Left arrow Mur Lura

SPEECH BY THE HON. JOE BORG, MINISTER OF FOREIGN AFFAIRS, AT THE 726TH WILTON PARK CONFERENCE – MADRID - 28 OCTOBER 2003

pr1280
Date Icon 28/10/2003

HOW CAN DECISIONS BE BEST MADE IN AN ENLARGED EU?"

Excellencies,Distinguished guests, Ladies and Gentlemen,
The title of this talk is an excellent place to startfor anyone wanting to understand what this Intergovernmental Conference is all about. How, indeed, can decisions best be taken in an enlarged European Union?
It is clear that any decision-making mechanismdevised for the European Union will need to pass two tests.

Firstly, it will need to pass the test of legitimacy. Every one of the 25 Member and Acceding States is a democracy whose government derives its legitimacy directly from its citizens.

The Union itself, however, despite the fact that itsParliament progressively grows in stature and power with the passing years, derives much of its legitimacy from its constituent states. The resulting greater distance from its citizens, this detachment, has come to be recognised as one of the key challenges facing the Union today.
Bluntly put, Europe’s citizens do not seem to feelthat the workings of the Union directly affect them. When they do, all too often it is in a negative sense when they feel that their way of life, or their livelihood, may be threatened by decisions that they perceive are taken by the notoriously faceless, nameless bureaucrats in Brussels.
If our Union is to be a strong, healthy and vibrantone, then Europe’s citizens must feel that they own it. They must feel that it is not something remote and beyond their control, but something that they have a stake in, something that, collectively, they can mould and shape. A first step towards achieving this is to make sure that they can understand it.
The very sophistication of the European project nowmeans that it has grown greatly in complexity. It has developed a language and logic of its own that make it daunting and intimidating to the uninitiated. This, then is one of the key tasks of this IGC – to slash away the cobwebs, to remove complexity and obscurity and to replace them with crispness and simplicity.
When, therefore, we repeat the phrase that has nowbecome almost a cliché - that the Convention and the IGC must bring "Europe closer to the citizen" – we are not just being politically correct. We are setting ourselves a task upon the success or failure of which depends nothing less then the very health of our Union.
Yet even if the decision-making mechanism that isproduced passes the legitimacy test, it will still have to pass yet another test of equal importance – the test of efficiency.
The fewer the actors involved in taking a decision,the more efficient and fast one expects the decision-making process to be. Next year the Union will be made up of 25 states, all with their own unique perspectives and interests. The number of permutations and combinations of viewpoints and positions will grow exponentially. Yet, if the Union is to succeed, the length of decision-making must not be allowed similarly to increase; if anything decisions need to be taken faster, without any decrease in the quality of those decisions. While achieving this, however, care must also be taken that, despite the need for speed, the interests and needs of the individual states are given due consideration.
Having set ourselves these two tests, let us now seehow we are doing, first referring to the work done by the Convention, and now in the Intergovernmental Conference.
The Convention went beyond traditional norms ofpolicy-making in the European Union. It drew on the interests of other players in the arena, ensuring that the text of the draft Constitutional Treaty it produced was as all-encompassing as possible. This, together with the fact that the Convention also included representatives from the acceding states, means that the draft Constitutional Treaty it produced broadly reflects the interests of the stakeholders.
On the whole the Convention came up with a balancedtext, the result of a compromise amongst all those involved. The Heads of Government and Heads of State convening in Laeken clearly understood that the future of the European Union was not solely the domain of politicians, diplomats and bureaucrats. These leaders felt the need to ensure that their own citizens, at both the European and national level, participated in this reform process. The Convention has hopefully helped, in some small way, in bringing Europe’s citizens closer to a better understanding of their Union. This is commendable and should set a standard for popular consultation with regard to institutional change for years to come. We should not, however, delude ourselves that the Union has moved close enough to the citizen. If it is ever adequately to do so, efforts in this regard must be ongoing and strenuous.
Now it is the turn of the Inter-GovernmentalConference to examine the text produced by the Convention and to discuss, amend and improve it. One issue that will be decided in the Intergovernmental Conference that will have a determining effect on the overall efficiency of the decision-making mechanism that we put in place, is that regarding the scope and application of Qualified Majority Voting. There are, of course, many community policy areas where the introduction of Qualified Majority Voting is welcome, even necessary, if decision-making is to avoid paralysis, and movements in this direction in the draft Constitutional Treaty are welcome.
But the need for efficiency has also got to bebalanced by the need to take into consideration the specificities, needs and interests of individual states in certain key areas. The Convention recognised this, and the draft Constitutional Treaty kept certain polices such as foreign policy, defence and taxation as areas where unanimity should be maintained. With regard to the scope of application of Qualified Majority Voting, therefore, Malta is largely satisfied with the draft Constitutional text.
With regard to the actual definition of whatconstitutes a qualified majority, the draft Constitutional Treaty removes the Nice system of weighted voting and replaces it with a double majority mechanism. Thus, for a proposal to go through it will need the support of a simple majority of member states representing at least three fifths of the EU population. One understands that, with nineteen small member states out of twenty-five next year, there was a concern that the population should be given its due importance in the decision making process. However, we thus far remain unconvinced that it is necessary to discard a solution based on weighted votes in this regard before it has actually been tested. Having said this, we remain open to a solution that respects the needs of small states.
From the method of decision-making, we now have toconsider who will be taking the decisions. A novelty within the Draft Constitutional Treaty concerns the Presidency of the Council. The Conference is currently debating as to whether we should have a fixed presidency for each of the Council formations, or whether to adopt a system of rotation. On our part, we would have preferred to maintain the present system whereby the Presidency rotates between Member States every six months. However there is merit in the argument that a constantly changing Presidency does not allow for sufficient continuity in the work of the Council. We are therefore open to alternative arrangements that would provide efficiency and continuity while at the same time fully respecting the principle of equality between Member States.
Various options are also being considered by theIntergovernmental Conference. We have seen the emergence of the idea of Team Presidencies for Council, with the exception of the Foreign Affairs Council, where consensus seems to favour long-term presidencies under the chairmanship of the European Foreign Affairs Minister. The composition of each Team Presidency must be devised in such a way that the council formations are split along equitable lines enabling each member irrespective of size, to chair one of the more important formations. At the same time, we also agree with the proposal that the presidency of the General Affairs Council would rotate on a six-monthly basis between each of the Member States within the team. I had occasion last week to write to Minister Frattini that Malta could accept the Italian Presidency proposal of a four Member State Team Presidency lasting for two years, with the General Affairs Council being presided over by each Member State of the team in turn. I am confident that the IGC will lead to a successful outcome in this respect.
As for the European Council itself, the Conventionproposed two major changes. Firstly, it is suggested that the European Council should be elevated to the status of an institution, and secondly, it was suggested that it should have an elected President at its helm. While the former proposal received general support almost without exception, the prospect of ending the rotation of the European Council Presidency was met with strong opposition by smaller countries, both at the Convention as well as the Intergovernmental Conference.
Here again, we see a number of countries – mainlysmall – interested in maintaining the current system and therefore not relinquishing the rotating presidency, whilst others back the changes proposed in the Draft Constitutional Treaty. There is no doubt that there is a certain amount of prestige connected to the Presidency of the European Council. The current system is perfectly egalitarian in that it ensures that Member States will be at the helm of the highest decision-making body of the European Union periodically. On the other hand those favouring the elected president argue that this would bring greater continuity to the execution of Union policies.
The European Parliament has progressively seen itsdecision-making powers increase. From a consultative role, parliament is nowadays deeply involved in the decision-making process of the Union, in particular through co-decision. This procedure further integrates our elected euro-parliamentarians, and through them the European citizen, into the shaping of Europe and this process should be encouraged.
The role of national parliaments should be furtherenhanced as well. At the Convention, the representative of the Maltese Government tabled a proposal to the effect that members of national parliaments be given the possibility to communicate to the President of the European Parliament recommendations on aspects of Commission legislative proposal which, in their opinion, may have a bearing on European citizens.

