OPENING REMARKS BY MR ALFRED FIORINI LOWELL, SECRETARY TO THE CABINET, AT THE FIFTH CONTACT GROUP MEETING OF EUROPEAN FINANCIAL CONTROL ORGANISATIONS – MALTA – MONDAY 28 OCTOBER 2002
Madame Commissioner
Distinguished Delegates
Ladies and Gentlemen
May I first of all welcome all of you to Malta and wish you an interesting discussion on the topics that you are here to share your experiences with those of other friends and colleagues. I hope that each one of you will take back from this meeting something that will be of use in the ongoing process of upgrading in your own country the sector that is the subject of this meeting.
I also augur that during your short stay here you will find some time - as I understand many of you already did so yesterday - to experience some of the attractions of our small, but historically and otherwise rich, country in the Mediterranean and, shortly, also in the European Union.
In introducing this occasion I feel that I cannot but refer to the fact that the Fifth Contact Group Meeting of European Financial Control Organisations is being held at a crucial and auspicious juncture in the development of Europe, the continent we all live in.
The EU is on the verge of the biggest enlargement since its creation – a project of vision that is certainly one of the most complex and significant exercises on which the Union ever embarked. As we all know, earlier on this same month the European Commission formally recommended that ten candidate states will be ready to join the EU in 2004, a recommendation that has been accepted by the Brussels European Council that ended last Friday. Indeed, on the very day that we are meeting here in Malta, the EU Presidency is meeting with the thirteen candidate countries in Copenhagen to discuss the outcomes of the Brussels Summit. The remaining period up to the close of negotiations at the Copenhagen Council in December will be a hectic and determining one.
In these circumstances it is therefore an even greater pleasure than would normally be the case, for me to be able to welcome to this meeting on behalf of the Government of Malta the representatives not only of all 15 EU Member States but also those of the 10 Acceding Countries, including my own, referred to up to some days ago as Candidate Countries. The imminent change in status to EU Membership is in fact reflected in the proceedings of this conference in that one on the main items on its agenda concerns precisely the future role of the Contract Group after the year 2003.
I of course extend a similarly genuinely welcome to the representatives of the other three applicant countries.
The area of Financial Control is one of the sectors which the EU considers to be essential to its continued development. It is of course covered by a chapter of its own in the acquis.
It is, I would say, a dynamic area – an area in which, in the words of a report prepared by DG Budget in September 2002, (I quote) "the results already achieved (i.e. in legislative terms) by the Applicant Countries in the last couple of years can be called a watershed and even dramatic" (unquote). Strong words indeed, but ones that reflect the reality of the situation. The complement should nevertheless not be allowed to promote complacency but should rather be taken as encouragement for the efforts that will always need to continue to be made in the pursuit of further excellence in the area.
It is, I believe, to the credit not only of the Acceding and Applicant Countries themselves that we have reached this stage of development in Public Internal Financial Control in Europe, but undoubtedly also to the efforts of the different Commission Services involved, including DG Budget, and certainly to those of the current Member States. All have contributed to this success. Moreover, there can be no doubt today that the Contact Group structure was itself crucial for the high degree of all-round co-operation that has made such a success possible.
I wish, if I may, be allowed here to refer to Malta’s own past and more recent experience in the area now referred to as PIFC.
Malta’s geographic and strategic location has meant that our economy has, over the years, depended heavily on trade with the countries in the European landmass to our North. A natural consequence of this was that Malta inevitably absorbed many of the experiences of its trading partners. For example, our laws owe much of their underlying principles to the legal systems of the United Kingdom, Italy and France. Our system of Government is still in essence based on the Westminster model. When it comes to formulating local policies in the public sector, our Civil Service, another British legacy, as well as many of our professions, amongst them the accounting profession, also continue to look critically at, and be influenced by, what is happening today in the United Kingdom and now, increasingly so of course, in the other EU Member States.
However, the rate of absorption of good practices was in the past not a uniform one in the different sectors of Government. In the case of Public Internal Financial Control, it is certainly a fact that the system in Malta was, even up to the beginning of the 1990’s, still based on principles, standards and practices established in the early 1960’s at the time that Malta gained its independence. On the other hand this contrasted with the more pronounced developments that were taking place at the same time in the same areas in Malta’s private sector.
