Speech By the HON. george pullicino, Parliamentary Secretary in the Ministry for Home Affairs, at the launching of the ‘Environment Impact assessment – Methods and Techniques’ course organised by the Planning Authority - floriana
In Malta, a number of issues have been raised about EIAs. It has been argued that the production of Environment Impact Statements constitutes an extra expense on applicants for development permissions; that EIA is just a legal obligation; an obstacle to obtaining a development permission and a time consuming exercise. Moreover the question whether EIA is really effective in helping improve decision making is still being asked.
The question of expenses has already been addressed by the Planning Authority, by encouraging that when there are similar developments in the same locality only one EIA should be commissioned. Furthermore the Planning Authority can also issue a call for quotations for an EIA in the name of the developers and after evaluating the quotations, prepares and forwards a report so that the applicant will choose the most favourable quotation and thus checking high fees.
The main reason given as to why impact assessments are produced is to provide decision-makers with an indication of the likely consequences of their actions, that is whether or not they approve a proposal, and if so, under what conditions.
The Environment Impact Assessment process in Malta started in 1993, a few months after the inception of the Planning Authority. The regulations were produced under the Development Planning Act and assess effects of certain public and private projects and generally detail the procedure to be adopted in the development control process for EIA.
The EIA Regulations 2001 fully transpose the EU Directives on EIA (Council Directives 85/337EEC and 97/11/EC on the assessment of the effects of certain public and private projects on the environment).
In some cases the Regulations are even more stringent. For example, certain projects in Malta might require an EIA whereas in EU countries they probably would not. This is because of Malta’s small size: certain developments that are considered large locally will not be in EU countries (for example, farms).
It is understandable that consultants are in to make a profit from their contribution to an EIA. However one has to ask whether their contribution is of value. Cases where consultants charged exorbitant fees for their services are not unknown. When one compares the fees charged by a consultant to the value provided, the comparison may raise a few eyebrows.
Consultants should remember that first and foremost they are providing a service to the community. Although their services are paid by developers, their main concern should be the sustainability of the project and its impact on the environment and the community.
The aim of this course is to improve the quality of EIAs and Environment Impact Statements to help in providing a pool of consultants who later may be eligible to be included in the Register of EIA Consultants that is contemplated by the Regulations.
I congratulate the Planning Authority for the initiative of organising the course and the participants attending the course and wish them every success.
Other Press Releases:
PR261926
STQARRIJA MILL-UFFIĊĊJU TAL-PRIM MINISTRU “Sodisfatt bil-qbil bejn il-mexx...
PR261925EN