Left arrow Mur Lura

THE BOLOGNA PROCESS - RECOGNISING QUALIFICATIONS: REMOVING OBSTACLES TO PROFESSIONAL MOBILITY

pr1000
Date Icon 28/08/2003
“The University and otherMaltese higher education institutions must work together to ensure that the quality of their diplomas and degrees will pass the quality assurance test of the external evaluations and accreditation agencies that are being set up as part of the process leading to the European Higher Education Area.  This will be of great benefit to Maltese students and workers who will be better placed to further their studies and training abroad and to be more mobile in the development of their careers.” Education Minister Louis Galea said when he was addressing a seminar for top officials of the University, MCAST, the Malta Centre for Restoration (MCR), the Institute for Tourism Studies (ITS) and ETC, at the Mediterranean Conference Centre.
TheSeminar was organised by the Ministry of Education for authorities of Higher Education to ensure the best networking possible between Maltese institutions in the implementation of what has become known as “The Bologna Process”.  The process is gradually constructing one European Area of Higher Education of great significance both on a local and European level.  The University of Malta is already very actively involved in the process.
MinisterGalea said that the Ministers of 29 European countries including himself signed the Bologna Declaration on the 19th June 1999.  This declaration builds on the Sorbonne Declaration, signed in May 1998 by the Ministers of Education of France, Italy, Germany and the United Kingdom.  The Bologna declaration is a key statement on higher education policy and reform in Europe.  It is a process – referred to as the Bologna Process – driven by the participating countries but also involving the European Commission, the CRE-Association of European Universities, the Confederation of Rectors Conferences of the European Union, the Council of Europe, the Student Platform and EURASHE as partners in the follow-up process.  Malta is represented in all these arenas.
Thesignificance of the Bologna Declaration to Malta is particularly relevant to the recognition of qualifications within an enlarged Europe.  There has been a concern for the ‘adoption of a system of easily readable and comparable degrees’.  In this context mention is made of the Diploma Supplement, in other words an academic transcript with relevance and standing throughout the European Union and beyond. The Bologna declaration also links its use to the reform of higher education systems, where specific reference is made to the adoption of a system essentially based on two main cycles (bachelor and master levels).  There is also direct emphasis in the declaration on the role of higher education in preparing students for the labour market as highlighted by the statement ‘the degree awarded after the first cycle shall also be relevant to the European labour market as an appropriate level of qualification.  The establishment of a credit system, which has been in operation in Malta since 1997, guarantees the European Credit Transfer System - ECTS - which is the backbone of the Socrates-Erasmus programme, by which Maltese higher education students can become mobile to another EU member state and vice-versa.  This is one of the programmes that the Nationalist Government has secured from the fruit of pre-accession to membership and will be strengthened on accession with Malta as a full member of the EU.
MinisterLouis Galea said the law enacted by Parliament last September, and the establishment of the NARIC Office (National Academic Recognition Information Centre), will facilitate the mutual recognition of qualifications and make it easier to support mobility.  In recent years much work has been done locally to raise standards in education and also to establish criteria for new standards when these did not exist.  He said that the creation of a wide variety of study and training programmes, such as those offered by the Institute of Health Care within the University of Malta, the ITS and MCAST, are evidence that the Government sees different routes to qualifications.  This ties in with the Europe-wide philosophy that every citizen had a right to have some form of recognisable certification.  It is the Government’s intention that one of the measures being taken by law is for the non-traditional professions to be also better regulated and certified.  This sort of confidence that the Government has of its citizens in operating within an enlarged European Community.
MinisterGalea also mentioned the European Network for Quality Assessment (ENQA) which has been established for EU countries and candidate countries.  “This is a step in the right direction” said Dr. Galea and added that “mobility should not be at the expense of quality.  In fact the Bologna Declaration highlights this by stating unequivocally that member states should be involved in the ‘promotion of European co-operation in quality assurance with a view to developing comparable criteria and methodologies’.  University and other Maltese higher education institutions must work together to ensure that their diplomas and degrees will pass the quality assurance test of the external evaluations and accreditation agencies that are being set up as part of the process leading to the European Higher Education Area.  This will be of great benefit to Maltese Students and Workers who will be better placed to further their studies and training abroad and to be more mobile in the development of their careers.  This is the way forward”
LouisGalea said that next month he will be in Berlin together with other European Ministers to agree on the way forward in higher education.  Malta will be both a decision-maker and a co-planner.  The choice of membership has assured this position.

