Left arrow Go Back

MINISTRY OF EDUCATION STATEMENT

PR477E
Date Icon 11/04/2002

With reference to the article carried in "The Malta Independent" on Monday 8th April 2002, reporting comments by the Opposition Spokesman the Hon. Evarist Bartolo, entitled "Only one per cent pass English exam", the Ministry of Education states that the Hon. Bartolo is not being fair in his comments about students in State schools, particularly students in the State Area Secondary Schools, when he says that only 1% of Government area secondary school students passed their English SEC exam. Although the Hon. Bartolo often says that exams are not the beginning and end of everything and speaks about the undue pressure that is put on students for them to pass exams, he then uses the examination yardstick and statistics which were published for the first time to try to put Government in a bad light.

The Hon. Bartolo seems to have a certain affinity towards the use of statistics. However he not only gives an unbalanced and unrealistic view but he also makes important mistakes in his number scrunching.

Statistics must always be seen in context, in this case the context of our country's educational system. The fact is that locally the Government is committed to an inclusive educational policy that accepts to teach all students up to the levels that each individual can attain. The system is such that approximately at age 10/11, students sit for an exam where more than half are routed into one of our Junior Lyceums and the others are routed into one of our Area Secondary Schools. Of the latter, a number of students choose to sit for the SEC exams whilst others do not. To date, in most cases, those who do not sit for the SEC exams stop attending school at the compulsory schooling age (16) and start working after they have received their School-Leaving Certificate. There is no doubt that in this sector there is still a lot of work to be done.

However, the Hon. Bartolo chooses the figures that best suit his strategy of painting a grim picture at the expense of secondary school students. As an example he says that only 15 students (1%) passed their SEC English exam in 2001. The facts show that of all those attending State schools, 59% 'pass' their English exam. This figure rises to 79% if we take the figure of those who passed as a percentage of those who actually registered for the English exam. Even if we take the Area Secondary Schools separately, we find that 23% of those who sat for the exam actually passed the English exam. This is a more realistic picture than that depicted by the Hon. Bartolo.

The Hon. Bartolo calculated his figure of 1% by reducing as much as possible the numbers of those who passed and calculated these figures against the total number of form 5 students at Area Secondary Schools. The Hon. Bartolo considers those who have passed as those who have attained a result between Grade 1 and Grade 5 and left out completely those who passed their September re-sits, even then it still seems that Hon. Bartolo left some students out of his calculation.

The Matsec Board considers as passes Grades 1 to 7 and confirms this in the executive summary of the same report Hon. Bartolo uses:

"When all passes (Grades 1 to 7) are considered, of the 1985 cohort (N=3,891): 18.6% obtained passes in 11 to 15 subjects, 52.2% in 6 to 10 subjects, 25.1% in 1 to 5 subjects and 4.3% did not pass in any subject. When Grades 1 to 5 only are considered, 13.1% obtained passes in 11 to 15 subjects, 40.1% in 6 to 10 subjects, 33.6% in 1 to 5 subjects and 13.1% did not pass in any subject. Passes in 10 subjects were the most common category whether passes were taken to include Grades 1 to 7 (16.5%) or grades 1 to 5 (10.6%). Passes in 11 and 9 subjects were also common."

The Ministry of Education believes that there is still a long way to go in improving our educational system and helping students realise their full potential, however it is definitely wrong to quote statistics incorrectly and unfairly.

Share this Press Release Icon socials Icon socials Icon socials Icon socials

Other Press Releases:

STQARRIJA MILL-UFFIĊĊJU TAL-PRIM MINISTRU  “Sodisfatt bil-qbil bejn il-mexxejja tal-UE għax Malta ilha mill-bidu nett timbotta favur soluzzjoni għall-paċi” – Il-Prim Ministru Robert Abela

PR261926

STQARRIJA MILL-UFFIĊĊJU TAL-PRIM MINISTRU “Sodisfatt bil-qbil bejn il-mexx...

PRESS RELEASE BY THE MINISTRY FOR EUROPEAN FUNDS, SOCIAL DIALOGUE AND CONSUMER PROTECTION  European funding through the Erasmus+ programme to strengthen educators’ professional development

PR261925EN

PRESS RELEASE BY THE MINISTRY FOR EUROPEAN FUNDS, SOCIAL DIALOGUE AND CONSU...

More Press Releases Right arrow