Left arrow Go Back

SPEECH DELIVERED BY THE HON. AUSTIN GATT, MINISTER FOR INVESTMENT, INDUSTRY AND INFORMATION TECHNOLOGY AT THE MALTA INSTITUTE OF MANAGEMENT CONFERENCE ON ‘ENTREPRENEURSHIP AND INNOVATION IN MANAGEMENT’ – ST. JULIANS - FRIDAY, 5 NOVEMBER 2004

PR1731
Date Icon 05/11/2004

Your speakers today must have given you all the insight one can hope for in a single day on the subject you chose for your conference. I do not presume to be able to add much to the expertise that has been presented. Instead I will try to approach the subject from my own bias – the experience which I have acquired as Minister responsible for the State’s investments.  

It is now a familiar mantra that, unless, there are explicit reasons to justify such a thing, Governments should as a rule not indulge in commercial business. Perhaps at face value the reason for that is that Governments, good as they may be in their own art, can be manifestly bad at business. If politicians had been good at doing business they would probably have done it with their own money.  

There are, of course, explicit reasons, why, on my portfolio, there is an airline, utility corporations, a shipping line and a ferry service, a large ship-repair industry, a broadcaster and significant investments in postal services and telecommunications, an airport and a bank no less. You will understand that I have enough on my plate to keep anyone and his brother rather busy.  

The reasons for continued public ownership, vary from one firm to another: some are in Government ownership because the size of the Maltese market and the essential nature of the service make it very difficult to contemplate a competitive scenario which would be truly beneficial to the consumer.  

Others are still in our ownership because we inherited them as painful legacies from the past. Others are in transition from public to private ownership. In all, however, the reason why they appear to remain in public holding is for want of finding a better arrangement that would have an explicit benefit to our economy.  

For want of such a better arrangement, it is my job to ensure that the public’s money is spent as wisely and as usefully as you would spend your own money. Because this is not my money, there are checks and balances to scrutinise my work, and this is indeed as it should be. I have also made it my business to strengthen the structures of scrutiny and will be telling you about what initiatives my Ministry has undertaken in this regard. As you might also expect, I do not think all works smoothly and will be sharing with you some concerns on the weaknesses in our structures.  

Earlier I spoke of painful legacies. One of these is a cultural problem with adapting to contemporary ideas of corporate governance. You will confirm that this is by no means an issue entirely exclusive to public entities. The Maltese private sector also often finds itself slow in growing out of traditional family arrangements based more on personalities and the orbit of their satellites than on transparent rules of governance.  

Ministers are, by definition, personalities, and heavy ones at that! Their choices for Chairmen and Directors of public companies are almost always highly capable people, more often than not hand-picked from among the leaders in our business community, who are also then, by definition, heavy personalities. In turn, Chairmen and Directors work on a daily basis with Management teams which they either appoint or find in place.  

There are theoretical lines drawn around each of these corporate functions: the politicians are accountable to the public and are therefore duty-bound to plot a course of sustainability and political desirability; the Directors have responsibilities defined by law – as long as they remain within those responsibilities they have the task to translate the politicians’ vision into strategy. Management translates that strategy into business plans and have the responsibility to run the company on a day to day basis. We all know it is not always like that.  

When I took stock of matters as I took over the responsibility for these investments nineteen months ago I was less surprised about the rate of breach of these rules of engagement and rather more surprised about the perception and expectation of the rate of breach.  

Put simply I was and remain frustrated by how often people entrusted with the responsibility of taking commercial decisions (and I mean salaried Management in case there is some ambiguity on this) rather prefer to wait for the Minister to take the plunge. When I took office I introduced structures of shareholder supervision so that I can effectively ensure that public entities are consistent with the larger Government vision and do not develop into uncoordinated territories and competing empires. These structures have permitted us to reverse age old trends of commercial losses in the smaller firms such as Gozo Channel, Malta Air Traffic Services and PBS and to enforce the road to recovery in the larger firms such as Air Malta and the Shipyards. They have therefore proven to be effective and refreshing initiatives.  