Background information follows

DOI  28.08.2003

Background Information

While much as been achieved by the Bologna Declaration, the backbone of the framework is the Council of Europe/Unesco Lisbon Recognition Convention and the EU directives on recognition for professional purposes. For academic recognition, the higher education institutions operate within a general framework of institutional autonomy; this is also the case of the University of Malta.  While they are bound by general regulations, there are therefore limits to direct state influence on the recognition decision reached by individual institutions.  Nevertheless, Malta hopes to be both beneficiary and contributor to the development of the European Higher Education area by 2010.  The discussion that took place in Parliament on the 17th of September on the presentation of the bill regarding the General Systems Directive was an occasion for celebrating our success story in higher education.  It shows that Malta can be an active participant, a healthy partner and an influential figure in the building of this Area.  Organised mobility programmes, such as the Socrates programme or the newly instituted Erasmus Mundus presuppose institutional agreements on recognition.  As these kinds of academic mobility become more important and fundamental for today’s youth and tomorrow’s adults, the need for institutional agreements, especially on the recognition of periods of study, will increase.  This will be particularly important for recognition for academic purposes, but will indirectly be important also for recognition for professional purposes.  In order to look to the future of recognition, it may be useful to take a brief look at the past.  Substantial progress has been made toward improving recognition over the past fifteen years or so.  Important achievements include: 

·        The Lisbon Recognition Convention which provides an overall framework for the recognition of qualification in the European region;

·        European Directives 89/48/EEC and 92/51/EEC which provide the framework for the recognition of qualifications for the purpose of access to regulated professions in the countries of the European Union and the European Economic Area

·        ECTS (European Credit Transfer System) – already integrated with the University of Malta’s structures, and its ‘cousin’ the Diploma Supplement, which helps in situating a qualification within the education system to which it belongs.

·        The ENIC/NARIC networks (the Nationalist Government established a National Academic Recognition Information Centre to strengthen compliance with the Lisbon Convention).  Malta in fact hosted a joint meeting of the European Network of National Information centres – ENIC (Council of Europe) and NARIC (under the auspices of the European Commission) in June of this year. 

·        The Recommendation on International Access Qualification, primarily developed by UNESCO and adopted by the Lisbon Convention in June 1999, will facilitate the recognition of school leaving qualifications not belonging to a national education system for the purpose of access to higher education. 

Allthe above are in line with the recognition of standards.  Standards should be taken to mean agreed norms for conduct or profile rather than a complete harmonization of degrees and study programmes, which would go against the principle of subsidiarity within the EU or the wider European tradition of diversity.  Recognition is a concept that should be flexible enough to allow candidates to move easily not only between education systems but also between subject areas, in order to facilitate career orientation.
Anotherimportant consideration relates to the fact that recognition will become an increasingly important issue for the labour market.  One may suggest that three kinds of recognition exist:

·        Academic recognition;

·        Professional recognition for access to regulated professions;

·        Professional recognition for access to the non-regulated parts of the labour market.

