Left arrow Go Back

Address by the HON. Louis Deguara, Minister of Health, AT THE International Conference for Mental Health Nurses: "Sharing Ideas, Sharing Futures" – ST.JULIANS – THURSDAY, 31ST OCTOBER 2002

PR1523
Date Icon 01/11/2002

Distinguished Guests, Ladies and Gentlemen,

Let me start by congratulating the organisers of this first International Conference for Mental Health Nurses. We feel honoured that Malta was chosen for this international gathering. I am sure that your efforts during these few days will throw more light on this still misunderstood but quite common illness in its diverse manifestations.

Here in Malta mental health care has a long history. The Knights of St John provided for our original mental health patients in the Sacra Infermeria, their general hospital, now the Mediterranean Conference Centre. Moved during the early part of the English period, it moved finally to the current purpose built hospital, Our Lady of Mount Carmel, in the 1860’s. That facility is in the process of being extensively modernized and management and treatment thoroughly reformed.

Mental Health in Malta, as in other countries, has been for a long time the subject of frustrations and hopelessness. Mental disorder carried and still carries to a certain extent a stigma and fear that prevented the proper treatment in its proper setting, the community. The sad fact is that society generally does not have a clear understanding of the nature of mental illness, nor does it have a history of supporting those who suffer from it. All too often people with mental illness are viewed as dangerous.

I feel the popular press could do more to alter this perception. People do not readily realise that mental illness is not as different as they imagine from other illnesses. Perhaps there is something about mental illness that frightens the general public. The idea of ‘being different’, of being a source of ridicule, of being seen as incompetent or simply being described as ‘mad’ offends the individual’s sense of self worth. More likely it is because of a lack of knowledge about what mental illness is, how it is caused, how it can be effectively treated, and how it impacts on the life of a person struggling with one of these disorders. Thus, it is perhaps not surprising that under such circumstances society does not call for more effective ways of coping with mental illness, nor ways to fund projects designed to treat and support those who suffer its most severe forms.

Conscious of this totally wrong approach, a decade ago government decided that reform in the sector of mental health was a priority that could not be retarded any longer. A team of professionals from Malta and abroad studied the system in the most thorough way and devised a plan to start tackling its numerous deficiencies. A National Mental Health Commission was set up. A National Policy On Mental Health document was published in 1995. It set as its mission the "Fostering conditions for healthy living environments in family, school, workplace and community" and "offering a range of appropriate services to empower people to cope better with mental health issues thus maximising their productive and social life."

We knew that the reform was not easy and that it had to take time. In the first place the provision of care for this group of people has always proved to be difficult. Comparison can be drawn between the effects of long-term physical illness and those of serious mental illness. In both cases there may be no ability for independent living without outside help, no expectation of total recovery or returning to one’s pre-illness life, and no relief from a growing dependency on specially trained, skilled help to ensure the safety of the vulnerable individual.

The main differences may only be in the perception of others as to the necessity for such help, and the financial determination of the health care system to support such people over time. A person suffering the effects of physical illness is easily identifiable as requiring such help. A person suffering a loss of social skills and debilitated by intrusive thoughts and bizarre beliefs is most often not as easily recognized or supported.

A culture change was of the essential, if the reforms were to be given a chance of success, and as you know such a culture change necessarily needs time to mature. The public had to be educated so that the prejudice and the stigma of this illness were removed, and about the proper standards of treatment and rehabilitation. This was essential for the involvement of the community is central to the objectives of the plan.

Human resources proved another equally important challenge. As in other areas of the social sector we faced a dire scarcity of persons with the right mix of human and professional management qualities. Specialised social workers were almost non-existent. Today the situation is much better but we are conscious that we have to make further efforts.

We are encouraged by the success so far. The stigma and prejudice are not so pronounced as before. We have succeeded to reduce the hospital in-patient population from over 700 to 500. Some of these have gone back to their families, others are living independently in groups. This proves that our educational strategy is working. Neighbours are learning by experience that after all these patients have proved no danger to the community.

Whilst the actual care provided to individuals with mental health problems may be complex and complicated, there is general agreement that the organisation of that care need not necessarily be as complex if properly thought through. Research would suggest that five commonly accepted components are at the heart of good mental health care.

1. A comprehensive assessment of the individual’s needs and his immediate social network
2. Development of a care plan or package of care to meet those needs
3. Ensuring that the individual has access to or receives the care to be provided
4. Monitoring the quality of care provided
5. Monitoring on-going, long-term support and content with the individual and his social network.

Reforms that have taken place within the hospital with these aims in mind are proof of the beneficial results of a rehabilitative approach. These reforms are achieving adequate assessment on admission and effective holistic treatment with the scope of speeding up recovery, discharge and early integration within the community. We are naturally proud of the outright success of the sheltered work scheme introduced for patients in Mount Carmel Hospital. Up to now over 150 patients have been given paid work within the hospital.

The success of the scheme is measured by the increased self-confidence of these patient workers and their enhanced dignity. Several of them have benefited so much that they have sought and secured work on the open market. Others have enrolled for University and higher education courses. Encouraged by the proven soundness of the scheme we are planning the set-up a co-operative for these workers. The plan is at an advanced stage and we hope that it will soon be launched.

The importance of nursing in this matter cannot be stressed enough. The American Nurses' Association suggests that psychiatric and mental health nurses are highly qualified to function as both case managers and providers within care systems. They are positioned to have a maximum impact on the care of psychiatric clients because:

  1. They are committed to improving access, quality, and cost containment
  2. They understand prevention and wellness and know how to educate patients to improve health
  3. They know how to triage and assess the needs of patients, and
  4. They know how to accurately evaluate the necessity for inpatient admissions and continued hospital stays.

