Left arrow Mur Lura

SPEECH BY THE HON. GIOVANNA DEBONO, MINISTER FOR GOZO, AT THE SEMINAR ORGANISED BY THE FOUNDATION FOR TRANSPORT STUDIES: TRANSPORT, INDUSTRY AND INSULARITY" – MGARR GOZO – 31.10.2003

pr1303
Date Icon 31/10/2003

Mr Chairman,

I should first of all like to thank the Foundationfor Transport Studies for organising this Seminar on Transport, Industry and Insularity, a topic of great relevance to Gozo.
I congratulate you, Mr Chairman, not only on the wayyou chaired the Conference but also on the way you laid out the themes for discussion. As we are fast approaching the day of our accession to the EU it was very apt to have the first part of the Conference discussing the main topic in the EU context and then zooming in and focusing on Gozo in the second part.
I must confess I enjoyed the proceedings of theConference – the keynote speeches as well as the interventions from the floor. The subjects discussed are very close to my heart and are part of my daily life, as a Gozitan suffering from double insularity as well as Minister for the island of region of Gozo.
In the European context, as Minister for Gozo, I havebeen actively campaigning for the cause of the island regions mainly, but not only, through the General Assembly of the Conference of Peripheral Maritime Regions of Europe, the Islands Commission and the InterMediterranean Commission. It was only last month that I addressed the General Assembly in St. Malo, France where I strongly advocated the introduction of the principle of territorial cohesion in the EU Constitutional Treaty and that this concept be translated into concrete measures. I stressed this point again only two weeks ago in Rome where I took part in a Ministerial Meeting on "The Role of the Regions in the European Union" organised by the EU Presidency.
I am saying this because the process of Europeanconstruction now places the island issue in a wider context than that of their national context alone. However at this point in time the question is how and by what means can the Union’s Institutions, legislation and policies demonstrate with regard to the island the flexibility that their situation warrants and justifies. There are at present two possible scenarios.
In the first scenario, the Community would recognizethe special nature of the Island context. It could introduce mechanisms that permit a certain flexibility in the application of Community policies in the islands and enable them to be integrated into the single market under equitable conditions. Moreover it could continue to show solidarity with the islands by taking account of the permanent nature of the structural handicaps.
In the second scenario, the Community would givepreference to an approach based on standardisation, and would refuse to concede any differentiated treatment to the islands on the pretext that this would call into question both its purpose and its functioning. In this situtation, it would become very difficult to implement economic and social policies adapted to the islands’ stuation.
To date, the Community’s attitude has blown hot andcold between these two scenarios. On one hand the adoption of the Treaty of Amsterdam gave certain recognition to the special situation of the islands with the modification of Article 158 on economic and social cohesion and with the adoption of Annexe Declaration No. 30 which recognised their permanent structural handicaps. The conclusions of the Nice Summit subsequently reaffirmed the possibility of adopting specific measures for the islands. On the other hand, however, these provisions and declarations have so far not been adequately followed by concrete measures and developments in Community legislation.
It is therefore to our great satisfaction that theConvention on the Future of Europe has now provided an opportunity to give a clear direction and to allow the situation to evolve. In fact the Convention has recommended the inclusion of territorial cohesion as one of the fundamental objectives of the Union, complementary to the priciples of economic and social cohesion. The principle of territorial cohesion would allow the Community to assert its determination to take into account the diverse nature of its territories, to provide them with a genuine equality of opportunity and to contribute to their harmonious and balanced development. Such approach would have a positive impact on certain Community policies, foremost amongst which the transport policy by improving the accessibility to the peripheries. This approach would of course in no way apply exclusively to the islands, but, as a text book example of peripherality, islands would undoubtedly be among the first to benefit from such evolution. But the debate still goes on and the recommendations of the Convention have yet to be approved by the forthcoming Inter-governmental Conference.
It was in this context that I made my strong plea atthe St. Malo Conference. It was in this context that in their Final Declaration, the 149 member regions of the Conference are urging the representatives of the States at the next Inter-governmental Conference not to make any changes to the proposal on territorial cohesion put forward by the Convention.
Let me now follow the route taken by this Conferenceand pass on to focus specifically on Gozo. I do not want to sound boastful, but I think that never as in the past five years have the double-insularity status of Gozo and the permanent handicaps resulting therefrom been so widely and strongly made known not only in Malta but also all over Europe. It is, for instance, due to this strategy that in the Gozo Special Needs Assessment Study, commissioned by the European Union, we find very apt references to them. Let me quote some.
"Gozo suffers from what is known asdouble-insularity, since it is on the periphery of another small island. This necessitates air or sea transport with mainland Malta for connections with the rest of the world. There are various problems associated with such double-insularity, including constraints on the movement of persons, goods and services, due to the limited, uncertain and discontinuous accessibility to the island, as well as financial expense and time delays. These factors impact negatively on all sectors of the economy, notably tourism, manufacturing and agriculture and also limit the accessibility to important services such as education and health."
