SPEECH BY DR. JASON AZZOPARDI, CHAIRMAN: STANDING COMMITTEE ON FOREIGN AND EUROPEAN AFFAIRS, HOUSE OF REPRESENTATIVES – MALTA AT THE CONFERENCE ON SCRUTINY PROCEDURE IN THE TEN NEW EU MEMBER STATES ON “THE STRUCTURE AND ROLE OF THE STANDING COMMITTEE ON F
The Maltese Parliament has been facing an increased number of challenges during the pre- and post- European Union accession process, and has been primarily entrusted with the additional responsibility of scrutinising the EU’s pipeline acquis. This has been accompanied by restructuring changes whereby the Maltese Parliament set up the Committee on Foreign and European Affairs (SCFEA) instead of the previously established Committee on Foreign Affairs.
The core functions of the SCFEA relate to the scrutiny of legislative proposals or documents originating from the European Union, and to represent the House in the Conference of the European Affairs Committees (COSAC). The aim of the scrutiny procedure is to assess the legal and political importance of EU documents that are deposited in Parliament and to determine whether they should be debated and analysed in more detail, or whether they can be cleared without further debate.
The scrutiny of the Government’s policy with respect to the European Union has the function of bridging the gap between what goes on in Brussels and its effect on the Maltese citizens. This role of bringing the people closer to the European Union is crucial in ensuring that the European citizens do not feel detached from the Union itself. Furthermore, the debates that are held during the Committee meetings ensure that at any point in time the Government’s accountability and transparency can be verified.
The Standing Committee on Foreign and European Affairs (SCFEA) is composed of the Chairperson and 8 Members – representing both sides of the House of Representatives - who are appointed by way of a parliamentary motion at the beginning of each legislature. The Chairperson is elected by way of a motion in the House and has the original and the casting votes.
With regard to the composition of the secretariat of the committee, there are currently five members of staff within the SCFEA - 4 research analysts and 1 Committee Clerk. The research analysts’ main task is to carry out research in respect of the pipeline acquis as well as incidental research and reporting support to the Committee whereas that of the committee clerk is to coordinate the various tasks and requirements of the Committee.
The Main Characteristics of the Maltese Scrutiny Process
The scrutiny process adopted by the Maltese Parliament is closely modelled on the UK House of Commons Scrutiny System. The model is document-based and thus includes all proposals or recommendations for legislation by the Commission, and any documents submitted by one European institution to another.
The SCFEA encompasses within it 3 sub-committees which are engaged in parliamentary scrutiny – Working Group I, Working Group II and Working Group III. The Standing Committee for Social Affairs, which deals with social policy issues, might also be required to function in scrutiny mode similarly to Working Groups II and III. Working Group 1 has the function of examining the acquis in preliminary scrutiny and deciding on whether to clear a particular document without reservation, or whether it requires further scrutiny. If further scrutiny is required, Working Group I refers the document either to plenary SCFEA or to Working Group II, Working Group III or the Social Affairs Committee.
The areas of responsibility that fall within the remit of Working Group II include economic and monetary affairs, taxation, research, employment, education and culture, transport and energy, budget, regional policy, internal market, and customs union. Working Group III is responsible for areas related to health and consumer protection, development and humanitarian aid, rural development, fisheries, justice and home affairs and the environment. Matters related to constitutional affairs, enlargement, development, external relations and trade, enterprise and information society, and competition are treated in plenary by the SCFEA.
Once a document is referred to either Working Group II, Working Group III or the Social Affairs Committee, the Chairman of the respective Working Group calls a meeting during which the Minister responsible for the document is expected to attend so as to answer any queries the Committee may have on the particular document. The Minister is encouraged to bring along experts from his Ministry when participating in such meetings. The Minister responsible for the dossier and the Opposition spokesperson on the matter appearing before the Committee act as members during the respective meeting.
After the meeting of the relevant Working Group, the Chairman, on the basis of the discussion within the Working Group declares whether:
- The document is cleared, which implies that the members of the Working Group are of the opinion that the queries or clarifications sought by the Committee were satisfactorily answered and there is no scope for further discussion or consultation to be held.
- The document is retained (i.e. not cleared) pending receipt of additional information.
- A parliamentary scrutiny reservation is to be retained. The registration of a parliamentary scrutiny reservation obliges the Minister to provide supplementary explanatory memoranda; keep the Committee continually informed of any developments; and answer any queries that may arise in connection with the document under analysis.
The parliamentary scrutiny reservation in theory precludes the Ministers from giving agreement on the proposed legislation or policy. The parliamentary scrutiny reservation has no legal status in Malta although it is strongly recommended that during the negotiating process during the Council meetings in their various configurations, the Minister takes into account the Committee’s views relating to a particular document. A vote may be taken during any of these meetings if the Members do not reach a consensus; however to date there has never been the need to take such a vote.
As soon as the documents have been cleared the Chairman of the Standing Committee tables all the documents in Parliament. Consequently, all documents are made publicly available, also on the Committee’s website, thereby enhancing the transparency of the Committee’s work.
The involvement of Government in the Scrutiny Process
Government is involved in the parliamentary scrutiny process right from the beginning; in fact under the current set up it is Government that sets off the process. All documents originating from the European Union are forwarded to all the Member States and are received by the relevant Ministries. In turn the Ministries have to prepare an Explanatory Memorandum (EM) to be presented to Parliament accompanying the original document which is forwarded to the SCFEA once it passes through a number of steps, the last of which is Cabinet approval.