Malta’s public financial control structures started again being seriously looked at in the early 1990s as part of an initiative that was in fact one particular link in a long chain of reform measures in the public sector initiated by the Government some years earlier.
That process of reform was launched in 1989 with the publication of a far-reaching Public Service Reform Commission Report. In fact, interestingly and intentionally, the start of the process coincided with the submission of Malta’s original application to join the European Union. That in fact happened only a few months later in July 1990.
The two important policy decisions – to embark on a process of reform of the Public Service and to apply for membership of the European Union – were, without any doubt, determining and extremely positive factors not only in the development of Malta’s recent history in general but in that of PIFC in particular.
The adoption and subsequent implementation of many of the Public Service Reform Commission’s recommendations, including those in the area of financial management, has since resulted in significant improvements in the public service. They have indeed also been crucial in the mobilisation effort that, like all other applicant countries, Malta had to mount in order to be better prepared to meet its EU accession aspirations and responsibilities.
Turning even more specifically to the subject of financial management, there is at present before our Parliament a completely new Public Financial Management Act that embodies provisions that address: the efficient and effective management of government resources; the proper harnessing and control of the public debt; and the rules on accrual accounting that will be introduced in January 2005 in government financial planning and accounting frameworks.
One other specific and important aspect of public service reform, which is worth mentioning at this point, is that relating to the recruitment policy adopted in recent years. The new policy has led to a steady intake of graduate and professional accountants and auditors into government and its agencies, a development that has raised considerably the professional level of the public servants working in the particular sector.
But, perhaps, one of the most significant thrusts of the reform of PIFC in Malta was directed at the public audit function - both external and internal audit.
In external audit, following legislation enacted in 1997, our National Audit Office was established as a completely independent body that reports directly to Parliament. The Auditor General now has extensive powers that enable the National Audit Office to function effectively. The Office is also empowered by law to perform formal inquiries which can be compared to judicial ones.
Very soon after, a re-engineering exercise was launched which eventually led to the complete revamping of public internal auditin Malta. Government now has a strong and effective tool to promote good management practices and to provide increasingly more effective protection against all forms of errors and mismanagement in the use and application of all public and EU funds.
Before continuing, I must here specifically thank Unit D6 of DG Budget for its advice and material support in the process of reform of Malta’s PIFC structures and for its knowledgeable and valued guidance on how to ensure that these developments respected the requirements of the aquis. Thank you Mr Jurgen Andermann and all your staff. Your unit was the effective catalyst without which earlier efforts in the area of public internal audit would not have been brought to fruition in such a relatively short period of time.
Malta’s experience in the upgrading of public internal audit was that the most important elements of the reform were: (1) the centralisation of the function; (2) the inclusion of the basic principles of internal auditing in our laws and regulations; (3) the creation of as highly a professional and internationally qualified cadre of auditors as possible; (4) the introduction of a strong IT-based audit approach; and (5), for the first time in Malta, the giving of parliamentary backing to the function, an objective that is expected to be achieved soon.
A further aspect of the reform was the Government’s decision to make the same structure responsible for both the public internal audit function and for the performance of financial investigations. This may sound unfamiliar to some of you, perhaps because international guidelines and practices on internal auditing do not specifically refer to this type of eventuality.
In Malta’s case, this particular reform mutation was originally prompted by the need not to duplicate precious human resources. There was however an even more significant reason for that decision. It is an accepted fact that, through its in-depth examination of systems, policies and procedures, the public internal audit function gradually builds up a vast database of information – information that is very often also relevant as evidence in instances of possible mismanagement, corruption of public officers and fraud of national funds.
It was therefore, in a way, a natural step for responsibility for internal audit and that for financial investigations to be assigned to the same body. It was however also decided that the new body should still hand over responsibility for further investigation to the Police authorities whenever the prosecution of a suspected crime was indicated.
