INTRODUCTORY ADDRESS BY THE CHIEF JUSTICE VINCENT DE GAETANO, ON THE OCCASION OF THE THIRD PLENARY SESSION OF THE 16TH NSTF MINI-EUROPEAN ASSEMBLY
Hon. Parliamentary Secretary Dr Mifsud Bonnici,
Mr Secretary General of the NSTF Francis Stivala,
Ladies and Gentlemen
It is indeed a great pleasure for me to welcome you again this year to hold another session of the NSTF Mini-European Assembly in the building of the Courts of Justice.
This is the third Plenary Session of the XVI Assembly, and, as has been customary now for a number of years, one of these sessions is invariably held in this building. This I consider to be very appropriate. The Assembly is essentially an exercise designed to train young people in European Affairs and in public speaking, and since much of European Affairs concerns legislation dealing with the rights and duties of citizens of the European Union, it is also appropriate that the structures involved in the administration of justice and in the interpretation of, and final adjudication upon, those rights and duties should also contribute to this very worthy exercise that the NSTF has been conducting over the past sixteen years. The judicial structures, both at national and at EU level, guarantee to the states members of the Union , and to the Union itself, a degree of stability that they would not otherwise have. Indeed one can state without fear of contradiction that out of the three branches of Government in any modern democratic state, the Judicial branch, although generally having neither purse nor sword, is the most important branch since it is the final arbiter of the legality of every law that is passed by Parliament and of every administrative act that is performed by the Executive branch. Without the Judicial branch, justice is inconceivable, and without justice, the State is inconceivable. And this is no new theory. That great scholar, philosopher and theologian, Augustine of Hippo, who, before his conversion, once pleaded with God “Grant me chastity and self control, but please not yet”, after his conversion had no qualms in affirming in the most forthright manner “Remota justitia, quid sunt regna nisi magna latrocinia?” – if you remove justice, what remains of the kingdoms, of the states, except a bunch of robbers? His conception of justice was so fundamental that for him a law was not a law unless it was a just law: “Mihi lex esse non videtur quae iusta non fuerit” (De Libero Arbitrio).
This building, like every court building in any modern democratic state, entertains cases ranging from those which may appear trivial (and to that extent those cases may indeed sometimes be very entertaining) to those which concern the very essence of democracy. Suffice it to mention cases where the Courts have to decide whether the fundamental rights of an individual have been infringed by the State. Whether the case deals with a minor contravention or with the constitutional validity of an Act of Parliament, the procedure is basically the same – the parties have to put their case before the court, marshal the evidence, if any, and support the case by cogent arguments. All this requires on the part of those appearing for the parties that they should not only have a very good command of language, but also that they should have the necessary speaking skills to put forward a case in a clear, concise and convincing manner.
The NSTF Mini-European Assembly has over the years proved to be an excellent training ground for both lawyers and politicians – even the latter require good public speaking skills, which perhaps may explain why many parliaments are crammed with lawyers.
You will presently be debating a resolution dealing with the problem of human trafficking and teenage prostitution in Europe – a problem that has been accentuated in recent years with the fall of the Iron Curtain and the opening of Europe ’s borders on the east. But before you debate that issue, it is my pleasure now to invite a lawyer and a politician – and one who certainly does not lack the necessary skills in public speaking – to deliver his keynote address on the subject of to-day’s session. The Parliamentary Secretary at the Ministry for Justice and Home Affairs, the Hon. Dr Carmelo Mifsud Bonnici, needs very little introduction. Before taking up his first ministerial appointment, Dr Carm, as he is affectionately known, was a regular practitioner in this building, with a wide ranging practice -- from civil, commercial and maritime cases, to criminal cases and family law cases. He is also a lecturer in civil law, including Roman Law, at the University of Malta , and for the last two years has had the unenviable task of dealing with the administrative side of the administration of justice.
Without more ado, I therefore invite the Hon. Dr Carmelo Mifsud Bonnici to address you.
Stqarrijiet Oħra:
PR261947
STQARRIJA MILL-UFFIĊĊJU TAD-DEPUTAT PRIM MINISTRU U MINISTERU GĦAS-SAĦĦA Ċ...
PR261946