MINISTER FOR INVESTMENT, INDUSTRY AND INFORMATION TECHNOLOGY ADDRESSES THE FIFTH WORLD-WIDE FORUM ON ELECTRONIC DEMOCRACY
The Minister for Investment, Industry and Information Technology has today addressed the Fifth World-Wide Forum on Electronic Democracy that is meeting outside Paris under the patronage of the French President, Jacques Chirac.
The meeting is discussing the theme: “The Information Society: A New Opportunity for Democracy?” and is organised by the President of the Global Cities Dialogue André Santini.
As information technologies increasingly penetrate the public sphere, in recent years, governments in Europe and throughout the world have contemplated the use of these tools to remodel democratic practice and transform relations between citizens and public services.
With the goal of providing a regular meeting place to examine and discuss these major developments which concern all those with a role to play in city life, the Worldwide Forum on Electronic Democracy was created in 2000.
With an increasing number of participants overseas contributors and exhibitors, the Forum's flourishing success illustrates the importance of information and communication technologies in daily life and, more particularly, democratic life.
The Forum also benefits from the participation of European and world networks such as ADMINET, the Internet Rights Forum, Global Cities Dialogue, the Brazilian public information technology conference, the e-ID Contest, and major institutional actors. This participation reinforces the Forum's goal of making a real contribution to the implementation of e-democracy in tomorrow's world. Indeed, since the Forum's participants are present in the field, they have the means with which to apply proposals made over the course of the event.
The speech delivered by Minister Austin Gatt follows.
DOI - 30.09.2004
SPEECH DELIVERED BY THE HON. AUSTIN GATT, MINISTER FOR INVESTMENT, INDUSTRY AND INFORMATION TECHNOLOGY AT THE 5TH WORLDWIDE FORUM ON ELECTRONIC DEMOCRACY ON “THE INFORMATION SOCIETY: A NEW OPPORTUNITYFOR DEMOCRACY?” AT THE PALAIS DES ARTS ET DES CONGRÈS D’ISSY-LES-MOULINEAUX, FRANCE– 30TH SEPTEMBER 2004
Democracy has been defined as ‘Government by the people, for the people.’ A definition is supposed to clarify matters: to make them easier to understand. But very little in political theory is clear, and almost nothing in political practice is easy to understand. That is why we qualify the term democracy with adjectives.
‘Athenian Democracy’ refers to the genesis of the term. Romantic notions of an authentic golden age very soon make way to the appreciation that what are the most important lessons from Athensof 2,500 years ago point at what was wrong with their system. The free men of Athens spent their days articulating policy in free and open debate and respecting the will of a freely deciding majority. What is significant is that they actually had time to do this. What is clear is that to free up their time the rest of Athenian society (women and slaves) did all the real work. Such an arrangement would today be called inherently undemocratic.
Our understanding of Democracy is not limited to voting and deciding matters of policy. It extends to rights and their protection, to basic access to social well-being, to the respect of every individual as a complete member of society at the service of whom institutions exist.
Our understanding of Democracy also no longer distinguishes between us and barbarians. We believe that fundamental rights should be available to all: everyone should have access to water and food, to education and a decent living, irrespective of where in the world they come from.
Democracy therefore has a meaning that extends beyond narrow administrative choices and beyond narrow group interests. Democracy as a principle is universally desirable and meaningful only when absorbing other universally desirable objectives such as freedom from poverty and ignorance, discrimination and hate, war and violence.
In a world where poverty, ignorance, discrimination, hate, war and violence are not distant Malthusian prospects, but oppressively present features of many lives, these theoretical ambitions sound painfully hollow.
The adjective ‘Electronic Democracy’ sounds like adding decorations to a burnt Christmas Tree. If the global gap between the starving and the obese in our world appears to grow wider, the gap between those with access to technology and those without appears to be of mere academic interest.
And yet, as in anything in political practice, nothing is simple to explain and less is simple to understand.
Even the quickest of prognosis of the state of health of democracies in wealthy, developed countries, shows that not everything is quite as rosy as it may at first appear. A depressingly small portion of the population of Europe and the US find the conventional electoral process a sufficiently effective means of participation to actually bother to cast their vote. Many reasons are given for this. Few, in my view, are in any way convincing.
It is hard to believe that voters do not know who they are voting for, or for what issues they are casting their preference. There are many criticisms that can be made to contemporary industrialised society: these cannot include lack of information. If anything, one might say there is actually a bit too much and we have not yet learnt as individuals to organise it properly in our heads.
It is also hard to believe that voters do not think their vote can make a difference. If votes did not make a difference, none of us in this room would live in the perpetual state of fear of losing our job: which we are, and so we should be. We would live the lives of members of the old Politburos arranging for our embalmment to retain power even after we die. Votes do make a difference. Votes make a difference, every time. And yet few bother to use them.
Another explanation that is given is the old warning that elections are aught but periodic interruptions in the lives of dictatorships. The lack of participation in decision making and the lack of influence on decisions during the actual term, is the reason why many feel totally helpless even when they are asked to make a choice on who should oppress them for the coming few years. There is something to be said for this objection. Traditionally the justification for representative democracy was that in a society where everyone, not the few are free, most of us have to earn a living so we appoint some of us to make their living out of taking decisions on our behalf.
The shape and the need of the professional politician today is changing. People have more free time and broader interests. More people have the intellectual inclination and the time and energy to look closer at how their neighbourhood, their country, their world is run.
