SPEECH BY THE HON EDDIE FENECH ADAMI, PRIME MINISTER, AT THE CONFERENCE, “THE QUALITY OF LIFE: THE EUROPEAN SOCIAL MODEL IN CONCRETE TERMS,” ORGANISED BY AZAD, WITH THE SUPPORT OF THE EUROPEAN COMMISSION AND EZA. SATURDAY 5 OCTOBER 2002
Two reasons have guided my choice to discuss the European Union’s principle of solidarity with you.
The first is that solidarity is becoming the focus of an increasing number of discussions within the European Union; it has attracted attention at the Convention on the Future of Europe. In one respect, this is a new development. Of course, solidarity has for long been the third principle of the Union, alongside subsidiarity and proportionality: but for a long time too, one heard much less about solidarity than about the other two principles.
This difference in emphasis was perhaps natural; it reflected the priorities of an earlier phase of European integration. The principle of subsidiarity is concerned with the question of when European-wide institutions are to be involved in decisions concerning national and more local contexts; the principle of proportionality is concerned with the question of how European-wide institutions are to involve themselves in decisions – that’s to say, with what degree of force. In other words, the principles of subsidiarity and proportionality are concerned with restricting the extent and force of higher-level involvement in decision-making. The principle of solidarity has a different spirit: its motive is not restriction of power; it is concerned with how to extend social justice and equality.
So it is understandable that institutional questions of subsidiarity and proportionality dominated attention when Europe was in the first, economic phase of integration. These questions are even more delicate now, when we are going through a second, political phase of integration.
A practical concern with solidarity is more likely to emerge when a certain level of economic and political integration has already been reached. The increasing attention that is now being given to the principle of solidarity is a sign that we are approaching that phase. But the change of emphasis is also a mark of the conviction of an increasing number of people that it is prudent to steer through the current political phase of integration with the next phase already in mind. A major challenge of the Europe of the future is to make sure that European integration brings with it an effective concern with welfare.
The second reason I have chosen to discuss the principle of solidarity with you is more personal. Solidarity as a political value has been a concern of mine throughout my political career. Twenty-five years ago, when I became leader of the Nationalist Party, I made it one of my goals that the importance that my party gave to solidarity with workers should be made more evident to the general public than it was at the time. Today, our workers’ section is called Solidarity. I have fought one election, as leader of my party, on a programme that insisted that work, justice and liberty go together. Having won that election, and led a government that managed over a five-year period to generate significantly more employment and affluence in a significantly more just and liberal society, I then fought the next election with ‘Solidarity’ as my party’s slogan: I am happy to report that on that occasion too my party managed to persuade the Maltese electorate that national prosperity should be accompanied by a concern with social justice and equality.
My government is now in the process of persuading the Maltese people that Malta’s accession to the European Union offers the best prospect, in a globalised world, of combining increased prosperity and liberty with solidarity. We should hold a referendum on the issue some time next year, probably soon after our accession negotiations with the European Union are completed. The current indications are that the majority of the Maltese population is persuaded that Malta’s proper place is within the European Union.
These, then, are the two main reasons why I am interested in discussing how the principle of solidarity can be implemented in the new order that is emerging in Europe. Of course, the principle of solidarity is not concerned only with issues of work, which are the subject of this conference. However, the concerns of European workers’ organisations, especially with work protection and with the quality of life, can be helpful in providing a focused perspective on the future of Europe. This conference can serve as a lens, so to speak, through which we can look at the future of European integration and some of the challenges ahead.
I believe it is difficult to discuss the future of Europe without recalling the two models of the Future Europe that are frequently presented. On the one hand, the media project the idea of Europe as a super state. This conforms to the way in which states have been ideally conceived in modern times – a pyramid structure, with a constitution at the top, and with subordinate powers distributed downwards to the lower levels of national and sub-national regions and localities.
At the opposite end, there is the idea put forward by more pragmatically minded people that Europe will progress better without any elaborate, overall political framework. Let us move forward, they say, just by ensuring increased contacts and communication, and by fixing up “ad hoc” greements.
Such people believe that Europe should grow organically and naturally, as opposed to artificially and mechanically. They favour a return to something like the medieval approach to society, viewing this almost as one would a living organism, and away from the technological modern concepts that treat Government as if it were a machine.
I suspect, however, that a general feeling is emerging that the future of Europe requires something else. New systems of government are needed, because the Europe that is being brought into being is a new kind of creature in World History. Its model should be neither the human body, nor the combustion engine. In this dawn of a new millennium, having just stepped over the threshold of the 21st century, should it not rather be something like an electronic network?
A network model means that in the Europe of the Future there need not be anything like the apex of a pyramid, or any monarchical position. The system has, of course, to be a multi-level construction, in the sense that authority has to be exercised at different levels – local, regional, national and continental.
However, provided the authorities at each level have a clearly defined field of jurisdiction, there is no compelling need for one level to be subject to that above it in a hierarchial fashion.
A formulation of the principle of subsidiarity to this effect, together with other relevant principles, combined with a restatement of universally acknowledged human rights, might even be considered an appropriate “Constitution” for Europe. It might not quite look like the Constitutions we are accustomed to having proclaimed by states, adhering in some way or other to Social Contract theories of sovereignty. But it would reflect the novel character of the unprecedented political entity that is being set up.
In the Europe of the future, it needs to be recognised that the State cannot be the only factor of governance. All future democratic systems will call for partnerships between both public and private institutions, and collaboration between them in the pursuit of the common good.
To a certain extent, Europe is already there. The way the European Union operates currently, especially in those areas that concern the regulation of work conditions, do not quite conform to a pyramid model of subsidiarity; that is to say, it is not the case that the European, national, and local institutional levels operate separately and in hierarchical mode.
In practice they work together on the same committees. The Union has some 800 committees, not to mention the various regulatory agencies, which deal with issues such as health and safety standards and other such issues to do with work protection and the quality of life. Now, the mere mention of 800 committees might invoke the image of a monstrous, bureaucratic European Commission: but this would be a false image. These committees are made up not only of people connected with the Commission; there are others who are nominated by national governments, and yet others from public and private institutions. The most appropriate image of these committees is, I believe, precisely that of an electronic network that creates nodes where information can be gathered, processed and redistributed.
The Future Europe will need to make this supranational network more transparent. Attention has also to be given to social and cultural issues. In these areas, maintaining the balance between integration on a European scale, and preservation of national individuality, is difficult and delicate.
In this context, the implementation of the principle of solidarity raises two fundamental issues. One is that workers’ organisations and other institutions concerned with welfare, social justice and equality need to make sure that they are represented properly at the appropriate nodes of the network.
The second issue is this. Solidarity is a meaningful expression of unity and support; it is most effective when it is non-bureaucratic and personalised. Being meaningful and personalised, it is inescapably cultural and susceptible to cultural variation. Solidarity in Europe will be difficult to achieve without an accompanying right of European nations to preserve a distinct cultural identity within supranational political networks.
The European Union’s principle of solidarity brings us to recognise something important. It is the recognition that peaceful and democratic development, such as that which Europe would like, has implications in terms not only of economic markets and political institutions, but also of cultural pluralism.
Other Press Releases:
PR261929
PRESS RELEASE BY THE NATIONAL AUDIT OFFICE National Audit Office Malta hos...
PR261926