STATEMENT BY THE HON. TONIO FENECH, PARLIAMENTARY SECRETARY IN THE MINISTRY OF FINANCE, AT THE EBRD CONSTITUENCY MEETING – VALLETTA - 26 – 27 JANUARY 2006
Governors, Ladies and Gentleman, good morning.
It is a pleasure welcoming you to Malta to attend this second interim meeting of our EBRD constituency. I take this opportunity to thank our special guest, the Secretary General of the EBRD Mr Horst Reichenbach for finding the time to come over and address this meeting notwithstanding his very busy schedule. Later in the morning it will also be my privilege to invite another guest speaker, Professor Bannister, Chairman of the Malta Financial Services Authority to make a presentation on the development of the financial services sector in Malta.
In saying a few words of introduction I would like to express my appreciation of the work of our Director and Alternate Director for keeping us constantly informed on developments at the EBRD, particularly the Bank’s policies and a number of important issues that affect the membership. The organisation of meetings such as this, also give us, as member countries, an opportunity to provide the Bank with some views on topical subjects that concern the Bank’s operations and activities.
In this regard I am convinced that the EBRD has gone a step ahead of other international financial institutions in enhancing its dialogue with, and accountability to, its shareholders. These constituency meetings are a typical example of the Bank’s efforts in this direction. They complement other measures that the Bank has taken to enhance its transparency with NGOs and civil society.
A constituency such as ours has brought together an interesting mix of countries. All have strong or growing links with European institutions particularly the European Union. Three members – Austria, Cyprus and Malta - are members of the EU. Bosnia and Herzegovina has continued to make progress in terms of the priorities identified in the Feasibility Study for a Stabilisation and Association Agreement (SAA) with the EU and has been granted potential candidate status. Israel and Kazakhstan offer a broader but very interesting dimension given their geographical location and their special relationship with the EU. The group as a whole has a variety of characteristics in terms of physical structure, culture, economic development, and, as you might have inferred, size.
Malta is the smallest country in the constituency, and measured against the vast economic size and financing needs of the countries of operations, its economy can only make a small direct contribution to the Bank’s resources. Yet it is a strong supporter of the EBRD and is committed wholeheartedly to the principles of the Bank particularly its endeavours to further transition in the countries of operations.
For example, it is an objective of my government to encourage Maltese investors to seek business opportunities in the countries of operation. At present Malta’s trade flows still remain concentrated among a few countries of operations and so there remains ample scope for developing commercial relations with countries in the region. It is our pleasure to note that Maltese companies that have ventured into the region have been successful and continued to grow. One particular company, for example, has established hotel operations in the Czech Republic, Hungary and Russia. In recent years we have also seen a growing interest among property developers and real estate agencies in certain countries of operations, most notably in Bulgaria, Croatia and Romania. Tourist flows between Malta and central and Eastern Europe have also increased. Although such activities typically make a modest contribution in terms of transition impact, these cultural exchanges tend to generate new interest in the products and services offered by these countries. Such exchanges also suggest that the local community is becoming more conscious of the economic potential of the region as a whole. Over time, this should engender enough confidence among the local business community to consider investing in other sectors of these economies.
In relation to our membership obligations I am happy to say that recently we completed the ratification process allowing Mongolia to become a country of operation of the EBRD. In a wider European context I am also pleased to declare that my Government continues to support current and potential EU candidates in the Western Balkans in their efforts to achieve EU member status. We note that in this regard important milestones were achieved in 2005. EU membership negotiations were opened with Croatia while the Former Yugoslav Republic of Macedonia was granted candidate status. The European Council also approved the start of negotiations for a Stabilisation and Association Agreement for Bosnia and Herzegovina and Serbia and Montenegro.
I am sure that these countries’ economic progress towards fully functioning market economies and the outstanding challenges towards that end will feature prominently in today’s meeting. The latest Progress Reports by the European Commission suggest that these countries have continued to make progress on both the economic and political front. In particular, conflict has ceded in many areas and most countries have taken steps to strengthen their relationship with neighbouring countries.
The prospect of EU membership will continue to provide the necessary impetus to the legal and economic reforms which are necessary for them to establish a stronger economic base and durable economic development. Each additional step that will be taken on the road towards EU accession will provide the international business community with an assurance that the region is indeed committed to a business-friendly environment and to break from past episodes of strife. The experience of the eight countries of operations that joined the EU and our own suggest that the process of gearing up for EU accession can indeed have a catalytic effect on reform. This finding has emerged in many editions of the Bank’s Transition Report and emerges again in the 2005 issue.