Mr Chairman,

Human nature is never fully satisfied with what it has. As soon as we see a new invention on the market, we immediately feel the urge to improve it. I would say the same goes for politics, political systems and decision-making processes. Nearly one month since the opening of the Intergovernmental Conference, I am today more confident than previously that we will have a timely and successful outcome – an improved system and an improved European Union that is at the same time efficient and responsive to the needs and aspirations of its citizens. Doubtless, some way down the line, and in the light of new experience, we will need to revisit some of the decisions we are taking at this Intergovernmental Conference. When that time comes I am sure that Wilton Park will organise another conference as interesting and useful as this one to the benefit of all participants.

Thank you.

Ixxerja din l-istqarrija Icon socials Icon socials Icon socials Icon socials

Stqarrijiet Oħra:

STQARRIJA MILL-UFFIĊĊJU TAD-DEPUTAT PRIM MINISTRU U MINISTERU GĦAS-SAĦĦA  Inawgurat bust ta’ Ġorġ tal-Mużew fl-Isptar Mater Dei b’tifkira tal-ħidma tiegħu fost dawk vulnerabbli

PR261936

STQARRIJA MILL-UFFIĊĊJU TAD-DEPUTAT PRIM MINISTRU U MINISTERU GĦAS-SAĦĦA I...

PRESS RELEASE BY THE MINISTRY FOR ENERGY, THE ENVIRONMENT AND THE REGENERATION OF THE GRAND HARBOUR  ERA launches anniversary publication: A decade of protecting Malta’s natural future

PR261935en

PRESS RELEASE BY THE MINISTRY FOR ENERGY, THE ENVIRONMENT AND THE REGENERAT...

Aktar Stqarrijiet Right arrow