Ifthe labour market is increasingly an international one (especially with globalisation), it follows that recognition for the purpose of access to the non-regulated part of the labour marked will also be increasingly important.  This personal assessment will need to delve beyond formal higher education qualifications but also into access for the non-regulated part of the labour market and in the case of persons wanting to return to the higher education system to further and/or improve their qualifications on the basis of both a previous higher education qualification and/or significant work experience.
Itis clear that employers in Malta will increasingly need reliable information on all kinds of qualifications, both those acquired locally and those obtained abroad.  This information is normally channelled through recognition statements from competent national authorities.  Credential evaluators will therefore increasingly be faced with issues of professional qualifications, which will require a further development of their skills, and in some instances of a change in attitude.  This is intrinsically linked to the fact that many European States, including Malta, will be required to process an increasing number of applications for the recognition of non-traditional learning.
Thishas to do with changes in the way in which knowledge and competencies are developed and conveyed – i.e. innovations in teaching and learning.  The traditional teaching environment of a four-walled classroom or a set campus will be the setting for a smaller proportion of the overall education effort.  More education will be delivered through the Internet, through transnational arrangements, through a combination of traditional and innovative learning techniques, through the recognition of various forms of prior learning, including task/technology/work-based learning.  Much non-traditional learning will be provided on a different time scale.  For this, lifelong learning is the key concept, but not only in the form of specifically designed courses for those already employed who have a degree, who need to develop their skills further, and who are prepared to pay for this service.  Rather lifelong learning will, in my opinion, become the chief mission of higher education.
Onecrucial question that was raised in the recent Council meeting for Ministers of Education of EU member states and candidate countries that I attended in Brussels on the 5th and 6th of May, was whether it is more pertinent to develop a separate set of qualifications for non-traditional learning or rather to integrate non-traditional learning into the overall qualifications structure.  The former option risks branding non-traditional or innovative learning as second rate, and the questions of recognition would still have to be dealt with.  The second option requires creative rethinking of the way qualifications are earned and recognised.  The concept of learning paths should be added to the concept of course curricula.  Alternative routes to qualifications and the right assessment and evaluation of these qualifications should be the key words rather than the way in which the qualifications were earned.
MutualRecognition of qualifications enhances the educational standing of a country; it does not lift the gates on unqualified labour hordes advancing on our country. The benefits of mobility within the EU-Socrates, Leonardo and Youth Programmes are being felt at all levels of our society.  The future requires us to be operative both inside our shores and outside them.  Our vision must provide our citizens, in a lifelong perspective with a wide choice of education provision, much of it beyond the confines of traditional state provision.  This is partly a question of how Maltese learners having a right to make informed choices on education that has validity beyond the insularity of our islands.
TheEuropean Network for Quality Assessment (ENQA) has been established for EU countries and candidate countries.  This is a step in the right direction.  Mobility should not be at the expense of quality.  In fact the Bologna Declaration highlights this by stating unequivocally that member states should be involved in the “promotion of European co-operation in quality assurance with a view to developing comparable criteria and methodologies”.  This is the way forward. In September of this year, Ministers will agree in Berlin on the way forward in higher education, Malta will be both a decision maker and a co-planner of the road-map.  The choice of membership has assured this position.
Ixxerja din l-istqarrija Icon socials Icon socials Icon socials Icon socials

Stqarrijiet Oħra:

STQARRIJA MILL-UFFIĊĊJU TAD-DEPUTAT PRIM MINISTRU U MINISTERU GĦAS-SAĦĦA  Inawgurat bust ta’ Ġorġ tal-Mużew fl-Isptar Mater Dei b’tifkira tal-ħidma tiegħu fost dawk vulnerabbli

PR261936

STQARRIJA MILL-UFFIĊĊJU TAD-DEPUTAT PRIM MINISTRU U MINISTERU GĦAS-SAĦĦA I...

PRESS RELEASE BY THE MINISTRY FOR ENERGY, THE ENVIRONMENT AND THE REGENERATION OF THE GRAND HARBOUR  ERA launches anniversary publication: A decade of protecting Malta’s natural future

PR261935en

PRESS RELEASE BY THE MINISTRY FOR ENERGY, THE ENVIRONMENT AND THE REGENERAT...

Aktar Stqarrijiet Right arrow