Left arrow Go Back

SPEECH BY THE HON. TONIO FENECH, PARLIAMENTARY SECRETARY IN THE MINISTRY OF FINANCE, AT THE SEMINAR ON THE SAVINGS TAX DIRECTIVE ORGANISED BY THE MALTA INSTITUTE OF TAXATION – BIRKIRKARA – THURSDAY, 9 JUNE 2005

PR0862
Date Icon 09/06/2005

Mr. President, Ladies and Gentleman

What is a fair burden of taxation? Is our system just?  Is everyone giving his fair share?  These are the questions that I’m sure many of us boggle with every day.  Everyone would like to live in a tax free world, but since we have no gushing oil the financing of our public services, whether health, education, pensions, our infrastructure, the environment and other public services will have to be financed by taxation.  

I believe that our fiscal system is, by and large, both fair and equitable, though inevitably there will be some issues which require attention, whilst continuing with the gradual process of shifting the burden of taxation from productive and income generating activities to consumption.    

Tax evasion, however, consigns fairness and equity to the theoretical sphere.  This is something which we cannot afford, and which I am sure is rejected by all sectors of the community.  A national effort to eradicate evasion is now gathering pace, and today I would like to comment on aspects of this effort.  

There have recently been complaints, mostly in the newspapers, but also in Parliament by members who should have known better, about the way in which the Tax Compliance Unit and other investigating agencies have been setting about their duties.  May I remind the audience here today, and the wider audience to whom my words will hopefully be reported, what are the reasons why agencies such as the T.C.U. were constituted.   

Simply put, this was, in the first instance, to eradicate tax evasion.  Secondly, they were entrusted with the task of nurturing a culture of tax compliance.  I think we all agree that while both aims must be high on the national agenda, neither is easy to achieve.  If somebody thinks that these twin tasks can be implemented simply by nice and gentle tactics, I beg him to come forward to explain lucidly his theories and prove them to be effective, so that they can be inserted into the T.C.U.’s mission statement.  On the other hand, we will not tolerate a confrontational approach.  One’s duty on the job is just one’s duty and nothing more.  At times some of those being assessed complain that some unusual methodologies may have been occasionally used in trying to arrive at the true taxable income.  Many times these are not more then logical reasonableness tests that are used to verify the validity of the income declared when compared to the purchase components declared.   

Clearly, the workings of the T.C.U. have still to be weaved into the fabric of Malta ’s tax system.  I would encourage everybody concerned, on both sides of the fence, so to say, to make an all-out effort to nurture carefully this extremely valuable tool in achieving what is after all the civic duty of tax compliance.  Most of us present today are auditors by profession, while most of the rest are lawyers.  I think it will be generally agreed that, in both professions, our responsibilities do not always allow us to be nice and gentle, though courtesy can never be forsaken.  Facts are facts, and have to be driven home as such, however awkward for the person at the receiving end.  

I think that my good friend the President of the Institute will not mind my reminding this audience that he was not precisely renowned for shirking his responsibilities during his long years’ service at the Inland Revenue, nor of being ‘soft’ with defaulters.  He is however also remembered among both officials and practitioners not only for his labors on behalf of the public purse, but also for the fact that there are few persons around who can justifiably grumble at the reason why, and the way in which he relieved them from their money in the process.  I would exhort everybody concerned with taxation to regulate themselves accordingly.  

This brings me to my second point, the implementation on the 1 July 2005 of the Savings Tax Directive, not only with the European Union, but also with the third countries and territories in or associated with Europe, including Switzerland, Liechtenstein, San Marino, Monaco, Andorra, Jersey, Guernsey, Isle of Man, Channel Islands, Antilles, British Virgin Islands and Turks and Caicos Islands.  

Our experts from the International Tax Unit will later on today go into the technical details of the Directive, to clarify any outstanding difficulties.  I will therefore restrict myself to our preparations for the 1st July next, when the Directive finally comes into force.   

