ADDRESSING THE IMPACT OF INTERNATIONAL FUEL COSTS
| When Government | introduced the 17% Fuel Surcharge on water and electricity consumption on the 1st January 2005 , Enemalta was buying Fuel Oil and Gas Oil at Lm59.92 and at Lm133.32 per metric ton respectively (December 2004 prices). |
| Last month, Enemalta | paid Lm117.62 per metric ton of Fuel Oil and Lm215.87 per metric ton of Gas Oil. |
Chart 1 – Fuel Oil CIF Med. in Lm Prices Oct. 04 to Sept. 05
Chart 2 – Gas Oil CIF Med. Prices in Lm Oct. 04 to Sept. 05
| The 17% surcharge rate | had been calculated on the premise that oil prices for Enemalta would stay around the prices registered in November 2004. Notwithstanding the fact that these prices were exceeded every month between January and September 2005, the surcharge was not increased but was retained 17%. |
| The result of these | higher than expected fuel prices was that whilst the surcharge raised, as targeted, Lm7.7 million, Enemalta under-budgeted its fuel requirements for 2004/05 by Lm6.8 million. Thus, it was decided that this sum will NOT be passed on to the consumer but will be absorbed by Enemalta. Consequently, the fact that the surcharge was not reviewed earlier will NOT work to the detriment of the consumer. |
| Furthermore, the | decision-making process with respect to the revision of the surcharge rate took much longer than expected in view of the higher than expected international price increases, a situation rendered even more difficult by September’s massive market disturbance following the impact of Hurricane Katrina. As a result, the October 2005 increase – expected to be around Lm2.5 million compared to October 2004 – has still to be factored in. |
| Government has | decided that this shortfall should NOT be financed by the consumer and is therefore being absorbed by Enemalta. |
| This sum is in addition | to the Lm8.4 million that Enemalta had already adsorbed when the surcharge was introduced last year – a sum which, as explained in the MCESD last year, represented the cost of internal energy generation and distribution inefficiencies on the part of Enemalta. In this context, it was decided that once again for the financial year October 2005 to September 2006, the sum of Lm8.4 million will again be absorbed by Enemalta. |
| For the avoidance of | misconceptions, both these inefficiencies and any other organisational inefficiencies are NOT being passed on to the consumer but will be absorbed by Enemalta this year as they were last year. |
| Enemalta will | consequently be taking out a loan for Lm9.3 million to finance the above-stated budget shortfalls whilst it will also finance the sum of Lm8.4 million from its cash flow as it did last year. |
| In its discussions | within the MCESD, Government had always indicated that one of the options it faced was that Government and Enemalta would assume part of the sum that needed to be recovered in this financial year. That commitment is now being translated into action. The Government also believes – as clearly stated to the social partners – that whatever solution is arrived at, the burden must be shared by all the players and spread equitably across society and the economy. |
The surcharge rate for November 2005 onwards
| In its budgeting | process, Enemalta has to attempt to predict what it will spend on fuel to generate electricity each year but in a highly volatile market this process can, at best, be an educated guess. If the estimate happens to be distant from the market reality and, as happened last year, it proves to be conservative, whatever level of surcharge is introduced now, will again have to be changed later on. Irrespective of the prudence adopted in Enemalta’s purchasing strategy, in the present market atmosphere, this is likely to happen. |
| The Government has | therefore decided that rather than trying to predict the market, Enemalta should base its calculations on the actual fuel costs it incurs (hedging included) and adopt a system of more frequent changes, as already successfully adopted for motor fuels since 2001. This is also the system that is adopted in most, if not all, EU countries and has the added advantage of ensuring that the consumer does not suffer from infrequent but hefty increases. Moreover, Enemalta’s cash flow would not be strained by regular increases that are absorbed by it rather than reflected in its charges to the consumer. Similarly, the consumer would immediately benefit from any decrease in the Corporation’s fuel costs used for the generation of electricity. |
| Obviously, Government | understands that in a rising market, this may probably negatively affect the consumer but it is universally recognised today that one cannot completely offset the effect of international fuel pricing. Whichever model is adopted, eventually and over a number of years, has to align electricity rates with international oil prices. |
| In this context, | Enemalta will be calculating the surcharge rate as follows: |
· The revision will be made every two months, the first revision applying from 1st November 2005 to the 31st December 2005 ;
· A week before the start of each two month period, Enemalta will publicly announce the surcharge rate for the following two month period – this means that the next announcement will be made in the last week of December 2005 and the rate will be applicable for the months of January and February 2006;
· Since the surcharge is based on the principle of the differential between costs for this year as against costs for last year, Enemalta will extrapolate its actual fuel costs (using Lm CIF Med. as a base) for the previous two months (September and October 2005 for the present exercise covering November and December 2005) onto a yearly basis, compare it to the base fuel cost for 2004/05 and add the present surcharge recovery (Lm7.7 million). The result will represent the sum that needs to be recovered in the following two months and is applied to the surcharge model agreed last year in the MCESD and which will be applied again this year;
· This would mean that the surcharge rate will – like motor fuel prices – follow the international market on the price of fuels and may go up or down every two months;
· Changes to the billing system will be taken in hand in order to ensure that the consumer can clearly identify the different surcharge rates as they come in and until such time as the adjustments are made to the software (approximately four weeks) no further bills will be issued except those for industrial and commercial consumers which receive bills on a monthly or a bi-monthly basis;