Their greatest weakness however is that in some cases these structures continue to be perceived by Management as measures of Ministerial intervention in the nitty-gritty of day to day management which they are expressly not intended to be. This perception, erroneous as it is, is not necessarily a negative perception but is rather seen as a measure of comfort … a political heavy-duty cushion for Management, as it were.  

This is not a blaming game, and I will prove to you that I am not in the business of apportioning blame by using an example that I am sure will provoke a sympathetic reaction to the predicament of Management.  

The term ‘hedging’ is on just about everybody’s lips these days. Few of those who use the term as if it was second nature will be able to explain, correctly at least, what it actually means. My guess is most people understand it to mean “heavily discounted oil in exchange for the supreme wisdom of Ministers with Socialist inspiration”. The political baggage that loads this word is so heavy that the technical, commercial meaning of the word is almost completely buried under it.  

Now to spare you the fear of having to witness a bout of political football, I wish to reiterate my oft stated position that notwithstanding the political kicking, I cannot see why the word ‘hedging’ should be stained with normative values: if you ask me, it is neither ‘good’ nor ‘evil’. It is a commercial tool and not a political controversy, or at least that is how it should be.  

As any commercial tool it will work sometimes and not work at other times. There is a polished expertise, specialised and skilled in dabbling in hedging. I certainly do not have that expertise and nor do I want to. Almost certainly my shadow Minister knows as much about how to hedge oil prices as I do. It is neither my job, nor his, to be expert hedgers. It is up to Enemalta to employ people for this express purpose.  

But even the most hard-nosed business people, the most refined experts, the most seasoned investors, can get it wrong sometimes. Entrepreneurship, as you must have heard several dozen times today, is about risk and its management: and risk by definition can either provide exponential returns if it works out, or cost you losses if it does not.  

Can you blame Enemalta Management if they are more cautious about taking risks than they probably would if they were hedging with their own money? If they were hedging with their own money, they would take losses in their stride, as a fact of commercial life and move on to the next commercial enterprise. On the other hand, if a commercial initiative undertaken by a public entity does not work out, expect hell-fire and brimstone from politicians.  

The present Brindisi Terminal controversy is a reverse case in point. The commercial enterprise made manifest commercial sense. It was so self-evidently right that the first to back it wholeheartedly and politically forcibly was the then Prime Minister, now Leader of the Opposition. Unfortunately, it was one Malta Freeport effort that did not work out so well. Because it turned out wrong commercially, something everyone used to agree upon, became a major cause for disagreement and controversy.  

Since you only hear of the commercial enterprises gone bad, you’d think that public investments never get it right. The reason why few of you ever heard of Malta Freeport’s investment in Oil Tanking is probably because it has worked out so well for us, and in the political game, success stories are far less interesting.  

Whether in enterprises owned by Government or within the structures of the public service itself, Managers (like Departmental Directors) face a culture which penalises them for risk and initiative. The classical tradition of reducing the budget of a Department which has struggled to cut its costs in the previous years has gone deep under the skins of public managers. The reverse should be true. Successful public sector managers should be measured by the same yardstick as any other manager. In this portion of the economy too, only what gets measured, ends up getting done.  

From these experiences, perhaps the most important lessons are that in spite of the existing checks and balances, information on what has actually succeeded is hard to come by because nobody ever mentions it, and information on what is not working out so well is late in emerging in the public domain because no one will be too interested before it becomes one of the rare but politically juicy commercial failures.  

It is part of my routine business to table audited accounts in Parliament. It is part of the routine business of Parliament’s Public Accounts Committee, chaired by the Opposition no less, to scrutinise those public accounts. To this add the information that is published on the MFSA website. And yet, all this bureaucracy and structure remains ineffective in delivering to the public the information they truly deserve to know.  

Last year I established the practice of personally meeting the press to discuss, one entity at a time, its financial performance during the preceding year. This has improved public awareness considerably and I am therefore committed to continue this practice year in year out.  

