Left arrow Mur Lura

SPEECH BY THE HON JOHN DALLI, MINISTER OF FINANCE AND ECONOMIC SERVICES, AT THE MALTA INSTITUTE OF BANKERS ANNUAL DINNER  -  ST. JULIAN’S  -  14 NOVEMBER 2003

pr1387
Date Icon 17/11/2003
Excellencies,Ladies and Gentlemen
Thisis the time when Malta is caught up in a talk of reforms.
Thereare those amongst us who pay lip service to reforms, uttering palliatives about how important reforms are, and then sitting on the fence watching the gladiators fighting it in the arena.
Thereare those amongst us who pontificate about reforms, giving all the theory behind what should be done, and the advice that goes with it, but knowing that willy nilly they will be deep in their bunkers when missiles start to fly.
Thereare does amongst us who look at reforms as a chess game, with an attitude that they can sacrifice principles in the form of pawns or knights or bishops, as long as they move to checkmate the opposition.
Thenthere are those who believe in reforms, are serious about them, are imbued with the sensitivity of the economic and social implications that they imply, and are cast to lift the burden and carry it in the arena to fend off the tigers of self interest and lobby groups that constantly show their fangs and sharpened claws.

I count myself with the latter group.  I hope that when in the arena I turn my head to see who is down in the sand with me, I will see someone from the class of captains of industry, bankers, opinion leaders, trade unionists and journalists who really believe in reforms and who are prepared to expose themselves in the thrust to implement them.  

Manytalk about deficits.  The deficit is a problem.  The debt that it generates is absorbing financial resources as much as the health system is.  We must control it, reduce it and wipe it out.  Our deficit does not come about as a result of inordinate commitments on our defence or in international solidarity.  It is by and large a question of social transfers.
Thosewho talk about deficit and debt seem to underplay the fact that we boast one of the best health systems in the world (everything for free of course), one of the best pensions system, social services that are the envy of many, an education system that pays students that have increased 15 fold in the past 15 years, and that is now also in one to one facilitation for the underprivileged, an infrastructure that is much more functional and a greatly improved standard of living.  When those who talk about the deficit and debt talk about these things, it is only to demand more and more and more.
Inshort, the services that other people in other countries are used to pay for, we expect for free.  This is the public expenditure that we hear so much about.  This is what causes deficits.
Tostate the obvious, which sometimes is not recognised by many, a budget deficit comes about when revenues do not cope with pubic expenditures.  If we want to turn the equation around we can also say that a deficit comes about when public expenditures over-run public revenues.  The solution on paper is straightforward: either to increase the revenues i.e. through higher rates of taxation to pay for the expenditures demanded by that society, or else trim expenditures to suit the level of revenues which that same society wants to contribute to the public coffers.
Reformsaddress the process of trimming of expenditure.
Inview that social security, pensions and health, in short, our own welfare state, make up a sizeable proportion of our public expenditures, and because they are the reason for the increasing pressure on more government outlays, the key to controlling public expenditures is the realisation that first and foremost we need to answer a fundamental question. What kind of Welfare State do we, as Maltese, want for the future?
Tohazard a reply to such a question, one needs to know whether there is a consensus about what the welfare state is for and, therefore what outcomes we should be measuring.  We may find in fact that not all increases in public expenditure on the welfare state are necessarily enhancing the stated objectives.  Similarly agreed cuts would not necessarily diminish the desired outcomes.
Perhapsrather than being philosophical, it is better for us to seek a historical explanation of the premises and circumstances around which we have originated the Welfare State, and how and from where did the push for continuous additions come from.
Theprincipal rationale for the Welfare State was that of government intervention with the aim of transferring incomes from the haves to have-nots of society, that is, the unemployed, the aged, the sick, the persons with disabilities, the families without a bread-winner.
Thatwas a time when lay organisations, mostly religious gave generous assistance, when the extended families helped in times of need, looked after the aged family members, the sick members, and all those in need.  Based on the premise of a family with a male bread-winner providing income for the family, while the female adult member looked after the social and educational needs of the children.  One must also say that at that time our population was growing fast, with big families providing many children ready to help supplement the family income and help in the family with its needs.  I would hazard to state that if we consider the unpaid family workers, we can also state that the ratio of workers to the whole population was higher than today.
Inview of these specific circumstances the government could afford to be generous in those areas we now consider the core competencies of the welfare state.  As it is to be expected in a small society as ours this rate of state handouts quickly became entrenched benchmarks against which successive administrations would be measured.
Onanother front another principle was introduced.  This is the principal of universality.  One possible reason for its introduction and wide application is that the taxpayers, independent of the income level they were at, wanted to be included too in the annual distribution of benefits, even just to receive some sort of token benefit on Budget Day.  It was as if the bitter pill of tax payment would be sweetened somewhat by the participation in the now universal welfare state system.

A second reason was that the government administration saw in this principal the avoidance of the stigma and the administrative expense attached to means testing.  For all these reasons we achieved a situation where each year a considerable amount of transfer payments are collected through taxation from the society at large only to be distributed according to a set of very complex criteria to that same society.  