· Using the above methodology, the surcharge rate for November and December 2005 will be 84% for all consumers. Government, however, believes that this rate is still too high and requires adjustment principally for social considerations. Government has therefore decided that rather than financing all the increase from an increase in the surcharge rate it should spread also part of the load onto fuels;
· Consequently, Government has decided to increase the excise duty of Unleaded Petrol and Lead Replacement Petrol by 3 cents which in turn means that the surcharge rate can be initially reduced from 84% to 79%. This additional excise duty will be reduced by 0.125 cents per month to be totally abolished over a period of 24 months; and
· Neither the price nor excise duty of Diesel and Kerosene will be increased.
Cushioning the effect of the surcharge
| Government is more than | aware that whilst economic theory clearly supports the rationale to increase the surcharge rate as above, both the national interest as well as its policy of social solidarity require that if the burden is to be shared by all it should also protect people in real need as well as ensure that the country’s economic performance is, as far as possible, not placed at a disadvantage. |
| Consequently, as a | first measure, Government will not be applying the surcharge to all persons who are classified as social cases with Enemalta Corporation through the Department of Social Security. This means that some 13,000 persons will NOT pay ANY surcharge at all apart from the fact that they will also continue NOT paying any meter charges. The lost revenue for Enemalta will be refunded by Government through a direct subsidy to Enemalta in the interest of these households. |
| As a second measure, | Government believes that the rise in the surcharge rate should be further cushioned applying the principle that the burden should be shared by all and the impact spread over a reasonable period of time. As a consequence, Enemalta will be increasing its lending by circa Lm11.3 million in order to assume a further portion of the increase, which loan will mean that for the consumer the surcharge rate will be initially reduced from 79% to 55%. This will be the surcharge rate on the 1st November 2005. |
| The reduction in the | surcharge rate is a method of spreading the cost to the consumer over a longer period of time rather than having to assume it at one go, hence creating a temporary ‘cushion’ for the consumer. In other words, it will be stepped-up over a period of time with the resultant ‘cushion’ being financed by Enemalta. Government has determined a 24 month period to align the difference of 29% (55% to the full 84%) which means that – independently of international price movements – the ‘cushion’ will be decreased through 1.21% monthly increments in the surcharge rate. |
| In view of the above | financing arrangements, the total financing to be covered by Enemalta will therefore be of Lm20.6 million in addition to the current fuel commitments and Lm8.4 million financed through its cash flow as it did last year. For the avoidance of misconceptions, this financing will not be met through any form of increased taxation measures. |
| As a third measure, and | in view of the rise at one go of the surcharge from 17% to 55% Government is, as of the 1st January 2006 , including in the RPI adjustment the inflationary effect of this measure. In effect, this means that a substantial number of households will only be marginally affected by the revised surcharge. Moreover, Government will include the 100% adjustment also for senior citizens to ensure that these are not adversely impacted by these increases. |
| This decision may be | criticised by employers that were against it at the MCESD when it was requested by the Unions as they correctly argued that it would once again increase costs and erode competitiveness. In reaching this decision, the Government has taken these views into active consideration and once again tried to spread the burden equitably keeping in mind that: |
· Domestic consumers are already subsidising heavy industrial and tourism consumers through the application of the capping mechanism;
· Whilst economic competitiveness is important so is social solidarity and a right balance has to be found between the two;
· Government is adopting other measures – as will be explained further on – to increase the competitiveness of Maltese industry and tourism;
· This is an exceptional, one-off decision that does not in any way effect the basic RPI agreement;
| The net effect of this | move is that besides the 13,000 persons who would not be affected by the surcharge, the latter would have a neutral effect on any household that is in the low-to-moderate consuming bracket. |
| As a fourth measure, | Government and Enemalta have decided to retain the cap it introduced last year in favour of heavy consumers in industry and tourism. However, it believes that the present cap (Lm5,000) should move proportionately in line with the increase in the surcharge which means that the cap will be increased to Lm21,000. This means that the maximum effect on theses industries will be of Lm16,000 per year. The cap will be set for the full financial year and will only be reviewed in October 2006 to reflect prevailing market conditions and the corresponding surcharge rate. |
| In the discussions | within the MCESD, some employers’ representatives argued for even more special treatment for this sector. Whilst clearly appreciating this demand, Government and Enemalta have only partially acceded to it mainly due to the following: |
· The introduction of the cap meant that whatever is not recovered from the heavy industrial and tourism consumers is in fact recovered from the others – domestic and commercial consumers. Whilst this makes sense from a national economic interest point of view (support to competitiveness), lowering the cap increases the burden on the others – a burden which is already increasing substantially; and
· The increase does not dent the competitive base of the Malta product since our competititors are passing rate increases regularly into their own systems and their products have felt the effect of high fuel prices long before we did.