It is common knowledge that vast sums of money have in the past been siphoned off from Malta ’s economy and salted away overseas.  I do not intend to explore the origins of this phenomenon and why we have been so liberal in furnishing other countries with the finance to develop their own economies.  I will leave that to future historians and students: I am sure that several learned theses will be written on the subject.  Unfortunately, however, once this practice got going, it spread like a cancer through the fabric of our society and seemed to be unstoppable.  

It is small consolation that this malady was not restricted to our country.  It was first widespread in America in the post war boom, and later emigrated to Europe following the tightening of controls in the USA , the emergence of the ubiquitous computer, and the growing affluence in Europe . Working alone, there was very little that a country such as Malta could do about the matter.  But what we could not achieve in isolation could be done through a determined common effort by all the nations of Europe .   

The E.U. Directive has had a long gestation period because it was early on realized that if imposed by Europe alone, money would simply flow away to other financial centers, leaving a huge vacuum in Europe and the possible collapse of such financial institutions as Switzerland, the city of London, Frankfurt and Luxembourg.  Only when non E.U. financial centers agreed to join in was it possible to implement the Directive.  

Coming events, as they say, tend to cast their shadows before, and it was long ago realized in Malta that the ground had to be carefully prepared for any such measure as the Directive.  An unheralded and sudden introduction and implementation would have simply created another crisis as serious as the one it would be intended to rectify.  You will all remember the step taken several years ago to introduce the concept of the taxation of investment income at a flat rate of 15%, anonymously and with no questions asked.  More than a few shouts of “scandal” were heard, and elaborations on the theme as to how nefarious and unfair the arrangements were could be found in many weighty newspaper articles.  Events proved otherwise, and in due course we were able to introduce the Investment Registration Scheme and the extension of the taxation of investment income anonymously at a flat rate to overseas investment.  The economic benefits are there for all to see.  

The coming into force of the E.U. Directive brings to an end our preparatory efforts.  The journey is now over and we have arrived.  Concessions and amnesties are a thing of the past, and the future is bleak for persisting defaulters.   A few days still remain, and I sincerely recommend to anybody who is still dragging his feet to make good use of this final and definitive opportunity.  

Many have not braced themselves to this reality, some even doubt the same effectiveness of the Directive and possibly think that they can still get away with it and information on their present “hidden” investments would not be disclosed to the competent tax authorities.  Others may have other concerns.   

I have heard false rumours that some have been investigated by the TCU, produced a certificate under the previous schemes, but still the investigation was not stopped.   This I must repeat is completely untrue and unfounded.  Over the years only two cases arose, and these were immediately achieved.  

Some investors are justly afraid to register as even though the tax authorities would not hunt them for their past income, exposure could lead Tax Authorities to be more vigilant when assessing their future activities.   This will surely be the case for those who opt not to register, as their information would eventually be disclosed to the authorities by the respective institutions and countries (on an annual basis) thus divulging not only the capital and income involved but also the beneficiary.  It must be emphasized that even those jurisdictions that have opted for a withholding tax system will only do so on a temporary nature.  

I can only conclude by encouraging those that are uncertain to take up this opportunity, there is not much time for an extension as the 1 July is only 2 weeks from the closure of the scheme, from then on the Government has no interest in extending, as the information will start to flow.  

May I wish you all well for today’s proceedings and thank you for your attention. 

Share this Press Release Icon socials Icon socials Icon socials Icon socials

Other Press Releases:

STQARRIJA MILL-UFFIĊĊJU TAD-DEPUTAT PRIM MINISTRU U MINISTERU GĦAS-SAĦĦA  Ċertifikazzjoni internazzjonali tal-ogħla livell għad-dipartiment tar-radjoterapija fiċ-Ċentru tal-Onkoloġija Sir Anthony Mamo

PR261947

STQARRIJA MILL-UFFIĊĊJU TAD-DEPUTAT PRIM MINISTRU U MINISTERU GĦAS-SAĦĦA Ċ...

STQARRIJA MILL-MINISTERU GĦALL-EDUKAZZJONI U L-ISPORT  Aktar minn 1,800 student jiggradwaw mill-Università ta’ Malta

PR261946

STQARRIJA MILL-MINISTERU GĦALL-EDUKAZZJONI U L-ISPORT Aktar minn 1,800 stu...

More Press Releases Right arrow