Up to now this was limited to forming an opinion when watching the news, much like we all have opinions when watching sports. Just because we follow closely our athletes competing, does not mean that we think we would do a better job than they if we were in their place. Not the same can be said of those following politics. Few people can ever be leaders of their own countries. But when people disagree with their leaders, theirs is not a superficial interest: they do indeed think that if they did get the chance to be the President or the Prime Minister, they would do things differently. In the absence of such a chance, they crave for a chance to tell the President or the Prime Minister what they think of his or her policies, and they do not intend to wait for the next election to do so.
This is why people scream at the television, join a protest march, write a letter to the editor: they have something to say and our democracy gives them the means to do so. But is it or is it not likely that someone who typically attends a protest march, or even screams at the TV at the sight of the top politico of the land, would also participate in a ballot when the opportunity arises? Is it or is it not therefore likely that even these methods continue to leave out in silence the majority of free people who decline their own right to participate in our democracy?
This is the gap that the onset of Electronic Democracy is looked upon to fill in the wealthy industrialised nations. What Representative Democracy claimed to achieve was the right for anyone to participate in the democratic process and to be eligible, on the basis of merit and popular support, to a space in the political sphere where decisions can be influenced. That was the theory. The practice of course is that politics was and is not for everyone. There are real life barriers that elites build around themselves to ensure self-preservation.
Electronic Democracy pulls down those barriers. Howard Rheingold tells the story of Dave Hughes a pensioner from Colorado Springs . The pensioner stood alone in the Strangers’ Gallery of his City Council, the sole dissenting voice on a new legislative initiative by the city planners. The man had thirty days and no conventional assets to raise awareness to his cause: he was not familiar with the local media and the local community barely knew he existed. He uploaded the proposed ordinance and sent letters to the local newspapers encouraging people to read the bill on line. At the next Council meeting 175 angry, noisy people showed up. The ordinance was defeated.
This is not the story of heady overnight debates at Westminster , or tie votes in Congress. It is the story of people using their home computer to influence decisions about their lives.
Politicians are a rapidly adaptive species. In this business you either change, or you die. The changing face of environmental activism is a vivid example of how this populist shift is being adopted by political elites. This is another improvement to the way our Democracy works. Because political decision making, whether started by Dave Hughes, the pensioner from Colorado Springs, or from the ruling party of a large country, can no longer be conducted in smoke filled rooms. The major physical shift that Electronic Democracy has brought about is the gradual dissipation of the monolithic political structure and the creation of broad networks involving politicians, business people, academics, NGOs, artists, and Mr Dave Hughes.
Conventionally the fount of information was the same source where decisions where taken. True, free press revealed what the authorities would have liked to keep hidden. True, elections were won and lost. But the locus of initiative remained at the centre, not unlike the way traditionally knowledge was stored in libraries and although everyone had the right to read books, they always needed to be passed on by librarians. Electronic communications has abolished the librarian middle-man. Knowledge is freely available from a multitude of sources and not only anyone can be a reader, but anyone can be a librarian; a writer even: in today’s Democracy anyone can be the decision maker.
Elections are not in and of themselves guarantees of quality. However Internet Democracy rubs salt in the wound of political extremisms, fetishism with violence, and murderous hate and terror.
Technology has reversed the means of scrutiny, perhaps without the scrutinisers themselves knowing how this has happened. It is reasonable to believe that had it not been for pocket sized digital cameras, we would never have known of the terrible abuses in the Abu Ghraib prison. I will not go into the merits of the case except to observe that there is agreement that it is as undesirable to hope that such abuses are kept secret as much as it is impossible to try.
I come from a country where the rate of take up of mobile phones is catching up with the take up of basic literacy and numeracy and the take up of Internet is catching up with the take up of TV game shows. People who for whole decades of their lives found little reason to write anything except their grocery shopping list are now writing SMSs like there is no tomorrow. More people are carrying digital cameras implanted in their little mobile phones for more days in the year than any other time. A world were everyone is a paparazzo equipped with technology that 15 years ago was the monopoly of 007 is bound to raise issues about privacy and the grammar and spelling of SMSs. But these are pathetically pale issues when compared to the real change that is happening to our lives.
As a futurist famously put it, “Little Brother is carrying a camera in his pocket, and he’s watching back!”
Information and the means to broadcast it is no longer the privilege of the elite. This is the electronic democratisation of information and even in this age, information is power. If it has stopped the abuses in Abu Ghraib prison, it cannot be a bad thing.
The new Electronic Democracy is therefore an evolution and probably an improvement on the Democracy we are used to but it is not without its problems.
And to close the circle, it leaves unsolved the problem of the distance between those with technology within their reach and those for whom technology is the least of their urgent needs. Electronic Democracy in wealthy countries highlights the new affordability of the means of influencing public opinion. Anyone, from home, can afford to speak to the whole nation, if the whole nation is willing to listen. But in places in the world where water and bread are unaffordable, the affordability of computers is a moot point.
It is hard to make up one’s mind whether to be optimistic or pessimistic. Electronic Democracy bears in it possibilities that give us courage and hope that we can win back citizens whom we unwittingly alienated with our way of doing politics. We cannot but be optimistic at the prospect of a political community where debate attracts universal participation and interest and where ideas and initiatives come from all directions no longer merely from the centre outwards. On the other hand, I submit, it is wrong to let our vision of the future be obscured by the mist in our eyes. No tool in itself can be an answer to a human problem. We can use it to get closer to a solution: but the responsibility of solving problems remains human.
There is still much scope for our profession, after all.
Other Press Releases:
PR261946
STQARRIJA MILL-MINISTERU GĦALL-EDUKAZZJONI U L-ISPORT Aktar minn 1,800 stu...
PR261945