REPLY TO NATURE TRUST ON SHIP SOURCE POLLUTION
Reference is made to Nature Trust’s expressed disappointment on Malta ’s position against the proposed Framework Decision on ship source pollution taken in the Justice and Home Affairs Council of Ministers in Luxembourg last week.
Malta is well aware and supports the reasons that gave rise to this move towards legislation by the EU against maritime pollution.
Nonetheless, Malta is disagreeing with the proposed Framework Decision on three counts:
1. The Framework Decision attempts to criminalise actions that under International Law issued by the International Maritime Organisation are not a criminal offence. Malta cannot subscribe to actions that in themselves undermine the UN agency on maritime matters. The effectiveness of international maritime legislation is the only means that can ensure worldwide applicability of safety and environment protection standards in shipping. Malta believes that multilateral action on a worldwide level is the most effective way ahead to eliminate ship-source pollution.
2. Malta is opposing this Framework Decision in that it attempts to impose harsher sanctions on EU-flagged vessels. The following is a typical example. Under the UN Convention on the Law of the Sea (UNCLOS) foreign ships are exempted from custodial sentences when they pollute territorial waters of a state without intent. The Framework Decision intends to regard all EU registered ships as being no longer foreign and therefore subject to custodial sentences while foreign ships will remain exempt from such sentences. Consequently, vessels that want to avoid exposure to this stricter regime can simply resort to flagging out of registers of EU member states and continue to trade in European waters nonetheless. Malta is not ready to undertake or support measures that will result in the Maltese flag losing competitiveness with no gains in terms of protection of the environment. The only thing the Framework Decision would have achieved is to render EU flags uncompetitive without making European waters any safer.
3. Although the Framework Decision proposes to impose on Member States, minimum levels of pecuniary sanctions that need to be reached by Member States when establishing maximum fines on ship-source pollution, it fails to provide an equivalent ceiling capping such fines. Malta believes that such ceiling is necessary in order to provide a measure of stability to the shipping industry which is increasingly being exposed to risks of being prosecuted in spite of having taken all the necessary measures available to ensure vessel safety.
Nature Trust should have at least contacted the Ministry for Competitiveness and Communications or the Ministry for Justice and Home Affairs before issuing statements that can only result in adverse publicity for the Malta Maritime Authority that has over the past years tackled the issue of Maritime Safety and protection of the environment in a very serious manner without compromising the prospects for so many whose livelihood depends on the viability of Malta’s shipping register.
DOI 03.11.2004
6.96 Kbytes Last Modified on 03rd November, 2004
HOME | GOV.MT
HELP | LINKS | SITEMAP | SEARCH
Stqarrijiet Oħra:
PR261947
STQARRIJA MILL-UFFIĊĊJU TAD-DEPUTAT PRIM MINISTRU U MINISTERU GĦAS-SAĦĦA Ċ...
PR261946