STATEMENT BY THE MINISTRY FOR TRANSPORT AND COMMUNICATIONS
Following the recent reports published in the French Newspaper "Le Figaro" and other reports which were subsequently published in the Maltese Press, the Ministry for Transport and Communications would like to clarify a number of points.
A little over a year ago, through normal channels, the French Investigating Magistrate Dominique de Talancé, who is conducting an inquiry on the shipwreck of ‘MV Erika’, asked the Maltese authorities for assistance and judicial co-operation and this assistance was duly fully accorded. Magistrate de Talancé, in fact, heard all witnesses she requested to hear, saw all documents she asked to examine and was given all explanations she asked for.
Madame de Tallance has, in the absence of any agreement between Malta and France summoned directly Dr Marc Bonello in his capacity as Chairman and Mr Carmel Vassallo the Executive Director of Merchant Shipping of the Malta Maritime Authority within the Ministry for Transport and Communications, to appear before the French Court in Paris for a first hearing on 15th July 2003. Dr Bonello and Mr Vassallo were advised by the Authority’s French Legal representatives not to appear in Court on the basis that the said summons was not in compliance with the proper procedures as established under the European Convention on Mutual Assistance in Criminal Matters, to which both Malta and France are parties and as such was null and void.
On the 15th July 2003 the Inquiring Magistrate as a result ordered Dr Bonello and Mr Vassallo to attend the Court Tribunal in Paris on 25th and 26th September 2003. Dr Bonello and Mr Vassallo were advised to attend this hearing during which they were assisted by the Authority’s French Lawyers, who maintained the stand that the Inquiring Magistrate was in violation of the state immunity enjoyed by Malta in that the Malta Maritime Authority was a state organ and Mr Vassallo a state official. Despite this the French Investigating Magistrate proceeded to summon Dr Bonello and Mr Vassallo to appear again before her at the sitting on the 15th – 18th December 2003.
It was therefore the view of the Maltese Authorities as advised by Malta Maritime Authority’s French lawyer that given the fact that the summons was being contested in French Appeal Courts and given that the said appeal proceedings were still underway, Dr Bonello and Mr Vassallo were not to attend before the Inquiring Magistrate until the appeal proceedings instituted by the Maltese Authorities were completed.
Furthermore, the Ministry would like to state that in fact an arrest warrant for the Maltese official has not been received by the Malta Maritime Authority and it is not yet clear whether this has in fact been approved by the French Courts.
Other Press Releases:
PR261936
STQARRIJA MILL-UFFIĊĊJU TAD-DEPUTAT PRIM MINISTRU U MINISTERU GĦAS-SAĦĦA I...
PR261935en