In support of the above ideas and principles, Malta may be said to have, through the guaranteeing of the independence of its public internal auditors and in the situs of the responsibility for the function, extended the concept of "functional" independence to one of "effective" independence. This independence was achieved through ensuring that the auditee had no control on the performance of the internal audit in his domain and by locating the responsibility for the function in the Cabinet Secretariat of the Office of the Prime Minister and not in that of a specific government line ministry. We reasoned that by doing so we would be helping to weaken the perception that internal audit was exclusively financially focused. That perception is of course quite incorrect as modern internal audit goes far beyond that.
Another consideration was to have the operational arm of internal audit and financial investigations to report directly to an independent policy-making board, the Internal Audit and Investigations Board, which is charged with laying down the policies to be followed in the implementation of internal audit and financial investigations and with overseeing, and providing the necessary backing to, the executive arm of the function, i.e. the Internal Audit and Investigations Directorate.
A further in-built safeguard in our system is that all the members of the directorate are in effect subject to two complimentary Codes of Ethics – that of their own profession and that which has specifically been drawn up for the public internal audit and investigative function itself. Furthermore, all public internal auditors are appointed by the Public Service Commission, a Constitutional Commission that is completely independent of Government. This all means that Government cannot summarily dismiss or interfere with their work. Malta’s public internal audit and financial investigations function is thus endowed with an extent of independence which, I would say, is just one step away from the complete independence enjoyed by our Auditor General.
Let me now touch upon certain aspects that are closely related to a particular theme discussed in earlier meetings of the Contact Group, particularly the last one.
When we met in Tallinnlast year I was struck by the degree of agreement between Member States and Candidate Countries in their efforts to ensure that the Public Internal Financial Control function developed as an effective tool against all forms of bad management of public resources, including that of EU funds. I particularly noted the impressive efforts made by the PHARE countries to install good quality laws and administrative frameworks and systems which were forward looking and modern in their approach. I should here also refer to the Mediterranean dimension, where Malta and Cyprus were, perhaps, more fortunate than the PHARE countries because of the long historical connection of each of the two countries with an EU member state, the United Kingdom, which was and remains one of the foremost international exponents of developments relating to financial management and PIFC internationally.
The Tallinn meeting also brought out the particular difficulties of individual states in reconciling the modern concept of internal audit (especially when that involved the adoption of risk-based approaches and methodologies) with the meaning of the term "inspection". From that debate and from the widely differing understanding of the meaning of the term, it became evident that the PIFC concept could never be one common, stereotyped, approach to be adopted by, or imposed on, all countries. That was simply due to the fact that in reality the underlying systems in each member state, acceding country and candidate country differs one from the other. The final objective must always remain the proper management and protection of both national and EU funds. On the other hand it must be acknowledged that we live in a world where not only are changes often happening even faster than we can absorb them, but where it is the particular national culture that dictates how citizens in a particular country live, how they do things, how they work and so on.
I therefore suggest that, instead of seeking to apply a rigid and somewhat utopian standard PIFC scenario in all individual countries making up the European Union, we must all learn how to appreciate the diversity and the interesting ways each one of us in practice applies to PIFC matters in his or her own country.
In other words, we must accept that it is impractical to expect the implementation of the same system in all Member States. We must instead, firstly, seek to monitor and adopt, where feasible, the increasing and regular developments that take place in the discipline throughout the world and, secondly, accept that the models of individual countries all have their strengths and weaknesses, albeit in varying degrees.
Having given a brief outline of the recent developments in Malta in the area of PIFC, and having referred very briefly to aspects of a theme discussed in much more detail in the Tallinn meeting, I would like at this point to pose three questions which emanate from Malta’s recent experience in reforming its PIFC structures. In giving the answers to the questions I hope that the exercise will prompt some further discussion on the points raised. The questions are:
- Do you agree that the internal audit function was in the past developed primarily if not wholly for the private sector?
- Do you agree that, given recent developments, there is a need to devise standards and guidelines specifically for the public sector, i.e. for Governments?
- Is the performance of "administrative investigations", as has started being practised in Malta, not a natural extension of the function of the public internal auditor?
My perception here is that this is certainly the case. It at least definitely happened in Malta. For example, in the 1980’s and the 1990’s it was the fashion to compare governments with business companies in the private sector, the shareholders of governments being the citizens who elected them. But, I ask, is this analogy still relevant to today’s concept of government? Very often, modern PIFC does not lend itself to the type of structures and systems practised in private sector profit-focused companies.