Thus there is great opportunity for nurses to expand their roles and develop new career directions.

However, nursing, in particular, has felt this pressure of care delivery and the changes that have taken place over the last two decades more than most psychiatric disciplines. Research has shown that this group of professionals feels under-resourced, unsupported and deskilled by many of the organisational changes taking place around them. Also, where in-patient care remains the dominant point of delivery rehabilitation processes are often not seen as part of the nurse’s role because they fail to see the structural link between admission and discharge. Similarly, if their internal organisational structures, i.e. the way that staff are grouped and care responsibility apportioned, are not clearly defined, managed and evaluated, sophisticated mental health nursing becomes an impossible professional target.

Moreover, high proportions of staff are not adequately versed or familiar with intensive therapy techniques but provide standardized support within blanket services. Given this reality, there exists a philosophical resistance to the introduction of yet more complex and seemingly elitist care models. The belief required for their implementation over existing models is often non-existent, and the necessity to change is seen to be driven by other forces, such as client pressure, reimbursement structures, and the demands of academia, "empire makers" and researchers. The motivation for change, i.e. the belief that it is a good idea, is often not present among many members of the mental health care community.

Yet without nurses and other mental health practitioners, there can be no skilled specialist care. That is why it is so important that conference like this one, bringing together specialists from around the globe, take place to enable people to learn from each other and collaborate on problem solving and the development of new ideas. We need to build upon the nurses’ vast array of existing knowledge and expertise, combining these with new ideas and technology but never losing sight of the fact that good nursing requires good organisation, good lines of communication and well defined roles and responsibilities.

Though this human resource problem is not solved to our satisfaction, we can report improvement. Specialised psychiatric nurses have increased but the need is still great. To bring up the numbers to adequate levels, psychiatric trainee nurses are given enhanced allowances over and above the generous stipend granted to tertiary level students. Besides we are investing in in-service training courses to augment the technical awareness and skills of our nurses in line with modern practice.

We have been blessed with the dedication of voluntary associations. The government encourages volunteerism, firm in its belief that these are essential for the transition from a welfare state to a welfare society. Government is willing to invest and provide all that is essential and more. But there are some things that government and paid professionals will never be able to provide.

The next important challenge we have to tackle in the very near future is to set up community services with the aim of prevention, early detection and better access for patients with incipient mental health problems. Our strategy assumes a multisectoral approach. Such a set-up would drastically prevent the institulisation of some as well as the reduction of length of stay of other patients. Through these structures in the community we would also be able to provide support to families having a member with mental health problems. As a beginning a manager has already been chosen.

We will have to consciously strive so that the mental health sector retains its fair share of funding in a scenario where health care organizations around the world are seeing increased demand for services, escalating costs, limited resources, and difficulty with access to care for health care consumers. Those who make decisions about health-care try to see that the needs of all individuals are met. However, financial resources are finite and some degree of prioritization has to be undertaken to ensure that the needs of the majority are met within limited health care budgets. This focus on generalised health care holds the key to understanding some of the problems associated with mental health services. For the physical illness the case is both obvious and the alternatives, in terms of cost of in-patient care or to the person’s quality of life, make the provision of individualized, complex and personalized community care viable. The need is clear, but so too is the demand from society that it should be met appropriately. This combination of available and cost-effective social and health care options and pressure influenced by social conscience is a powerful bargaining tool for the individual requiring such help. Unfortunately, for a variety of reasons the same tool is not ordinarily available to those suffering from the effects of severe mental illness.

Although mental illness may affect as many as one in six people within western societies, health budget allocations seldom reflect this statistic. Mental health care across countries is often a poor relation of that for physical health. Deprived of the funds that would enable it to offer a diversity of care options, it has consistently had to target blanket care options to deal with the needs of the majority of its service users. The availability of financial resources for sophisticated long-term care is therefore dependent upon very careful budgetary management and recognition on the part of planners that money would be well spent on such activities.

Finally, ladies and gentlemen, looking through the programme I have noticed that the organisers have wisely found the time for you to see some of the attractions of our islands. I would say not enough and what you will see will only serve to wet your appetite. Malta, being strategically placed at the centre of the Mediterranean Sea, one of the most important cradles of civilisation, has surprisingly more to offer than its size seems to warrant. Suffice to say that we can boast of some thirty sites where remains of prehistoric temples are still extant, a few of them reasonably well preserved. You may be surprised to learn that many of these temples predate the pyramids and are the oldest extant free standing monuments in the world.

So besides wishing you fruitful professional proceedings may I wish you a happy and enriching experience in our islands.

Share this Press Release Icon socials Icon socials Icon socials Icon socials

Other Press Releases:

PRESS RELEASE BY THE NATIONAL AUDIT OFFICE  National Audit Office Malta hosts bilateral meeting with the Spanish Court of Audit

PR261929

PRESS RELEASE BY THE NATIONAL AUDIT OFFICE National Audit Office Malta hos...

STQARRIJA MILL-MINISTERU GĦALL-EDUKAZZJONI U L-ISPORT Aktar minn 320 student jieħdu sehem fil-Malta Skills Championships 2026

PR261928

STQARRIJA MILL-MINISTERU GĦALL-EDUKAZZJONI U L-ISPORT Aktar minn 320 studen...

More Press Releases Right arrow