ADDRESS BY THE HON. LOUIS GALEA, MINISTER OF EDUCATION, YOUTH AND EMPLOYMENT, AT THE UMASA SEMINAR ON “RESTRUCTURING THE UNIVERSITY
It is a pleasure to be with you this morning, and it is encouraging to see this structured approach towards the necessary dialogue that needs to occur during the next few months between all the stakeholders in this sector of higher education.
I commissioned the working group headed by Mr. Chalmers precisely for this reason – to give us an objective synthesis of the current situation in the post-secondary and higher education area, highlight the major issues and challenges faced, and outline a number of options and recommendations for discussion and eventually for reform.
Today’s seminar is addressing the restructuring of the university. There is no doubt in my mind about the present Government’s recognition of the central role played by our University in our society and economy. Government is committed to ensure that Malta ’s higher education provision – MCAST and University in particular – is not only strengthened and extended but also that its quality continues to be a most attractive selling point in the package of Malta ’s competitiveness.
In these few minutes I would like to highlight three points:
1) The major areas that require fundamental and structural reforms as highlighted by the Chalmers report;
2) The underlying principles which government would like to preserve and promote; and
3) Share with you my response for a new policy agenda to be shaped over the coming months.
Looking first at the areas that need addressing, I take as important four major issues.
1) Participation trends continue indicating growth in demand for higher and tertiary level education, and a derived demand for general education at all lower levels of education. My Government’s strong view is that this is both necessary and desirable.
2) The fact that, because of the success that our policies have achieved over the last decade, institutions are under funded, and simultaneously operating in a framework which according to the report is deemed to be “wholly inadequate”, to me raises issues of :
· on one hand, the sustainability of higher education, and university in particular, under pressures of growth in demand and participation; and
· on the other, the efficiency, transparency and responsiveness of the university in using additional funds to deliver the highest possible quality education from both an operational and academic perspective.
Government wants seriously to consider the recommendation to move towards an objective formula funding mechanism, with an underlying exercise of three year, zero-based budgets, and a review of the university’s administrative and academic quality assurance mechanisms.
Parts of this framework had been proposed by the University itself, in some type of Formula funding, but I reiterate that accountability is a pre-requisite for academic autonomy which the university rightly deserves.
3) The striking imbalance in the proportion of funds directed towards student financing. Despite the success of these schemes in the past, a “generational rethink” is being called for. We must ensure that whilst this expenditure continues to preserve access to all - irrespective of their financial ability, that it does not work perversely on the institutions who require the same growth in finances to cope with expansion. This is not just the government’s problem, its an issue society at large must address responsibly, in the context of the overall drive towards further development.
I myself was one who fought for a free university and for additional student support. I am still wholeheartedly committed to this conviction. But in the context of increased participation, of quality improvement, and of competing claims on public funds, the report encourages us to explore the possibility of a shared burden which may take various forms. The public is ever more conscious of the worth of such an investment, and I firmly believe that in exchange for increased capacity and better quality of resources, everybody would be prepared to consider sharing the investment in their very own human capital.
4) Finally we have a call to co-ordinate the collage of institutions in the sector. The students’ experience to climb the ladder of educational achievement should encompass all institutions, access to the highest possible level based only on merit, and an ongoing lifelong experience.
With this came another call to treat the issue of “tilt” with caution. Despite the attractiveness of direct financial carrots to speed up the response of students in courses offering lucrative employment opportunities, the report urges us to fight asymmetry of information with information and guidance, rather than very difficult, short-termist, command and control mechanisms.
For these, the set-up of a co-coordinating body was recommended, which in my view could take the form of a re-enacted National Commission for Higher Education.
Amongst the underlying principles to be incorporated in this debate I believe there should be:
| 1) | A firm conviction and commitment towards higher participation rates and continued investment in the sector. |
| 2) | Preservation of the principle of equal access opportunities with the guaranteed provision of a safety net based on specified socio-economic criteria. |
| 3) | A shift in treating student support which is not directed towards the institutions as a social policy instrument rather than one of education. |
| 4) | A firm commitment towards the provision of quality to the highest degree possible, both in administrative and academic terms. |
| 5) | The recognition of Autonomy coupled with the necessity for stronger Accountability and the necessary reforms and funding for this process to become feasible. |
| 6) | The broadening of the term accountability to include not only regularity of financial procedure (ie. Audit reports) but a thorough analysis of the efficiency, relevance and value of such expenditure. |
In my efforts to act on some of the recommendations, these are the next steps in my plan :
1) I shall be recommending to Government the appointment of a National Commission for Higher Education, charged generally with these tasks:
a. Creating a radar for trends and forecasts based on local, European and international developments, through research and consultation, to act a basis for proper career guidance programmes by all institutions at all levels.
b. Engaging in dialogue and making annual recommendations for policy development to integrate and coordinate all the different institutions in the sector.
c. To develop an external review and support mechanism of the planning and budgeting mechanisms within the institutions. To develop, analyze and report on the functioning of a formula-funding mechanism, and externally review key performance indicators.
d. To assist in the development, support and externally review internal quality assurance programs run by the institutions.
e. To analyze, report and recommend policy reform in student support schemes. Any change in the SMG and Tuition Fee regimes must be co-coordinated all the other dimensions of policy, operations and finances.
f. To monitor and report on progress of integration of the various institutions within the EU framework of programmes and objectives eg. The European Higher Education Area EHEA.
2) Additionally, in the reform of the Education Act we shall include the following elements:
a. External review of institutions by National Commission for HE;
b. Zero-based budgeting, formula funding, and development of Key Performance Indicators;
c. An effort to support the development of reliable and externally reviewed quality assurance frameworks encompassing both academic and administrative issues; and
d. Possible changes in the Students’ Maintenance Grants system and Tuition fee regime following a full process of consultations with all stakeholders.
I am sure that the distinguished speakers you have on your panel, and even more so, the high level contributions of all the participants in the workshop sessions, will constitute a most important catalyst for the national dialogue that is essential for charting the way forward in consolidating and improving our higher education.
Stqarrijiet Oħra:
PR261947
STQARRIJA MILL-UFFIĊĊJU TAD-DEPUTAT PRIM MINISTRU U MINISTERU GĦAS-SAĦĦA Ċ...
PR261946