Whatever the type of relation with the EU, however, a country’s ability to persevere with sensitive reforms hinges crucially on attracting the right kind of investment. Success also requires that the flow of foreign investment is managed in a manner which takes into account the concerns of all members of civil society.
Yet, as many of the Bank’s shareholders have pointed out on various occasions, the extent of private investment, its form and destination are largely market-driven decisions, based on several considerations, ranging from the quality of the host country’s infrastructure, to the level of education and skills of the workforce and the presence or absence of unnecessary bureaucracy. While the majority of the countries of operations have once more delivered progress on many counts, the Transition Report suggests that there remains scope for improvement in all these countries.
This brings me to an important topic on the agenda – the geographical dimension of the Bank. A consensus has emerged in recent years, and this has been especially evident at the conclusion of last year’s Annual Meetings in Belgrade, that the Bank should shift its attention South and East, with a possible divestment in the countries that have joined the EU and other advanced reformers. There are however, a number of questions that remain unanswered. It is for example, not clear how international investors will interpret this move once it becomes more visible and, therefore, how the Bank’s divestiture should take place without destabilising the countries that will experience such disengagement. At the same time there are concerns that if the shift occurs too fast, the Bank might be exposed to a high concentration of risk. There are also differences of opinion regarding the considerations that should be brought into play to determine who, among the potential candidates, and, within countries, sectors, that should be the first to graduate from EBRD lending.
While one augurs that an increasing number of countries and sectors join the group of advanced reformers one cannot discount the implications which this could have in terms of the organisation of work within the EBRD and its liquidity needs as it shifts attention to countries of operation that face serious economic problems.
This brings me to the subject of the Bank’s resources. I am awarethat the Bank’s shareholders have generally been in favour of a budget increase along the lines proposed by the Bank’s management. Such an increase, which comes after eleven years of zero nominal growth, would place the Bank in a better position to do more where it is needed most, but of course different countries have their own views on whether the agreed increase is sufficient or not. They will also have views on whether its timing has been appropriate or not and on additional measures that could form part of the capital resources review to ensure that the Bank can achieve its objective of moving further South and East.
The discussion of the capital resources review which is the subject of Mr Reichenbach’s talk, could not have taken place at a time more opportune than this, because the results for the first nine months of 2005reveal a noticeable increase in the percentage of new investments undertaken by the Bank in early and intermediate reforming countries. These have risen from 49% in 2004 to 62% a year later, with most of the increase reflected in a corresponding decline in the proportion of new investment in the advanced reformers.
Our meeting here in Malta also takes place at a time when international oil prices seem to have resumed their upward trend. Recent disputes between Russia and its neighbours concerning gas supplies are also adding to security concerns in the energy sector. Whatever our dependency on these sources of energy, in one way or another our countries have all been affected by developments in their prices and their availability. High energy prices increase inflationary risks and expectations. They also affect the profitability of state utilities and private business, which in turn impinges on economic growth and fiscal balances.
At the same time, while this period has been one of windfall gains for oil exporters, it is often argued that oil exporters could deploy more of these additional financial resources to improve the efficiency of the energy sector. After all this is one of the most promising sectors in terms of transition impact due to its linkages with other economic sectors. We thus welcome the ongoing work within the EBRD to streamline the existing natural resources and energy operations policies into a single policy and to consult NGOs and other experts in this field. I am also aware that the EBRD is also playing a more active role in funding investment in renewable sources of energy. All members of the Bank will benefit from such measures, considering the important role which many countries of operations play as suppliers of energy products.
With these few points of reflection, I invite Mr Reichenbach to commence the meeting with his address on the important subject of capital resources which I am sure will stimulate active discussion. I look forward to a morning of interesting presentations which will not only contribute to fruitful debate and discussion but will also confirm the usefulness of such meetings organised by the constituency during the early part of the year.
Thank you all very much for your attention.
Other Press Releases:
PR261951
STQARRIJA MILL-UFFIĊĊJU TAL-PRIM MINISTRU “Meta nsaħħu l-MCAST inkunu qed ...
PR261950en