INTORDUCTORY REMARKS BY THE HON. JASON AZZOPARDI, CHAIRMAN OF THE FOREIGN AND EUROPEAN AFFAIRS COMMITTEE OF THE HOUSE OF REPRESENTATIVES, PRIOR TO A LECTURE ON THE ICJ ADVISORY OPINION IN THE CASE CONCERNING THE WALL IN OCCUPIED PALESTINIAN TERRITORY
Prof Attard, Prof Lowe, Excellencies,
Ladies and Gentlemen,
I must admit feeling both humbled and honoured in being invited to pass these introductory remarks.
As a former student of Professor Attard, and as someone whose doctoral thesis, 10 years ago, was about the UN Convention for the Suppression of Unlawful Acts against the Safety of Maritime Navigation, following the Achille Lauro tragedy, I can assure you that I have a deep-seated admiration and appreciation for all those who are contributing to a rule of law which is indeed international and one that is truly observed by both States and individuals.
Malta has been a member of the UN Committee on the Exercise of the Inalienable Rights of the Palestinian People since its establishment in November 1975. The United Nations General Assembly Resolution mandated the Committee to consider and recommend a program designed to enable the Palestinian people to exercise their inalienable rights. From its start and until the present day, the Committee has annually elected the Ambassador of Malta as Rapporteur. Thus Malta has always played an integral role in the Middle East peace process through its direct participation in the Committee.
However, there is no doubt that since May of last year, Malta’s membership of the European Union has brought it enhanced geopolitical clout. In recent months Malta has regularly advocated that the international community needs to extend its diplomatic support to Israel and the Palestinians to facilitate implementation of the Road Map as soon as possible. At a European Council meeting late last year, Malta’s Minister of Foreign Affairs insisted that the EU should not only be supportive of local elections in the Palestinian Territories as it had always done in previous declarations but make a specific reference to general elections. (para 33 of European Council declaration).
Some say that every cloud has its silver lining. It is a given that contemporary international relations in the Middle East are fluid in nature. It is precisely this fluidity which offers the EU an opportunity to upgrade its influence in this geo-strategically proximate region.
Malta’s Minister of Foreign Affairs (who last evening was updating the Committee on his recent visit to the Middle East and his official visit to Israel next week --- incidentally, next month the Israeli ambassador to Malta will be meeting my Committee and will be giving a presentation on the situation in the region, just as the Palestinian Ambassador did last January. Also, at the beginning of next year I will be leading a delegation of my Committee to the Middle East, a first for the Committee) has been insisting on a regular basis that the EU must spearhead the Middle East peace initiative and adopt an avant-garde policy in the Middle East together with the United States is essential if progress is peace talks is to be registered any time soon. The European Union must also formulate an external affairs strategy towards the Middle East that does not appear to be duplicating Washington’s endeavours to broker a peace settlement in the region.
Failure to adopt such a policy will only result in a wastage of already scarce resources and could also lead to a situation where the European involvement in the Middle East is regarded more through a competitive lens than a complementary one. Let us be frank about it. The Middle East stalemate is not only detrimental to the region itself but is also having a negative impact upon regional relations across the Mediterranean area.
International initiatives such as the MENA process and the Euro-Mediterranean Partnership that have attempted to spur intra-regional co-operation are being held hostage as a result of the lack of progress in peace talks.
The time has come for the European Union to do more than simply accept its “self imposed” subordinate role in the region – it is a major economic player in the Middle East and should seek to play as important a political role. Suffice it to say that the EU 2005 Aid Package to Palestine amounts to no less than Euro 250 million. The EU is also one of the most important trading partners of Israel linked to it through the 1995 Association Agreement which itself emphasizes the importance of human rights and the principles of the UN Charter and is thus in a unique position to ensure compliance by Israel with international norms.
It is also pertinent to point out that all the 25 members of the EU voted in favour of the UN General Assembly resolution of July 2004 which demanded that Israel comply with its legal obligations as identified in the advisory opinion of the ICJ.
Last March an International Meeting was convened, on the Question of Palestine with the theme: “Implementing the ICJ Advisory Opinion on the Legal Consequences of the Construction of a Wall in the Occupied Palestinian Territory – The role of Governments, intergovernmental organizations and civil society”.
The participants of the meeting, inter alia, whilst welcoming the ongoing work for the establishment of a register of damage caused to all natural or legal persons concerned, also welcomed the adoption by the General Assembly of its resolution of 20 July 2004.
To my mind the UN GA Resolution needs serious reflection. It reaffirms the permanent responsibility of the United Nations towards the question of Palestine. Words whose significance echo that of the Advisory Opinion when, in its First Part, it refers to the “direct concern to the United Nations”. Direct concern to the UN. Not to the two sides involved. Not to the Middle East. Not to the Mediterranean. But to the UN as a whole!
In the Third and Final Part of its Advisory Opinion, the ICJ stated what many times we are forgetting: “the tragic situation in the region can be brought to an end only through implementation in good faith of all relevant Security Council resolutions”. Is there any good faith left in the region?
Stqarrijiet Oħra:
PR261947
STQARRIJA MILL-UFFIĊĊJU TAD-DEPUTAT PRIM MINISTRU U MINISTERU GĦAS-SAĦĦA Ċ...
PR261946