The Committee’s research analysts prepare a report on the documents forwarded, irrespective of their legal or political importance, and indicate a recommendation as to whether the document can be cleared at Working Group 1 level without discussion or whether it should be referred to one of the working groups for further scrutiny.
Furthermore, the Committee has introduced post-Council meetings during the plenary SCFEA, whereby the Minister explains the outcome of the Council meeting attended and addresses any queries from the Committee’s members. This acts as a means of control of the effectiveness of the work of the Committee in that the Committee can verify whether the Minister took the stand that was indicated in the EM and agreed upon during the scrutiny process.
The process of scrutinising an EU draft proposal
In order to explain how the scrutiny process of EU documents is carried out by the Maltese Parliament, the procedure involved in monitoring the Proposal for a Directive of the European Parliament and the Council on amending Directive 2003/88/EC concerning certain aspects of the organisation of working time (COM (2004) 607) is being set out in detail.
Following Cabinet approval, the Explanatory Memorandum prepared by the Minister of Education, Youth and Employment was forwarded to the Committee including: background information on the proposal, the legal basis of the proposal, Malta’s position on the dossier in concrete terms, the economic and financial repercussions of the proposal, any changes required in the related national legislation and the internal and external consultations held by the Ministry. The Research Analyst working on this document prepared a brief including a set of recommendations as to whether the proposal should be cleared at Working Group 1 level or referred for further discussion. The Proposal was discussed during the meeting of Working Group 1 held on 17 January 2005 , and due to the technical nature of some of the amendments proposed as well as its high political importance, the Proposal was referred to the Social Affairs Committee.
After requesting further information from the Lead Ministry, the Minister responsible for the dossier appeared in person before the Social Affairs Committee on 16 February 2005 . The Members of the Committee presented their queries and sought clarifications on specific sections of the Proposal to the Minister. The Members were of the opinion that the replies and clarifications presented by the Minister on the Government’s position on the dossier were satisfactory. As the Committee was in agreement with the Government’s position on the proposal, the document was thus cleared and following that the Research Analyst prepared a final brief i.e. a summary of the scrutiny of the document.
The Minister’s Explanatory Memorandum, the Proposal for the Directive (COM (2004) 607) and the final brief prepared by the Research Analyst were tabled by the Chairman of the Committee on 11 April 2005 and consequently made available on the Committee’s website.
The Experience Achieved since the Setting up of the Standing Committee on Foreign and European Affairs
Significant progress has been recorded in the scrutiny process since its inception in May 2004, especially in the relations between the Maltese Parliament and the EU Secretariat within the Cabinet Office. However, the Committee is aware of and striving towards achieving a more effective operation of the scrutiny process. One of the major challenges faced by the Scrutiny Committee relates to the volume of documents issued by the EU institutions that have to be monitored as the document-based model requires that each such document is scrutinised. There are also a number of EU documents published before Malta’s accession to the EU that have not yet been received, thus creating a backlog of documents to be scrutinised.
A reduction of the time lag that exists between the origin of the document and its deposit into Maltese Parliament is one of the top priorities called upon by the Committee. Furthermore, due to the fact that documents are not received directly by Parliament, the Committee does not have the means to verify that all EU proposals received by the individual Ministries are forwarded for scrutiny. Government’s responsiveness to requests from Parliament varies across Ministries, depending on the staffing available at the EU Directorates of each Ministry. However, it must be noted that the introduction of the scrutiny procedure has brought about a significant culture change in the way the Ministries work and interact with the Maltese Parliament, and this is a new and challenging experience for both sides.
With regard to the availability of information, the relevant EU documents are downloaded from various databases according to the Explanatory Memorandums received. The EU documents are accessible to the Committee members and the secretariat. The official EU databases most commonly used include EUR-LEX, PRE-LEX and the Council Register. In addition, various online services and websites are used as a major source of information on the European Union.
During the past year, the Scrutiny Committee has analysed a total of 155 EU proposals, including but not limited to, Commission Communications, Proposals for Directives, Decisions, Regulations, and Recommendations. A total of 91 documents were cleared by Working Group I. From the documents referred to either Working Group II, or III or to the Social Affairs Committee, nineteen documents were cleared by Working Group II; twelve have been cleared by Working Group III; and five documents were debated and cleared by the Social Affairs Committee. Six documents have been retained under parliamentary scrutiny. The full list of scrutinised proposals can be accessed via the Committee’s website where all the relevant documentation is also available, including the EU pipeline acquis, the Minister’s memoranda and the analysts’ reports[1]. These are made available as soon as the document is cleared from scrutiny.
Conclusion
Thinking back, although the SCFEA has only been set up a year ago, it must be said that it was truly a hectic and eventful year for the Committee and for the Working Groups within the Committee. This is evidenced by the number of times the Committee and Working Groups were convened and the progress that was consequently achieved.
Whilst acknowledging the successes achieved during the past year, the Committee is aware that further improvements will yet have to be implemented to enhance the efficiency and effectiveness of the Maltese scrutiny process. In particular, the Committee looks forward to listen to and draw upon the experiences gained by other Member States since the inception of their own scrutiny committees. The Committee also believes in encouraging and fostering co-operation between the National Parliaments, particularly of the new Member States as they are more likely to share similar challenges and are still gaining increased exposure in the actual implementation of the scrutiny process.
Stqarrijiet Oħra:
PR261947
STQARRIJA MILL-UFFIĊĊJU TAD-DEPUTAT PRIM MINISTRU U MINISTERU GĦAS-SAĦĦA Ċ...
PR261946