Liquid Petroleum Gas (LPG)
LPG is mostly used for home heating and/or cooking and last year Government paid Enemalta Lm1.8 million through a contribution with the aim of keeping prices at their present levels. The table below shows the significant difference that exists between the production and distribution cost and the actual retail price, which difference is being subsidised by Government.
Chart 2: Differentials of LPG pricing
10 Kg | 12 Kg | 15 Kg | |
Price based on actual fuel costs | 4.21 | 4.90 | 6.12 |
Current price | 2.06 | 2.32 | 2.89 |
Government contribution | 2.15 | 2.58 | 3.23 |
In fact, through this arrangement, Government and Enemalta cover over 50% of the actual price of LPG cylinders to consumers.
Government has decided that it will AGAIN repeat the subsidy given last year and will also absorb this year’s further projected increase which will mean that this year Government and Enemalta will carry at least another Lm2.1 million in order to maintain retail prices at their present levels.
Once again, the Government is again concretely sharing part of the burden underlining the principle that the burden should be shared by all. It should, however, be obvious that this statement is dependant on LPG international prices registering only modest increases that can be contained within the subsidy.
Fuel Prices
Considering the rapid and constant increases that are being registered in the international fuel market, Government has decided that the quarterly fuel price review will be changed into a monthly price review, starting from the 1st November 2005 .
This means that fuel price movements at the pump and for industrial fuels will change every month and will follow more closely the Enemalta Lm CIF Med. Prices. Thus rather than averaging out the cost every three months, the price will reflect what Enemalta would have paid for that fuel the previous month. The table below shows the variances in selling price of the three principal fuels if the system had been introduced on the 1st January 2005 :
Chart 3: Simulated prices using monthly variance system
10 Kg | 12 Kg | 15 Kg | |
Price based on actual fuel costs | 4.21 | 4.90 | 6.12 |
Current price | 2.06 | 2.32 | 2.89 |
Government contribution | 2.15 | 2.58 | 3.23 |
A reduction in the excise duty carried by motor fuels has often been mentioned as a possible solution to lowering fuel prices. In fact, Malta – as most new EU members – has excise taxes that are actually below the minima established by EU Directives and in the Accession Treaty, Malta bound itself that it would progressively adjust these taxes to, at least, reach EU minima by 2010. The table below charts the movements required, which in any case are not envisaged to be implemented during 2006:
Chart 4: Malta and EU Minimum Excise Taxes
10 Kg | 12 Kg | 15 Kg | |
Price based on actual fuel costs | 4.21 | 4.90 | 6.12 |
Current price | 2.06 | 2.32 | 2.89 |
Government contribution | 2.15 | 2.58 | 3.23 |
| The industrial, agricultural and tourism | sectors depend on diesel products not only as motor fuels but also to run machinery. Keeping in mind the need to be competitive, Enemalta supplies Light Heating Oil as a substitute for kerosene in industry which retails at only 24 cents compared to 41 cents for diesel. Enemalta also sells various grades of thin fuel oils with an average retail price of Lm 165 per metric ton (equivalent to 16.5 cents per litre). |
| In these two products, | excise tax is below the EU minimum so no reduction can be made to enhance competitiveness. Nevertheless, in order to still achieve a reduction in price, albeit small, Enemalta has decided to cut its profit margin on thin fuel oil from the present Lm15 per metric ton to Lm5 per metric ton, essentially a 66% decrease. |
| In order to further | assist manufacturing industry, agriculture and hotels, Enemalta is introducing a new product as a substitute for Diesel 50ppm, namely Gasoil 0.2%, which whilst retailing at the same price of diesel will carry a refund limited to the manufacturing industry and hotels of 5 cents per litre on the excise paid and 1.3 cents from the profit margin of Enemalta (reflecting the lower cost of the product) – a total of 6.3 cents per litre. This is in line with Council Directive 2003/96/EC. |
| In line with this | policy thinking, the Ministry of Finance will be introducing a scheme whereby manufacturing industry, farmers and hotels can claim back from the Ministry of Finance 6.3 cents for every litre of Gasoil 0.2% consumed by them. |
