Left arrow Go Back

ADDRESS BY THE HON. CARM MIFSUD BONNICI, PARLIAMENTARY SECRETARY IN THE MINISTRY FOR JUSTICE AND HOME AFFAIRS, AT THE SEMINAR ENTITLED: “ADVANCING LEGAL APPROACHES TO MEDIATION IN CIVIL AND COMMERCIAL MATTERS” – MEDITERRANEAN CONFERENCE CENTRE – VALLETTA

PR242
Date Icon 26/02/2004

1. The present work load at our law courts is not any different from that obtaining in certain other European countries. It is a known fact that 41% of cases have been pending for five years and over, but it is a situation to which we have been reacting through the last years. We have entered into numerous amendments to our procedural law, introduced the Small Claims Tribunal, gave birth to the Centre for Arbitration and increased our complement of judges and magistrates. All these have produced results which have reduced the problem but we have to admit that this has not occurred to the degree and extent to which we can safely declare that we are satisfied. Yes, there has been a sensible reduction in the work load but we must admit that there is a hard core which is still extant and needs to be urgently addressed.

2. We are not, and should not, be pointing fingers. That is the state of matter and we should take it from that. So this Ministry has continued to work on new roads which should allow a further reduction of court cases. Roads which are different from those taken in the past years. We have announced certain measures to which we hope that this year will see them being brought to light. This does not however imply that we are not aware that old cases, those which have been on our shelves for the past five years and over, will be reduced just by the introduction of new measures. These will apply for new cases and not those already pending. However we hope that if we reduce the flow to the same mecca this should allow our judges more time to deal with the old knots.  

3. In furtherance with this line of thought we believe that mediation is a good means by which civil and commercial disputes can be solved both outside court and within the pre-trial stage. This process through which parties are no longer at loggerheads but are encouraged to actively cooperate to find a solution for their dispute with the expert advice of a neutral third party and that of their respective lawyers, is I believe, a must in to-days realities. It is a system that has worked at other times and is working efficiently in other European countries and we should all become aware of this. Unfortunately in this country mediation has not been used and is not being used. The legal culture is still built on the idea that the only venue that will allow the resolution of a dispute is through filing a law suit and obtaining a court judgment. The idea of using alternative dispute resolutions such as arbitration and mediation are still not quite the order of the day. Government believes in ADR and its benefits; thus, it has already taken this to task and we are happy to say that the Malta Arbitration Centre has been set up and is being used. But we must also register that it is not as yet utilized to its full capacity. Now we are studying and looking into as to whether we should also set up of a Malta Mediation Centre which can organize and regulate this sector better.  

4. We agree that Mediation is clearly a valid instrument which helps to reduce legal disputes and thus also the court work-load, but we do not see this as a substitute or part of a delaying tactic. It is for us a method through which new cases can be approached and if need be, and there is the necessary agreement, even the present case load can be tackled through mediation. May be we should also give these parties the option to refer the matter to mediation so long as this does not itself become a further expedient for delay, but as an instrument which facilitates the amicable resolution of the case. As more often than not we must admit that due to the great back-log, cases are not given the necessary time  to allow them to arrive at an agreement which is acceptable to both parties and which at the end of the day could be better than a court judgment. We are thus in for  mediation both within and outside court procedures. We are against the mal-practice carried out in certain states where by mediation has been allowed to become a vehicle for unnecessary delay and thus part of these tactics intended to prolong the matter, not solve it. We are  aware of  the fact that a right and legal mediation process helps considerably to diminish court costs. We are considering and evaluating how these legal frameworks should be set up and whether this should be provided wholly or partly free, but are definitely determined that they should be always reasonable and proportionate to the importance of the issue.  

5. The future law regulating Mediation will fortunately not be our first attempt at mediation. This has already been introduced since the 16th December 2003 in the family court division. There, mediation is working and already giving results. There is a growing awareness of the advantages of mediation and of the required skills and cooperation between the mediators and the lawyers representing their clients. We are monitoring what is happening there and so far we must say that the system has been in most cases a vital instrument to tone down the scale of the dispute and to rationalize it. Couples are given far more attention to their problems and this helps in order to allow most of them to arrive at a lasting and amicable settlement even though they have to register that their marriage has failed. We hope that we will draw valid lessons from this experience, such that we may finally arrive to the right choices for our mediation regime.  

6. To-days meeting is thus intended to start off and stimulate debate . We must all agree that information is a necessity in this field. Especially to those who are totally unaware of the advantages and of the possibility of setting up this, as an alternative venue. The advantages of mediation are still very unknown to most of us in this country and it is thus advisable that we start to spread them to as many as possible. We are at the end of the day  in reality joining a debate which is currently going on both at the Council of Europe and the European Union with the difference that we are (may be) already convinced that mediation is an asset which should be used and that hopefully  legislation will be submitted later on in the year.  

7. One last word - may I be allowed to sincerely thank all the participants in to-days Seminar. Your presence is an honour for us. A special thanks goes to the Council of Europe, The British High Commission, The American Embassy, the Ambassador of the Netherlands, the Judicial Studies Committee and the Chamber of Advocates - without your support this event would not have materialized. I sincerely hope that through our efforts we will reap a good harvest in the near future.

Share this Press Release Icon socials Icon socials Icon socials Icon socials

Other Press Releases:

STQARRIJA MILL-UFFIĊĊJU TAD-DEPUTAT PRIM MINISTRU U MINISTERU GĦAS-SAĦĦA  Inawgurat bust ta’ Ġorġ tal-Mużew fl-Isptar Mater Dei b’tifkira tal-ħidma tiegħu fost dawk vulnerabbli

PR261936

STQARRIJA MILL-UFFIĊĊJU TAD-DEPUTAT PRIM MINISTRU U MINISTERU GĦAS-SAĦĦA I...

PRESS RELEASE BY THE MINISTRY FOR ENERGY, THE ENVIRONMENT AND THE REGENERATION OF THE GRAND HARBOUR  ERA launches anniversary publication: A decade of protecting Malta’s natural future

PR261935en

PRESS RELEASE BY THE MINISTRY FOR ENERGY, THE ENVIRONMENT AND THE REGENERAT...

More Press Releases Right arrow