To supervise and to ensure a constant flow of information is a responsibility this shareholder is committed to very strongly. It takes time to change cultures. While some politicians cannot resist the temptation to bleat rather than talk, Directors struggle with the temptation to go native within a week of their appointment and lose sight of the big picture of national interest in exchange for the narrow bias of the company they are directing.  

It is, I can assure you, an unbelievably consistent transformation: the one most Directors undergo within a few days of their appointment. Without warning they often cease to be shareholder’s representatives (which is what the law asks them to be) and become buffers for the company’s age old traditions.  

This is often an involuntary phenomenon and is rather surprisingly expected by the public. The Government recently appointed a Management expert who works in the food industry to lead the public broadcaster’s Board. A small army of intellectual snobs pointed out that the Government’s choice has no experience in broadcasting. PBS employs around 50 broadcasters. What new insights can a Chairman who is also a broadcaster by profession really be expected to contribute?  

Call me radical, but I think the CEO and his or her Management Team should concentrate on daily business and to turn to technical expertise whenever they need it to take the right decisions and give the right advice. Chairmen and Directors should not sink deep into operational details and stay in a position from where they can give a real value-added contribution to the good of the company. These views are not universally accepted in the structures of our investments.  

These are weaknesses intrinsic to the reality that this is commercial business happening against the glaring background of politics. We try to mitigate this reality through proper structures and more clarified roles. Separating public operators from the regulatory function is one such mitigation effort. It has its own problems of course: the proliferation of corporate bodies in the public sector is, I personally am of the view, fast climbing rather over the top.  

At the last count, the Government has various degrees of investments in 

·                    6 Corporations, 

·                    6 Listed Companies and 

·                    35 Limited Liability Companies.

Over those, you can pile up 

·                    7 Foundations, 

·                    22 Commissions and 

·                    19 sundry Public Service Entities beyond the core conventional Departments 

                     that are by no means few.

All of these are regulated by 

·                    16 Authorities, 

·                    9 Tribunals, 

·                    22 Commissions and 

·                    5 Constitutional Bodies and they are supported by some 

·                    40 Committees, 

·                    20 Councils and 

·                    72 Boards.  

I have no doubt in my mind that this bureaucracy is excessive, that there is duplication, and that we can and should be doing more with less.  

Seen like this, the need for smaller Government ceases to be conventional Republican rhetoric. Indulging in commercial activities distracts us from our core functions as a Government, so it doesn’t matter if you are speaking from the political right or the political left: business should be left to business people and we should stick to what we know … at least as much as circumstances and wisdom allow. Our privatisation programme is consistent with this maxim.  

Our entrepreneurial spirit and sense of innovation should focus on providing efficient public services, to ensure top standards of health and education, to knit a sustainable social security safety net, and to create the environment and the space for your entrepreneurial spirit and sense of innovation for you to do what you are good at: doing business.  

DOI  05.11.2004

29.17 Kbytes Last Modified on 05th November, 2004

HOME | GOV.MT 

HELP | LINKS | SITEMAP | SEARCH

Share this Press Release Icon socials Icon socials Icon socials Icon socials

Other Press Releases:

STQARRIJA MILL-UFFIĊĊJU TAD-DEPUTAT PRIM MINISTRU U MINISTERU GĦAS-SAĦĦA  Ċertifikazzjoni internazzjonali tal-ogħla livell għad-dipartiment tar-radjoterapija fiċ-Ċentru tal-Onkoloġija Sir Anthony Mamo

PR261947

STQARRIJA MILL-UFFIĊĊJU TAD-DEPUTAT PRIM MINISTRU U MINISTERU GĦAS-SAĦĦA Ċ...

STQARRIJA MILL-MINISTERU GĦALL-EDUKAZZJONI U L-ISPORT  Aktar minn 1,800 student jiggradwaw mill-Università ta’ Malta

PR261946

STQARRIJA MILL-MINISTERU GĦALL-EDUKAZZJONI U L-ISPORT Aktar minn 1,800 stu...

More Press Releases Right arrow