Lecture by H.E. Prof Guido de Marco President of Malta on "A MEDITERRANEAN POLICY FOR EUROPE" At the Panteion University of Social and Political Sciences, Athens – Wednesday, 11th September 2002
Ladies and Gentlemen,
Jean Monnet, who is rightly credited for having brought about the European Coal and Steel Community in 1952 and who maintained that "Europe is something more than the price of coal and steel", declared some time later that "If I were to start again today, I would not begin with Common Market. I would start with culture."
The Europe of culture means a Europe of values. It also means a Europe that through the love of knowledge and wisdom, through its philosophy, will emerge not as inward looking regional institution but as an outward looking European Union based on values, building a unity in diversity.
When we speak about enlargement of the European Union, this should be considered not so much as an expansion of Europe towards the East or towards the South but as Pope John Paul II said in Vienna "The Europeization of the entire continent."
It is in this context that the peoples of Europe in full respect of their identity and history bring about "an increased sharing of the heritage of values to which each nation has contributed.*"
This message of an outward looking Europe is very relevant in structuring a Mediterranean policy. I believe no one more than us European States in the Mediterranean littoral do understand the need, indeed the necessity, of a strong involvement and not just an interest of Europe in the future of the Mediterranean.
The beauty of the Mediterranean Sea is that, through migration, trade, travels, conquests and conflict, all the peoples living on its littorals are connected in one way or another. The richness of exchanges and experiences has given the peoples of its region a particular sense of Mediterranean belongingness.
The history of civilization we witnessed in this region is not a dead history, inscribed only in stone or printed in books. It is a living history. Our environment, our intellectual disposition, our vision of life in many ways reflect the experiences of millennia.
Homer, 800 years before Christ, in his Iliad and in his Odyssey, sees in the Mediterranean, a Greek lake, a vehicle of culture and philosophy, making the genius of Greece the heritage of the Mediterranean. This forms an integral part of our heritage, the common heritage of mankind.
This rich heritage, given to Europe by Greece, enhanced by Rome and Byzantium, was also enriched by the Arabs in North Africa, in Spain, in Sicily and in Malta. Averroes, through his philosophical writings including commentaries on Aristotle and Plato, influenced Christian and Jewish writers and reconciled Islamic and Greek thought. I say this because I want to demonstrate to you the link, which is inherent between the European, Mediterranean and North African civilization and culture.
In some way or another, our peoples have been connected with each other since antiquity. Ancient Greeks gave us the foundation of western philosophy and thought, the Romans built not only roads but a body of law which survives to this day, Christianity has shaped our moral values, the Arabs bequeath us with mathematics, the foundation of science and technology. This, in conjunction, remains at the core of the foundations of Europe, a Europe of values, a Europe of culture.
I want to share with you my experiences of Euro-Mediterranean policies throughout the years that I have been involved in politics.
In Helsinki I, my country, through its then government, made a proposition which initially was received negatively, but later formed the basis of the Mediterranean Basket. This proposition is based on a statement which is as alive today, and perhaps even more so than it was in 1975, at the height of the Cold War! There can be no security in Europe unless there is security in the Mediterranean; there can be no security in the Mediterranean unless there is security in Europe.
The Mediterranean Basket at Helsinki I reflected the thinking of the then CSCE bringing in tandem the contribution not only of Europe but also that of the United States and of the Soviet Union.
A realistic approach for a Mediterranean policy for Europe is to be considered taking into account also of what is American policy for the Mediterranean.
As General Carlo Jean writes "From Washington’s perspective, the Mediterranean represents a vital transit of communication and a staging area to project American power through the greater Middle East and in the Sea of the Caucasus and the Caspian Sea. For the countries of Europe and in particular the southern ones, the Mediterranean is a unitary geo-political and geo-economic region."
These two perspectives have to be, where possible, reconciled if we want to have a realistic Mediterranean policy.
I am delivering this lecture on the 11th of September, the first anniversary of a tragedy, which marked for the American nation, its full first hard awareness of terrorism. The civilized world’s solidarity with the United States a year ago, reflected the world’s rejection of terrorism as an instrument of politics.
We are still waiting to see how the war against terrorism will fully evolve. Events in the Mediterranean may see two policies unfold, one European and the other American.
The closest holistic approach so far made by Europe towards the Mediterranean is through the Barcelona Process. The three pillars of this process, political and security, economy, and social and cultural, were intended to create a partnership between the European Union and the Mediterranean States.
But the effectiveness of the Mediterranean partnership has been found wanting. The immediate cause for this lack of effectiveness is the Israeli-Palestinian conflict. We in Europe believe, in the efficacy of resolutions 242 and 338 of the UN Security Council. We in Europe have maintained that there can be no solution to the Middle East process unless there is full recognition of the relevant UN resolutions.