My view is that the underlying objectives of internal auditing in the public sector are much more complex than those in the private sector. Whilst those of the latter are essentially profit-based, good governance in the public sector is all about providing the best possible quality service to the citizen, in the process satisfying, where possible value, for money requirements. Governments owe their citizens a responsibility that is fundamentally dependent on systems and frameworks that effectively protect funds that are entrusted to them by those same citizens.
Whatever the strategic goals of a government are, the PIFC function should occupy a very central role, backed by enough independence to ensure: (1) that government operations are performed correctly according to its underlying mandate; (2) that whatever is done by government takes account of the inherent restrictions of national resources; (3) that there is adequate protection against any form of mismanagement; and, finally, (4) that mismanagement, wherever and whenever it occurs, is uncovered so that immediate remedial action can be taken.
Again, I suggest that good Public Internal Financial Control cannot be efficiently carried out by internal audit or control structures of the form that may exist in the private sector. It has to be much more.
Put differently, it has to be recognised that public internal audit has a very precise duty towards the citizen. In the private sector moreover, management may silence the internal auditor, unless the external auditor comes to know of the particular weaknesses – that, however, often being too late to do anything to head off a damaging situation. The intervention of the external auditor in the debacles caused this year by a number of global companies was invariably completely missing, too late, or else manifestly ineffective. Can you imagine what would have happened if such circumstances arose in the public sector – in government?
It is, I submit, international good practice for auditors to have the necessary competencies to also perform financial or administrative investigations, also commonly referred to as "forensic audits". In that respect therefore I would suggest that Malta’s model does indeed fit in with international principles.
The introduction of the whistle blowing principle in public internal audit in Malta is also, I feel, another interesting development. In our case this will be used particularly when a financial investigation indicates the likely possibility of serious mismanagement or fraud. In such cases the internal auditor will be obliged to refer the matter to the Attorney General who is the authority in Malta charged under the Constitution with ordering the Police authorities to initiate a criminal investigation. The Government of Malta is fully committed to the dual principle of public accountability and transparency in all government operations, and the use of whistle blowing is the catalyst to effectively achieve this self-imposed responsibility.
The observations I have just made are intended to be food for further thought on how one can support and sustain good governance through PIFC. In this regard I suggest that, in the fast-changing world we live in, one needs to be pro-active in identifying how best to improve PIFC and how to generate solutions to problems before they even arise.
Increasingly, governments will need to have management and control administrative structures that are staffed by knowledgeable and competent individuals effectively armed to combat all forms of attacks against national funds, from whichever source these may arise. Such efforts would need to be sustainable, as it is not enough to ensure value for money in particular government activities. Public Sector management is a continuous process for the benefit of all the citizens of a country, and overall objectives and progress in the right direction should in no way be affected by changes in political leadership. We should perhaps add an "S" to the traditional three "E’s" – economy, efficiency, effectiveness and sustainability.
I hope that I have put before you some thoughts that might perhaps be discussed further either during next year’s Contact Group meeting or at some technical workshop on related issues which may be organised by DG Budget before then.
Before closing my address I wish in fact to reiterate Malta’s full support for this Forum or some other suitable alternative to it, to continue to exist even after 2003. Malta believes that, apart from being a very technical area, the influence of good PIFC extends to so many areas of Government that the subject merits the retention of a specific forum where common and harmonised approaches and methodologies can continue to be shared, discussed and effectively agreed upon. The past four meetings of the Contact Group have amply proved this need. PIFC is not dependent on whether or not a country is a member state, an accession country or an applicant country as it in effect deals with the very basics of the governance of a modern state.
Finally, I must here formally thank Commissioner Schreyer and her team for accepting Malta’s invitation to hold this Fifth Contact Group meeting in Malta. Malta fully appreciates the trust shown in the smallest of the member states in an enlarged EU but one that can also offer its fair share towards the continued development of the European Union in general and of the area that is the subject of the Contact Group Meetings in particular.
I wish you all excellent proceedings during the meeting.
Thank you.
Other Press Releases:
PR261929
PRESS RELEASE BY THE NATIONAL AUDIT OFFICE National Audit Office Malta hos...
PR261928