SPEECH BY THE HON. TONIO FENECH, PARLIAMENTARY SECRETARY IN THE MINISTRY OF FINANCE, AT THE INSTITUTE OF DIRECTORS CORPORATE GOVERNANCE SEMINAR – ATTARD – THURSDAY, 3RD NOVEMBER 2005
| Ladies | and Gentlemen, |
| It | is truly a pleasure to be delivering this speech at this conference at a time when talk of change, and spurring growth in our economy of heightened interest. |
| Let | me first of all congratulate the Institute of Directors for taking this initiative and for their unstinting effort in promoting good corporate practice in our islands. I also wish to thank them for presenting us with an opportunity to take a fresh look at corporate governance as a force for change during these very challenging times. |
| We | have already been very ably given an insight into the latest trends and developments in corporate governance and will no doubt be hearing more about the options we have before us in the course of the morning. I will therefore restrict myself to outlining some of the challenges we are facing as a country and share some thoughts with you as to why I believe that good corporate governance can play a direct role in also spurring change and the general well being of our economy. |
| As | market efficiency forces itself across the globe, irrespective of frontiers and border controls, we are realising that technology is continually expanding the possibilities for overseas trading and that there is no other way to survive except by learning to operate in an interdependent world. |
| Within | the local environment Corporate Governance is becoming all the more important. As the Prim Minister so clearly emphasised in last Monday's Budget Speech, Government is committed to continue with the more sensitive phase of the Government's privatisation programme, where possibly the more strategically sensitive state owned companies come into play. Also, it is this Government's clear intention to involve as much as possible the private sectors in delivering public sector services through public private partnerships initiatives. |
| However | who will operate our main telecom company, run the second largest bank on the island, operate our Valletta Port , and participate in the energy market, with liberalisation right at our doorstep? These are sensitive sectors, but as true to our belief that we as a Government should limit ourselves to facilitating and where necessary regulating rather then operating in the market, the companies that will run these businesses and operations must also have the right ingredients not merely in terms of access to innovation, markets and new opportunities, but also a sound basis of corporate governance and social responsibility. |
| This | is more so when services for public interest need to be acquired by Government either through public service obligation contracts from private operators or through public private partnerships, such as those recently issued involving the operations of the construction and operations Mellieha Elderly Home as well as the Catering Tender for the Mater Dei Hospital. |
| Another | important aspect that needs to be well analysed is how good corporate governance can positively affect economic performance and help us deal with change. |
| Although | corporate governance has been defined in many ways, it has been said to relate to the interaction of a company’s management, board directors and shareholders in the direction and control of a company so as to ensure that all financial stakeholders (shareholders and creditors) receive their fair share of the company’s earnings and assets. Such a definition rightly assumes that investors will choose which companies to invest in and companies will choose whom they do business with on the basis of their confidence in the company they are investing in or dealing with. Likewise financial intermediaries, stock exchanges, regulatory institutions and indeed the whole market economy depend on the integrity and credibility of operators at all levels in order to move forward. |
A much-quoted Mckinsey survey of investor perception indicates that, all other things being equal, investors are willing to pay more for a company that is well-governed and that the quality of corporate governance ranks alongside financial performance and other factors when deciding whether to invest in a company. It is amply clear therefore that capital will flow to stock exchanges, intermediaries and companies that abide by certain standards and shy away from operators that run shoddy organisations.