The non-realisation and non-observance of these resolutions are at the core of the conflict. The inalienable rights of the Palestinian people, their right to cease being refugees in their own country, to have a state of their own, free from foreign occupation, cannot be left in abeyance by the international community, in full recognition of Israel’s right to safe and secure frontiers. We are all realizing that it is a mistake to draw parallelism between the will of a people to fight for its freedom against foreign occupation and the terrorist attacks on the Twin Towers. On the other hand terrorism in all its forms, be it terrorism by individuals, be it by organisations or states, has to be condemned, rejected and defeated.
In structuring its Mediterranean policy, Europe is fully aware that the problems of the Palestinian people are being used and misused by some who want to instrumentalize the plight of the Palestinians, for fundamentalist politics making of terrorism a method of subjection.
Whilst Europe and the United States may not share the same Mediterranean perspective, yet there need not be a conflicting Mediterranean policy. It has to be one built on, the logic of persuasion, the correct understanding of the rights of the Palestinian people and their living tragedy, Israel’s right to safe and secure frontiers, the friendship of Arab States, the proper esteem and evaluation of Islam, the isolation of terrorism and fundamentalism, a refinancing of the Barcelona process, a clear policy to avoid the tragedy of economic refugees, the boat people of the Mediterranean, and the need to bring industry and trade to the shores of North Africa. Capitalizing on the idea of using petro-dollars as development aid can add a strong economic impulse to Europe’s Mediterranean policy. There is no reason why this policy need not also be shared both by the United States and the Gulf states.
In Barcelona 1995, in delivering the key note address, in my role as a Minister for Foreign Affairs, I advanced the concept of a Charter for Stability in the Mediterranean. This Charter is under consideration of the Ministerial Meetings. It will eventually prove to be the cornerstone of the Barcelona process.
Javier Solana, in an article on "A Union for Security" writes that "Recent events have underlined the value and importance of long standing dialogue with the Arab and wider Muslim world. The innovative Euro Mediterranean partnership has been a valuable tool in deepening the relationship and in encouraging greater regional co-operation. It provides for cultural, religious and parliamentary contacts across the Mediterranean. But we need to do more if we are to overcome the profound ignorance – and sometimes mistrust in Europe, of the countries on the other side of the Mediterranean."
May I add that we need to do much more.
Ladies and Gentlemen,
Peace and security entail compromise and a degree of objective reasoning.
Peace and security require clear political leadership and commitment.
Peace and security necessitate a fair and just outcome of a Peace Process that charts a clear political track and timetable, not to be held ransom by anyone.
Above all Peace entails a clear vision for a better future.
The challenges of the Mediterranean are great and many. So are the challenges of Europe’s vision for a stable Mediterranean region. The vision of a Euro-Mediterranean space is still to become a living reality for the millions of people who have a stake in seeing it materialize. The basic platform is already in place and will in itself be presented with the challenges of change. Key to the success of this process is our ability to institute a sense of shared ownership of the process. Key to the Euro-Med space will be our ability to see the peoples to the north, south and east of the shores of the Mediterranean share a common understanding of each other’s cultures and values.
Greece is at the centre of this Euro-Med space poised with an understanding of Mediterranean affairs which is its tradition and also having been a member of the European Union for many years can understand and identify that which the Union can do for the Mediterranean. Shortly Greece will be taking up the Presidency of the European Union, a Presidency which I am confident it will serve with honour and tact not least for the interest of moving the agenda of the Mediterranean forward.
I have started this lecture quoting Jean Monnet and his thinking "If I were to start again today, I would not begin with Common Market. I would start with culture." I believe in the value of culture. I think that Universities in particular have a relevant role to play in the Mediterranean context. In the Mediterranean we are living a great contradiction. Few kilometres of sea have created situations where neighbours are strangers, where beliefs are in conflict, where qualities of life are completely different.
We have long maintained that the Mediterranean, if left on its own can be a bomb with an ever-shortening fuse. Some have seen a future based on a conflict of civilization. Many see such conflict realizing itself in our region. I refuse to accept such theories. I even more reject those who make of such theories self-fulfilling prophesies. We cannot give to our children in heritage a conflict of civilizations. We maintain that these civilizations are not in conflict, they are complementary one to the other and in the Mediterranean we can work together through our common interest, our common concerns and our common heritage.
This I believe is the challenge that in the Mediterranean politicians and statesmen, academics and students, workers and traders have to face if we are to build a common future.
* Cardinal Carlo Maria Martini
Other Press Releases:
PR261929
PRESS RELEASE BY THE NATIONAL AUDIT OFFICE National Audit Office Malta hos...
PR261926