I quoted that part of the report because itacknowledges the fact that double-insularity is a horizontal issue affecting all the activity on Gozo. The Study does not however stop there. It deals with sectoral constraints for Gozo and stresses the restrictions in transport facilities and services. In fact it specifically says that " Gozitan manufacturing concerns incur additional costs, when compared to their Maltese counterparts, due to the double-insularity factor, in transactions relating to the importation of raw materials, machinery and spare parts and the exportation of the final product. They also face problems associated with uncertainties, discontinuous accessibility and time delays. Additional costs are also incurred in connection with business commuting to Malta."
The study also says that Gozitan farmers facepractically the same problems.
However the EU Commission experts went even furtherand said that "transport is assigned special consideration in this study due to the ‘double-insularity’ charecteristic of Gozo, which is a permanent handicap to the movement of goods, services and persons, to and from the island. As already explained, all goods, services and persons reaching the Maltese Islands from the rest of the world enter and leave Gozo through air and sea ports, located on mainland Malta. This of course affects the competitiveness of all business in Gozo. It is practically impossible for Gozo to have international sea and air ports, due to the small size of the island and its environmental fragility."
"Gozitan users of the ferry service faceuncertainties due to the disruptions of the service, mostly associated with the absence of an all-weather harbour at Cirkewwa. During bouts of inclement weather, the ferry finds it difficult to moor at the Cirkewwa quay, and the service is curtailed, leading to unacceptable delays or to the total interruption of the service. Given that Gozo relies almost totally on this service for its tourist trade and for the carriage of materials and finished goods, such delays and interruptions lead to high costs for Gozitan business, and to discomfort for passengers. There are incalculable risks regarding travel planning.
"Another cause of uncertainty relates to thefact that the timetable of the ferry service is, as expected, determined by Gozo Channel, the company operating the service. Gozitan importers and exporters, as well as operators in the tourism industry, experience service restrictions during the winter months. In addition, there is always the fear that certain loss making trips could be cancelled for commercial reasons."
Moreover, the experts also acknowledged that"the double-insularity of Gozo negatively affects tourist influx to Gozo, due to the expense involved in the inter-island crossing , as well as the discontinuities and uncertainties associated with the transport service. Uncertainties give rise to risks which often keep back tour operators and travel agents from marketing Gozo as a tourist destination."
Allow me here to degress somewhat to say that it isquite a hard task to make an expert from Inner London or from the heart of today’s Berlin or, for that matter, from the centre of Malta – our bigger island – to understand the handicaps of double insularity and the importance to Gozo of the inter-island transport links. To make non double-islanders understand all this, we have to put them in our shoes, even if only perceivably. We have to ask the Malta expert , for example, to keep within the local context, what he would do if all access roads to his village were totally closed for five hours at night and if during the day he could go or leave home at a fixed time only once every two hours and against payment. Would he have chosen to buy a house in that village and reside there? If he were an operator in the tourist industry would he invest in a hotel or a restaurant there? If he were an entrepreneur in the manufacturing industry, would he set up his business there knowing the restricted access and the substantial sums of money he would have to pay to enter and leave the village with his imports and exports?
I think I have made the point clear enough and thereis no need for further elaboration. So I now go back to my main line of thought.
I referred at some length to the Gozo Special NeedsAssessment Study as it was on the basis of its findings that all the EU Member States accepted the inclusion in Malta’s Accession Treaty of a Declaration on the Island Region of Gozo. In this Declaration it is noted "that the island region of Gozo has economic and social specificities as well as handicaps arising from the combined effects of its double insularity, its environmental fragility, its small population size, coupled with a high population density as well as its inherent limited resources."
It was also on the basis of the same Study that inthe Single Programming Document, that is the development plan for Malta to be co-funded by the European Union, there is a Priority Axis on the "Distinctivness of Gozo" as a result of which 10% of the European Structural funds that Malta will receive will be allocated for the additional efforts that Gozo needs to catch up with the rest of Malta and eventually with other European regions. It was also on the basis of the acknowledged distinctivness of Gozo resulting mainly from its double-insularity that a Regional Project Committee is to be set up in agreement with the European Commission to pre-select projects for Gozo and to ensure their implimentation by the authorities concerned.
I will be setting up this Committee in the comingdays and I auger that the economic and social partners who will be represented on it will work together so that we could reap the maximum benefits of what was sowed in the past years.
Ixxerja din l-istqarrija Icon socials Icon socials Icon socials Icon socials

Stqarrijiet Oħra:

STQARRIJA MILL-UFFIĊĊJU TAD-DEPUTAT PRIM MINISTRU U MINISTERU GĦAS-SAĦĦA  Inawgurat bust ta’ Ġorġ tal-Mużew fl-Isptar Mater Dei b’tifkira tal-ħidma tiegħu fost dawk vulnerabbli

PR261936

STQARRIJA MILL-UFFIĊĊJU TAD-DEPUTAT PRIM MINISTRU U MINISTERU GĦAS-SAĦĦA I...

PRESS RELEASE BY THE MINISTRY FOR ENERGY, THE ENVIRONMENT AND THE REGENERATION OF THE GRAND HARBOUR  ERA launches anniversary publication: A decade of protecting Malta’s natural future

PR261935en

PRESS RELEASE BY THE MINISTRY FOR ENERGY, THE ENVIRONMENT AND THE REGENERAT...

Aktar Stqarrijiet Right arrow