| In order to compensate | for the loss of revenue in excise duty from the above scheme, excise duty on LRP and Unleaded Petrol is being increased by 3 mils per litre (excluding VAT) with immediate effect (additional to the above-mentioned 3c). The net effect on revenue for Government will be practically nil at current consumption rates. The excise duty on kerosene and diesel for cars is not being altered. |
| These decisions have | been discussed with the Malta Resources Authority to ensure compliance with legislation and standards. Further submissions will be necessary after the announcement of these measures according to established procedures. |
| Government is also | supplementing this decision with a series of other measures aimed at addressing the overall energy scenario of the country, which were also explained in the MCESD: |
1. Government is exploring, through the Ministry of Foreign Affairs, the recent declaration made by the Libyan Ambassador in connection with this matter;
2. The Malta Resources Authority are preparing a wide-ranging study on the energy generation options available to Government and the country;
3. Enemalta have set in motion discussions with key energy players in the region to explore the options of connecting to the European Grid and also to connect to a gas pipeline;
4. The Fuel Procurement Advisory Committee of Enemalta, composed of technical experts, has been set up, is in full operation and hedges have been effected;
5. Enemalta has commenced the process to procure further generating capacity to enhance and improve its efficiency levels both from an economic and environmental standpoints;
6. A programme to reduce energy consumption in the public sector will be launched during 2006; and
7. Further incentives will be offered to households and businesses which invest in alternative energy generating devices.
This strong stance being adopted by Government is a clear indication of Government’s commitment towards the development of a holistic energy policy over the coming years.
Conclusion
Government is aware that the drastic changes that have had to be made in order to make good for an international problem that is not of the Government’s or Malta ’s making, are not easy to digest. However, Government believes that the solutions that it has come to – after hearing the social partners at the MCESD – represent an equitable distribution of the problem between the various sectors of society. In fact, the solution presented is on the same lines of Option 1 which was discussed in the MCESD:
1. Government and Enemalta, will next year cover Lm31.2 million of fuel costs;
2. This has been achieved without resorting to any form of new taxation or new Government loans which has ensured that the Government manages from existing means this portion of the burden rather than levying it from taxpayers and or consumers without missing its budgeting targets;
3. The surcharge rate of 55%, the subsequent adjustments and the new excise duties are expected to raise circa Lm33,000,000 from the consumer in 2006;
4. The consumer is being protected through the inclusion of the RPI adjuster as from January 2006 rather than a year later;
5. A balance has been found between the interests of the domestic, commercial and industrial consumer;
6. The competitiveness of the manufacturing industry and hotels is being protected through the use of the capping mechanism;
7. The competitiveness of industry, hotels and agriculture is being enhanced through a drastic downard revision in the prices of industrial fuels; and
8. Specific attention was made not to effect the retail price of diesel to contain the impact on the competitiveness of local business activity.
The Government considered it had one important over-riding duty in reaching its decisions: to achieve a fair balance between the needs of the country’s competitiveness and the obligation for social solidarity which is not only the Government’s obligation, but the obligation of everyone. It is important for all of us to face up to the real challenges generated by the economic realities today but is also crucial not to lose sight at any point of the realities of the lives of Maltese families whatever their income. The Government is convinced that these decisions achieve such a balance in the best way the current global economic environment allows.
Stqarrijiet Oħra:
PR261948
STQARRIJA MILL-UFFIĊĊJU TAD-DEPUTAT PRIM MINISTRU U MINISTERU GĦAS-SAĦĦA ...
PR261947