its share of this responsibility. |
| From a policy on irregular immigrants based on | compassion to a policy based on the rule of law |
| While subscribing to the view that the Government | should not shirk its responsibility to ensure the observance of fundamental human rights in its treatment of irregular immigrants and asylum seekers, the Ombudsman expresses concern that the Commissioner fails to appreciate that with the removal of reservations to the 1951 Convention and the enactment of the Refugees Act in 2000, Malta progressed from a policy based solely on compassion towards irregular immigrants to one based on the rule of law. |
| The Ombudsman asserts that the rule of law not | only gives rights but also imposes duties on the state as well as on irregular immigrants. On the one hand the state is bound to respect the fundamental human rights of each individual within its territory and in particular the right to freedom from degrading and inhuman treatment. The Ombudsman insists that fundamental rights are neither approximate nor relative and that their violation can neither be excused nor justified. |
| On the other hand, in this framework an irregular | immigrant who feels that his fundamental rights are being violated during his stay in Malta has every right to protest against any such violation with all the legal means at his disposal. At the same time, however, an irregular immigrant must realize that while in Malta the laws of the country are to be respected and that any person who violates the laws of the country has to answer for his actions. |
| The Ombudsman insists that until the competent | authorities grant an immigrant in Malta the status of a person seeking asylum, any such person has no right other than that of being treated as a human being and in conditions that respect his fundamental rights as an individual. Furthermore, no person has the right to enter a country of which he is not a citizen by irregular means and without proper identification since as a rule this is a criminal offence, punishable at law and sanctioned by forced repatriation to the country of origin. Besides, only irregular migrants who prove that they qualify for protection as bona fide asylum seekers should be granted this status. |
| The Ombudsman laments the fact that these basic | distinctions are not very evident in the Commissioner’s follow-up report. |
Detention policy
| Faced with problems caused by the sheer number of | migrants who find themselves in Malta , the Maltese authorities have resorted to the contested detention policy on which the major political parties in the country are in agreement. |
| The Ombudsman refers to the comment by the | Commissioner that “detention of asylum seekers should be warranted only in special circumstances and last as short as possible.” The Ombudsman points out that it is inconceivable for Malta to abandon the policy of detention completely and that it is the duty of the state to determine whether a refugee can usefully be integrated in Maltese society, even if temporarily. Despite problems to determine the identity of irregular immigrants, the Ombudsman appreciates that the state has the duty to limit the time of detention and to control the movements of irregular immigrants whose status is under consideration. |
| The Ombudsman expresses the view that under | acceptable conditions, detention for a reasonable time is in the interest of irregular immigrants. Giving these persons freedom of movement without any means of subsistence in a country that is totally alien to them, will place them in a difficult situation that could lead to further tragedy especially since it is widely known that the intention of most, if not all, irregular immigrants who find themselves in Malta is to reach the European mainland. As a result, as soon as they are freed from detention most immigrants try to leave the country and are likely to turn to criminal organizations that operate in the illegal transportation of immigrants to European shores. |
| The Ombudsman suggests that instead of insisting | on the discontinuance of the detention policy by the Maltese authorities, emphasis should be made on the need to ensure adequate living conditions in all detention centres. |
Conditions in detention centres
| The Ombudsman refers to the conclusion of the | Commissioner’s follow-up report that there are instances where detainees are kept in inhuman and degrading conditions and considers this conclusion as very disturbing. |
| Although despite well-known limitations the | Maltese authorities have improved the level of facilities and material comfort available to irregular immigrants, the Ombudsman agrees that remedial action is called for even though in turn it must be appreciated that Malta has been simply overcome by the magnitude of the problem. |
| Malta | lacks the financial, physical and human resources that are required for an effective solution and cannot cope single-handedly with the problem. As a result the country needs help from the other Member States of the European Union. In this regard the provision of specialised personnel who are able to communicate with irregular immigrants in their mother tongue, evaluate their needs and solve their problems is considered as a priority requirement. |
The process to define the status of immigrants
| The Ombudsman expresses agreement on the need to | hasten the process of defining status, to ensure a fair hearing while identifying immigrants who are entitled to the status of asylum seekers. The Ombudsman also supports the view that a proper appreciation of appeal tribunals is needed in their task to determine the rights of immigrants to seek asylum and that administrative decisions by these tribunals should be subject to fair and just scrutiny. |
| The current situation: a European and not | merely a Maltese problem |
| The Ombudsman takes note of the fact that although | the Commissioner for Human Rights remains critical of various shortcomings, it is accepted that in the circumstances the Maltese Government is doing its best. The Ombudsman, however, reiterates his view that this ought to be considered as a European and not merely as a Maltese problem and that the burden should be shared among EU Member States while expressing his firm hope that the international community will identify practical solutions that will be backed by tangible forms of assistance. |
| The | functioning of the justice system in Malta |
| The Ombudsman agrees with the Commissioner for | Human Rights that action to improve the effectiveness and speed of Maltese justice should not be at the expense of the basic rights of the individual. At the same time he shares the view that there is some cause for concern that attempts to simplify civil procedures could possibly be done at the expense of undermining the basic constitutional principle that the determination of civil rights and obligations should be done by an impartial and independent tribunal. |
| Referring civil disputes to compulsory arbitration | might not exactly fit in with this constitutional right. Similarly Small Claims and other tribunals might be considered not to completely satisfy the requisites of independence unless it is possible to appeal from their decisions, also on the merits, before a higher tribunal. |
| The Ombudsman does not agree with the Commissioner | that the solution to the core problem lies in the recruitment of more judges and magistrates and suggests that greater care be taken in their selection and that consideration be given to practical training programmes that prepare candidates for their future roles as judges and magistrates. |
| The Ombudsman agrees that the pensions of judges | and magistrates are at an unacceptable level. With regard to the claim that this could possibly jeopardize the independence of the Maltese legal system, the Ombudsman rebuts, however, that there is no proof that this situation, clearly in violation of the European Judges Charter, has actually jeopardized the independence of the Maltese judiciary although it is recognized that a potential threat exists. The Ombudsman agrees that this situation should be remedied because it is a serious deterrent to fill the vacant posts of judges and magistrates by the right persons. |
Stqarrijiet Oħra:
PR261956
STQARRIJA MILL-MINISTERU GĦALL-INKLUŻJONI U L-VOLONTARJAT U MILL-MINISTERU ...
PR261955en