SPEECH BY THE HON. AUSTIN GATT, MINISTER FOR INFORMATION TECHNOLOGY AND INVESTMENT, AT THE MAMO TCV ADVOCATES CONFERENCE “DATA PROTECTION LAW IN MALTA: PRACTICAL IMPLICATIONS” – ST.JULIAN’S – 25.09.2003
“Freedom” has been defined as the power of an individual to do what he or she likes as long as what they do does not impinge on anybody else’s right to do what they like. The definition itself is not simply a basic philosophical concept. Its structure bears the clue that any new liberty gained bears the responsibility to respect the liberties of others.
It is nowadays a century-old cliché to say that technology “frees” us of time and money, creates new opportunities and opens up new possibilities of profit, material and spiritual. The contemporary burst of innovation has increased exponentially our freedom to teach and learn, create and promote, buy and sell. Our liberties have grown. With them we experience a greater need for the state to regulate the environment surrounding these new liberties to ensure that technology is not exploited at the expense of individual freedoms.
Sacred among these freedoms, is the right to privacy. This right has been threatened, at times compromised, by the ever-growing volumes of data stored in ever-shrinking electronic containers. It is wrong to suggest that there is anything inherently wrong with technology. Nihilism – and its more recent imitation in the form of governments blocking the importation of computers because of the threats alleged to be inherent to them – is thankfully a thing of the past.
Nihilists were afraid of machines. Socialists were afraid of computers. They were both wrong. We would be wrong to create and stimulate suspicion around the present technology that allows us to collect data, analyse it, share it, and use it to better serve our customers.
We would also be wrong, however, to allow a limitless anarchy and pretend that the abuse of this technology has not, in the past, violated individuals’ right to privacy. The Government is aware of its responsibility to seek a proper balance between allowing technology to stimulate growth and an improved quality of life and ensure that abuse is curtailed and penalised.
Two years ago, Parliament approved our Data Protection Bill that clearly defines limits to which owners of data on identifiable individuals can retain, share or use that data. This summer we have brought into force that Data Protection Act that gives individuals the right to know that data identifying them is being held, why it is being held, and how it is being used.
It is beyond discussion that information is the most important vehicle in conducting business and providing service. The Act does not aim to defeat this reality. Doing so is both impossible and undesirable. The Government aims to ensure that this reality does not compromise the fundamental human and constitutional right of individuals to live in privacy.
You will today be discussing the practical implications of this law and I note you will be doing so by focusing on specific sectors and the implications of the Act on each of them. The fundamental, practical implication is that we need to implement this law. Implementation implies changes in the way some business sectors work, and sometimes, even if our intentions might have always been genuine and aimed at providing a good service to our client base, we now find our old habits and practices out of order. Satisfying the new rules and meeting the new challenge has a cost, which we cannot overlook.
It is necessary and desirable to discuss practical implications. It is mistaken and wrong to loose sight of the why we are doing this. I am convinced that we all share the view that in providing a good service to our customers we do not wish at any point to be a threat to our customers’ right to privacy.
Following the 2001 adoption of the Data Protection Act, Parliament further refined the law to ensure the autonomy and independence of the Commissioner for Data Protection and increasing the fines given to perpetrators abusing ownership of data. We are, indeed, serious about this.
Even so, the realities keep changing, and therefore regulation requires constant rethinking and updating. Newer crimes, need newer laws and newer penalties.
Anyone using e-mail, everyone in this room I am sure, and increasingly more people out there, are victims of an avalanche of unsolicited e-mails, mostly trying to sell adult content, or some get-rich-in-minutes financial scam. The problem of Spam mail is growing to an unbearable decree. A recent EU estimate puts the figure of Spam mail at half of all global e-mail traffic. Malta can confirm this standard. The Government network, itself a good representative sample of e-mail use in Malta, has in the last three months filtered out as unwanted junk half of all e-mails it has handled.
Recipients of Spam are faced by the daily nuisance of filtering the mail they get. That nuisance is cashed in loss of time and money. That is only a small fraction of the problem. The sheer volume of this junk is not simply words written pointlessly on the ether. They are a physical and gross waste of bandwidth, the coal and steel of today’s industry. Spam mail also undermines the public’s confidence in these technologies, which in turn might result in scepticism on the viability of these technologies and all that they might bring about.
I speak of anyone using e-mail and that might not be everyone. Just about everyone uses mobile phones, and just about everyone has received unsolicited SMSs. Thankfully this problem has not reached volumes comparable with Spam e-mail, but when and if it does, it would make the mobile phone, that most important technological innovation of the present, into an unworkable nuisance.
It has come to the point where we must declare war on Spam mail. The Government is drawing up new policies that, following a full consultation process, will be translated in new rules regulating this environment.
Of course this is not simply a matter of rules and regulations. Technology must be used to help regulate technology. That might sound like a paradox, but for every arsenic there must be an antidote. Internet Service Providers may either choose to transfer the added cost of wasted bandwidth to their customers, or set-up effective filtering software that nips the problem in its bud. It is positive to note that some ISPs are already adopting the latter strategy as a matter of course.
We should also think of punitive measures for the perpetrators of these, not merely annoying, but truly harmful and offensive crimes. Italy has recently announced prison sentences for Spammers who are proven to have committed the crime in pursuit of profit. The UK has adopted milder penalties, but in any case considers Spam a criminal offence.
We are studying these models and are seeking the best solution to this challenge of our days.
The Government remains committed to two objectives that we consider anything but a contradiction:
- One. Ensuring that technology “frees” up our time for a better quality of life, better choice of products and services, better opportunities for business and profit; and
- Two: Ensuring that the fundamental human right to privacy and a high level of quality of life is enhanced, never threatened nor usurped by those who abuse technology.
Today’s discussion shows that we are not alone in this commitment. The public is assured of a widespread commitment in the industry and in anyone related to it that we all want to keep the great technological space we are building together a safe place to work, buy, sell and live in.
Stqarrijiet Oħra:
PR261936
STQARRIJA MILL-UFFIĊĊJU TAD-DEPUTAT PRIM MINISTRU U MINISTERU GĦAS-SAĦĦA I...
PR261935en