Lack of understanding by MHRA on Government’s Waste Management Strategy
| With reference | to the statement made by MHRA, the Ministry for Resources and Infrastructure notes with regret that the paid advert issued by this Ministry has been received negatively by the tourism industry. |
| The advert was | not a matter of wasting a ‘couple of thousand pounds’, as stated by MHRA, but as a medium for disseminating more information to the general public. |
| MHRA must know | that delegates from this Ministry have always been and still are available to meet and discuss both formally and informally the various issues relating to this subject. Furthermore, an information seminar for all MHRA members and visits to hotels and restaurants were organised. This is evidence that the consultation process, which MHRA states is weak and not cost effective, goes beyond one page adverts. |
| The statement | re-iterates that the on-going studies for the Ghallis ta’ Gewwa site fall short of the criteria needed to evaluate the impact on the tourism industry. Reality is different. The initial evaluation of the sites has assessed the impact on tourism as compared to the other alternative sites. It has also compared the other criteria that must be included in the Environmental Impact Assessment (EIA). |
| The fact that | the detailed EIA will progress on Ghallis shows that the impact on tourism will be assessed to the full and not as part of the initial evaluation. This will undoubtedly characterise the impact on tourism further so that all necessary mitigation measures are seen to. With Maghtab as it is, the tourism industry boomed to about 40% of Malta’s bed stock in the region. With this site closed, rehabilitated and a controlled engineered facility in place, there is no reason why this percentage should not be sustained. |
| All | methodologies, findings of the EIA, detailed designs, etc will be available for public consultation as part of the EIA process. Once these stages are further developed the consultation process will happen and will take its required time. |
| With reference | to the specific questions put forward by MHRA, the Ministry wishes to clarify that : |
· With regards to the millions of cubic metres of inert material to be quarried, it must be emphasised that MEPA requires that any lower coralline globigerina limestone cannot be sterilised because it is valuable and diminishing with time. Therefore, the material will be extracted and used in construction projects, such as road works and the building industry. None of this will be going to waste, as the statement implies. The procedure for extracting this material will follow regular public procurement regulations.
· With regards to the immediate dumping of hazardous waste at Ghallis, referred to in the statement, this clearly shows MHRA’s lack of understanding of the proposed long term project. The project includes a controlled engineered landfill for non inert non hazardous waste, a controlled engineered cell for hazardous waste, a hazardous waste treatment facility and a Civic Amenity site for the general public. Therefore, apart from the fact that hazardous waste has long been co-disposed at Maghtab (mizbla) the proposed hazardous waste treatment facilities are a completely radical change in our waste management system. Hazardous waste will be treated at the hazardous waste treatment facility and either exported for safe disposal or landfilled in the controlled engineered cell.
· With regards to the cost of developing the interim and the long term facility, MHRA confirm the lack of cost effectiveness in developing a larger number of landfills spread over the island. It is far more costly to develop, manage and monitor satellite landfills rather than having a long term facility as this Government proposes.
· With regards to the EIA consultants, these are SLR of the UK and have an international track record of performing EIA studies on landfills.
· With regards to the choice of contractors it is not clear to which contractor MHRA are referring. However, the developer and operator of the controlled engineered landfill will be identified and eventually selected as part of the tender process of the Solid Waste Management Project of 2001.
· The rehabilitation of quarries is on-going. Quarry owners have long been involved in discussions for utilisation of available voids for these type of projects under both administrations. Only recently was there a break-through registered and the disused quarries may now be used for afforestation/agricultural purposes.
· Although it is impossible to highlight all the contract conditions in this statement (these consist of 5 volumes) it may be certified that these conditions are very thorough and exhaustive. Apart form this, MEPA will also be regularly monitoring the operational permits for these facilities.
· Logistics is one criteria being evaluated in the EIA and the international consortia bidding for this project are sure to have all the necessary expertise to plan for this. With regards to traffic, dust and noise pollution these will be thoroughly evaluated in the EIA and communicated upon during the consultation phase.
· With regards to the preferred sites for the interim facility, those quarries outside the Water Protection Zone were evaluated for capacity and operation. Only 16 were identified as listed in the Project Description Statement (PDS) and out of these only six are disused. Out of these six, only the chosen two have a sufficient capacity for a two and half year project. This goes on to show that, unlike what MHRA states, the use of existing quarries for a controlled engineered landfill is not an automatic solution and is not possible. All this information is in the public domain for consultation in the PDS.
As shown this Ministry has no reason to show ‘contempt’ towards the tourism industry and re-confirms the availability of its technical experts to explain the detailed work that is currently on-going and which cannot be summarised in adverts or press releases. What is also necessary is that this industry will seriously focus on waste minimisation and prevention so that the demand for landfilling will subside and the need for land for the disposal of waste will be reduced.
Stqarrijiet Oħra:
PR261936
STQARRIJA MILL-UFFIĊĊJU TAD-DEPUTAT PRIM MINISTRU U MINISTERU GĦAS-SAĦĦA I...
PR261935en