Thesystem of annual budgets brings with it naturally a certain amount of incrementalism, nearly always upwards of course.  Pressures for extending coverage, adding new programmes, correcting anomalies, and raising benefit levels.  Most of these increases are not even discretionary.  They have become automatically linked with one another, causing the slightest change in one benefit to trigger a whole chain of changes elsewhere in the system and which many a times had not even been factored in by the administrators.  This notwithstanding, budgets are always criticized on the morrow for not doing enough with some other more deserving groups within society.
Ineach sector, whether it is education, pensions, health, or social security we have achieved levels which, if only they could be sustainable, would be the envy of many countries more economically advanced than ours.
Perhapsa few examples would illustrate our point.

·                                      Tertiary education is a case in point.  It provides not only free tuition and financial assistance for the purchase of books, personal computers and related items, but goes beyond and donates extra pocket money irrespective of the need of the student concerned.  

·                                      Health – where the most advanced interventions costing thousands of pounds are demanded and obtained with no thought that even private insurance in similar circumstances would expect some form of capping or excess payment.  

·                                      Pensions – where we have an indexation system that works in real time to adjust pensions to levels and in ways that would send any actuarian crazy.  

·                                      Social Security – where benefits are sculptured to the needs of particular individuals, and where the individuals’ situation is adjusted to fit particular benefits.  

Thequestion is.  Are these practices truly sustainable?
Ourcurrent and projected economic and demographic indicators show that they are not.
Beforewe fall into a negative spell of doom and gloom, we need to ask ourselves:

·                                      Are we convinced that the social problems the welfare state is aimed to address can only be solved by throwing more money at them? And  

·                                      Is our current welfare state best suited to meet today’s changed social and economic circumstances and tomorrow’s challenges?  

Theanswer to both these questions is a resounding NO.  That is why we must implement reforms.
Letus now examine how and why the premises and circumstances on which the welfare state has been built, have indeed changed.
Letus start with the family.  The extended family structure has given way to the nuclear family which in turn is changing into so many varied structures that bewilders the mind.  Single parenthood is one of them.  Where before we expected the younger members of the family to support the aged, we now even find cases where pensioners are financially supporting the young members in the family.  As for the ever increasing numbers of senior citizens, thanks to advances in modern medicine, these too are being handed over to the state to look after as a matter of fact.
Demographicchanges in conjunction with a low labour force participation rate and an ever increasing dependency ratio, increasing the financial support burden on an ever declining relative smaller base.  At a time when reaching 100 has long lost its news value, we are still stuck to a pensionable age which was set during a completely different era.
Eventhe once revered social wage is changing its meaning in a fully globalised world where wages are benchmarked by what other similar workers or professionals are earning abroad.
Thesame for insurance and saving.  It is right and proper for the state to provide the necessary insurance and if need be carry out the saving on behalf of the individual when the financial institutions are absent, or rudimentary.  It is not the same when strong and reputable financial institutions, regulated by a modern institutional and legal framework, can provide a better and more efficient service.  It is the role of the state to provide a service of last resort for the uninsured and the poor, but should it continue with its paternalistic role to provide and interfere with the free decisions of a better educated labour force.
Inshort we need to underline that problems become structural and sometimes reach crises proportions only if our systems do not adapt to the changing circumstances.  Private businesses have long learnt that change is the order of the day and to survive the business must adapt to the changing business environment.  The public sector has likewise to face the changing reality and adapt.  It must be admitted that the public sector and with the society at large is more complex and is slower to realize the need for change and slower still to carry out the needed change.  But change we must.
Competitivenessrequires that all economic activity whether in the public or private sectors should not be burdened by additional costs due to public programmes which the country can ill afford or which are outdated and stuck obstinately to past circumstances.
Competitivenessis another issue crying for major reforms in our burocracy, work ethic and enterprise governability.   These are issues that must be addressed and that will be addressed.
Ofcourse society is made up of many special interest groups which are just interested in watching their patch and for their own reasons maintain the status quo.  The long term public interest demands otherwise.
Ixxerja din l-istqarrija Icon socials Icon socials Icon socials Icon socials

Stqarrijiet Oħra:

STQARRIJA MILL-UFFIĊĊJU TAD-DEPUTAT PRIM MINISTRU U MINISTERU GĦAS-SAĦĦA  Inawgurat bust ta’ Ġorġ tal-Mużew fl-Isptar Mater Dei b’tifkira tal-ħidma tiegħu fost dawk vulnerabbli

PR261936

STQARRIJA MILL-UFFIĊĊJU TAD-DEPUTAT PRIM MINISTRU U MINISTERU GĦAS-SAĦĦA I...

PRESS RELEASE BY THE MINISTRY FOR ENERGY, THE ENVIRONMENT AND THE REGENERATION OF THE GRAND HARBOUR  ERA launches anniversary publication: A decade of protecting Malta’s natural future

PR261935en

PRESS RELEASE BY THE MINISTRY FOR ENERGY, THE ENVIRONMENT AND THE REGENERAT...

Aktar Stqarrijiet Right arrow