| The | statement holds true whether we are talking of domestic, cross-border or cross-continental, trade and investment. In an increasingly liberalised and interdependent world corporate and economic success is likely to depend more and more on such things as the ease with which companies can raise money in overseas as much as in domestic markets and the ease with which investors can profit from investment opportunities in an efficient global market. The lynchpin on which all this hinges would be the confidence investors’ show in a company wherever it may be provided it operates within a sound corporate governance framework and has sound governance practices in which they can place their trust. |
| Against | this background, good corporate governance should be a key driver in our strategy to boost market efficiency and business competitiveness - a rallying point around which the public and private sector must come together to ensure transparency, fairness and accountability with respect to shareholders and other investors who have placed, or can potentially place, their faith in our business. In short, the success of our business ventures and our economy depend directly on the certainty and trust that a good corporate governance framework can retain in the long term. Good corporate governance is perhaps the single most important factor that can facilitate access to external financing to help our businesses and our economy to grow. |
| All | of this, together with the concerns raised by recent corporate scandals, has triggered off an unprecedented transnational debate on corporate governance issues. At EU level we constantly find ourselves discussing issues related to the improvement of transparency on EU capital and securities markets; the encouragement of competent financial intermediaries and proper supervision of financial institutions; the development of sound internal control mechanisms and of effective external controls by auditors; shareholder control and management accountability, and the implementation of operation and financial risk management systems. |
| On | the local level these issues have been mirrored in numerous regulatory and other non-binding, (albeit pressure inducing) measures such as the requirement to file audited financial statements with the Companies Registry, the introduction of International Accounting Standards in 1997, the adoption of a Code of Corporate Governance for listed companies published by the Malta Stock Exchange in 2001, amendments to the Companies Act in 2002 (particularly the first ever inclusion of a statement on the general duties of company directors in our legislation), and the upcoming revised code of corporate governance being prepared by the MFSA, the discussion of which is about to be kick-started at this conference. |
| Without | pre-empting this discussion, I would like to draw attention to a number of serious challenges we are facing in the wake of recent international cases of failure in the corporate governance framework. Recent corporate scandals have in fact given rise to the suspicion that there is plenty of opportunity for mischief inside large public companies, especially where shareholders remain passive in the face of a concentration of control in the hands of powerful directors. As a consequence of this, much of the governance debate in countries with highly developed financial systems focuses on the balance of power between shareholders, boards and top executives in widely held public companies. |
| The | first challenge therefore is that of improving the integrity and accountability of company boards, in particular through a better definition of role, competence and responsibilities of board members and the exercise of delegated powers by top management. Good corporate practice related to the role of board members in ensuring that the interest of minority and non-controlling shareholders is protected and particularly the role independent members could play in all this need to be given careful consideration. Numerous other issues are linked to the balance of power within the company structure. On example lies in the board’s responsibility to hire, fire and remunerate top managers. For this reason, corporate insiders come with an inherent conflict of interest when they sit on boards, although this is a very common phenomenon among developed countries. Other issues one should seek to examine in this context also include the degree of external influence company stakeholders such as creditors exercise over the affairs of the company and the extent to which these stakeholders should have a say in the running of a company while at the same time safeguarding shareholder ownership rights. |
A second important challenge is to enhance the application of international auditing standards and to closely monitor developments at EU and international level in this respect.
Yet another challenge lies in ensuring that shareholders are indeed given a true and fair presentation of the financial situation of the company through sound and reliable accounting and that board members have the responsibility to see that financial reporting and control systems are functioning properly. One way of ensuring this is by continuing to build on the International Financial Reporting Standards framework in line with developments at European and international level.
A fourth challenge lies in the degree of institutional intervention we should use in promoting a good standard of corporate governance. As in most systems (with the exception of a few like the United States) we know that we are unable to rely completely on market mechanisms to enforce shareholders’ sovereignty. On the other hand, as things stand, our financial services watchdog is responsible for the scrutiny of providers of financial services – i.e. financial operators – and does not function as a supervisor of businesses in general. Our challenge therefore lies in maintaining a balance between having in place all the necessary legal mechanisms to ensure that good governance principles are followed and allowing as much flexibility as possible so as to ensure that business is not unduly shackled by controls and burdened by costs that are uncalled for.
It is above all in our interest as companies, administrators, financial intermediaries, and stakeholders in our economy, to ensure that in the end efficient and credible solutions are found to guarantee effective levels of investor protection and optimum levels of efficiency for our business. Maintaining a high level of confidence in our respective business while facing the realities of a changing business environment is a challenge we must all take up embrace.
I therefore wish you all a meaningful, informative and successful conference that would hopefully lead to further mature debate leading to a balanced and effective outcome.
Other Press Releases:
PR261949en
PRESS RELEASE BY THE MINISTRY FOR EUROPEAN FUNDS, SOCIAL DIALOGUE AND CONSU...
PR261949